This is highly subjective, and there's no right or wrong here, but I find Josy's personality not at all boring. In fact I find her quite refreshing. I'm overly generalizing here but she's not the typical 2-dimensional "girly girl" (Jill, Maya), "mean girl" (Sage, Quinn, Sarah, etc), party girl (Camila, Mona, most of the rest of HOTs), cougar (Jade, Cathy), or frigid (Bella) characters that's common in a lot of adult games. She's probably the only girl in this game who will wear a football jersey or a baseball cap backwards, actually understand the game and is a fan, have a favourite team, and cheer and shout at a grand stand with you, while still being so cute that other guys at the game will give you the "you lucky s-o-b" nod.