I understood what you meant, but what I was saying was that even that doesn't feel like it is the right way to go. For me, it should have been the case that these "3 lovers" all leave as friends if either the MC chooses that or he has DIK affinity, and that even the latter should be the MC's choice.
A DIK affinity MC who automatically chooses friendship that both girls accept would make more sense than the girls rejecting him because of this arbitrary game mechanic, especially for those players on that path who did everything with M&J. So instead of 3 options - relationship, friendship, or rejection - there should just have been the options of relationship/friendship for the Neutral and CHICK paths, and friendship for the DIK path.