Disagree. Season 2 got worse as it went along. By episode 7, it hit a wall. Now if the metrics you are using is just renders and lewd scenes, then yes season 2 is better, but in terms of story logic and just plain fun, then season 1 is the clear winner. Parties were interesting and fresh, Hell week with your new bros was a damn good adventure, conflicts with the jocks were gratifying, and learning the ropes at B&R was entertaining. And that is not even counting any lewdness. Then the tone shifted in season 2 (and characters started acting...well, out of character). Season 1 had sad drama yes, but season 2 went full bore overkill with it.
For example with ep. 8, if you aren't on Josy's path especially then the entire first act is astonishingly morose. Almost every scene is people crying and moaning about feelings. I know the game needs some of that good old fashioned DPC heaviness, but jesus that was giving me flashbacks to (*shudders*) Acting Lessons style of game. Just a dark, depressing cloud of melancholy. Fortunately, ep. 8 got better later on, but not enough to make it more enjoyable than the general vibe of season 1.
I really hope DPC doesn't go back to his AL ways.
I understood what you mean. You don't like the genre change in the second season. Well, this is subjective and depends on the taste of each individual. In my opinion, a change in the plot direction is necessary and important. Look, the first season was a lot of fun - an American Pie-type comedy. Hell week, pranks, laughter. If things continued like this, we'd end up with endless American Pie sequels and it's... boring. Several seasons are the same, like chewing the same gum many times. Have you heard that the last parts of American Pie were successful? Exactly. People remember the first part the most, which is gold.
The drama and melancholy in the second season brings the characters to life. Maya, Jill, Sage... - I haven't empathized with a game NPC in a long time. This gave the project a fresh breath, allowed to look from the other side. That in addition to wild fun, there is also a dark side. A change of scenery is important for such a big project. The creator did not forget about the fun, it is worth remembering the sabotage in the snob house, Tybalt's cock, the fun in the nursing home, for example. A perfect balance between drama and comedy and I gave the second season a well-deserved 10/10.
This is not Acting Lessons, the dev has mentioned this many times. Don't worry, the college won't burn down at the end of the game. But the consequences of the decisions taken will be, otherwise the DPC would not be itself. In my opinion, the consequences are important for the creation of a living world, if you do not want to get Fallout 4 or ME Andromeda in the end. Because we are playing an RPG game. And that insanely cool cliffhanger at the end keeps you looking forward to Episode 9. The return of Zoya is a very good plot twist that will bring freshness to the project. How it sparked discussion: People are arguing hundreds of comments about the need to add her to the story. I am very interested in how the drama will develop in this triangle between MC, the girl you chose (if you chose) and Zoe. In any case, I will reserve a separate walkthrough for her.
That's was my point of view. Speaking for others, for the gaming community - as I said, the second season received 96% in Steam. The vast majority believe that the second season is not worse than the first.