felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,549
22,422
with Jacob, I'm not sure if he knew Sage was a Burke or if he just wanted to warn the MC because Sage was Chad's girlfriend. And we know Jacob is afraid of the Jocks. That's why I didn't include Jacob.:unsure:
Jacob does not refer only to Chad

jac "Man...you're fucking crazy."
jac "This isn't the CUM-petition anymore, you know that?"
jac "If you fuck her on that couch, everyone at this party will talk about that tomorrow."
jac "For one, it {b}will{/b} reach Chad before sunrise."
jac "And secondly, it will reach-"


and he stopped there
 

AchedCroissant

Conversation Conqueror
May 29, 2020
6,099
27,946
I loves ya, but no. Zoey is the Ex. I think DPC is fully Team Josy, but he doesn't like to close off certain past choices, just like how the ex reappeared in AL.
Calling her ex is totally wrong, She is the only character out of many who have tattoos that has a pink cake tattoo, Totally inspired by one of his favorite games, as much as it hurts some, she is the best written character in the entire game that even puts those FMC characters from other games to shame, he sent her to one of the favorite places where DPC traveled in the past he mentioned it in one of his patreon posts

DPC will clearly make her one of the most important characters in future episodes If Maya's problem is solved soon, who do you think will be the axis that will occupy that position in the new arc?
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
Calling her ex is totally wrong, She is the only character out of many who have tattoos that has a pink cake tattoo, Totally inspired by one of his favorite games, as much as it hurts some, she is the best written character in the entire game that even puts those FMC characters from other games to shame, he sent her to one of the favorite places where DPC traveled in the past he mentioned it in one of his patreon posts

DPC will clearly make her one of the most important characters in future episodes If Maya's problem is solved soon, who do you think will be the axis that will occupy that position in the new arc?
I also assume that Zoey will have an important role in BaDIK. We see in the Interlude that Zoey and the MC have a positive influence on each other. Even if the two remain just friends, it will become that way again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Redd23

Lostanddamned

Engaged Member
Mar 29, 2019
2,850
18,425
1) You should stop lying. I never said or wrote that (You're like "Luis is Wendy's father because he wears the color white" and you expect people to believe you.).:rolleyes:
Your red stapler/white pants/red pants theory from like last year which ended up with Josy as Jill's sister/niece (don't remember exactly). Completely pulled out of your ass but you know, typing bunch of unrelated stuff and trying to push it as a legit theory. :WaitWhat:

2) To you your theory may seem logical, but has very weak and little evidence.:rolleyes:
Dude I'm not trying to make anyone buy into it. You reply to me for no fucking reason, I didn't see your name anywhere in my theory, nor did I tag you, but you somehow get involved in it. What are you, Jill Royce? :unsure:

3) Again for you to read. This is a proof with facts from the game that makes your theory absurd.:p
What does Jill has to do with Bella's mental breakdown again? The theory is Bella's hallucination of James. You're putting words in people's mouths again so that you can show yourself right for whatever reason.
 
Apr 10, 2022
125
336
I don't recall this scene. Is this a throuple exclusive, or something else?
Having sex with Josy in the beginning of the game will make her comment during Tybalt's presentation, which Jill notices. You must also have stayed with Sage to trigger a scene where Jill talks to Josy in the bathroom after the presentation.
 
Last edited:

BigBlueDude

Member
Nov 15, 2020
212
702
I have to disagree. The problem with Zoey running out of money has nothing to do with materialism, it's that it undermines the arc the Interlude was (presumably) supposed to be about. While the Interlude doesn't show the passage of time clearly, we know at least 6 months passed between when Zoey confronted Emma and when she returned home. In all that time, she never reached out to the MC. It's all well and good to say she learned not to take home for granted, but what actually happened is that she continued to stay in San Diego with her 3-4 friends until she could no longer afford to remain. The alleged revelation didn't have much effect.

Now sure, it's possible to claim the timing is a coincidence and she just needed a while to sort out her feelings; she'd have spent time weighting tables (or something) before returning home if she'd had a little less money. But there's nothing in the game itself that really suggests that. The far more likely explanation is that Zoey is still in denial about her feelings and is only returning because she has no viable alternative. Which means she's still in the same headspace she was when she left the MC, which in turn means the Interlude was a complete waste of time.

IMHO, that's just bad writing. A much better way to handle it would be to have Zoey choose to leave San Diego before she runs out of money. She doesn't need to have a large sum left or anything, the point isn't the amount. The point is that in this scenario, we see that Zoey really was changed by the revelation. She's able to accept her feelings, face her own shortcomings, and proactively reach for new goals. In other words, we'd see that Zoey has matured after her time in San Diego, just like the MC has matured while at B&R. That would put her in a much better position to serve as a romantic foil. I'm still not keen on that idea, but if we're going to do it we may as well do it right.
What a glutton for punishment you are if you think its good to reconnect that early with someone after ending a relationship with them. :p And you know you wont be seeing each other since youre moving far away and starting essentially a new life. Its an honest and genuine portrayal for Zoey to stay away, to me shes trying to do the "right" thing and move on. It takes time to settle feelings and emotions for what she went through.

As to how you can suggest that shes in the same headspace after mourning and ending a friendship and moving and starting a new life and chasing a dream, is very upsetting honestly.

Quitting a dream before doing everything you could to realise it would be even worse writing imo, then she would have been wishywashy and fickle. Every person i know or have read about who have chased something of importance never would have given up like that, what it takes for someone to shift focus before every avenue is spent is something major like love, children, trauma and death. Zoey doesnt have have love at that point she is missing it and doesn't even know how much.

You claim that the amount of money doesnt matter, yet you contradict yourself when there have to be money left. I wish to know why that matters for you and why that makes her character worse. I could understand your reservations if her goal was money but nothing have shown thats her motivation (besides basic needs). Somethings not right here. It really looks like youre judging her for something she is not.
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
Your red stapler/white pants/red pants theory from like last year which ended up with Josy as Jill's sister/niece (don't remember exactly). Completely pulled out of your ass but you know, typing bunch of unrelated stuff and trying to push it as a legit theory. :WaitWhat:
But this has nothing to do with Wendy and Luis.:rolleyes:

Dude I'm not trying to make anyone buy into it. You reply to me for no fucking reason, I didn't see your name anywhere in my theory, nor did I tag you, but you somehow get involved in it. What are you, Jill Royce? :unsure:
I didn't know I wasn't allowed to reply to a post that contained a theory that I think is wrong. Interesting and presumptuous.:eek:

What does Jill has to do with Bella's mental breakdown again? The theory is Bella's hallucination of James. You're putting words in people's mouths again so that you can show yourself right for whatever reason.
Don't you see? I even provided possible evidence that James may have died just before the flashback of EP5. The flashback of EP8 is before the flashback of EP5 in terms of time. In the screenshot, we see Jill, who could be worried about a grieving Isabella. Since EP8's flashback is further in the past of the timeline, it shows a living James. It's that simple.:rolleyes:

screenshot0001.png
 

BigBlueDude

Member
Nov 15, 2020
212
702
Bella and Jill bonded over something and became friends. High odds that its "death of a loved one" since thats what messed Jill up to some degree (her sister is dead).

To me personally the order of likelyhood starts with
  • dead husband
  • dead child
  • even money on everything else.
The first one fits the most but could be a red herring.
 

BigBlueDude

Member
Nov 15, 2020
212
702
But this has nothing to do with Wendy and Luis.:rolleyes:



I didn't know I wasn't allowed to reply to a post that contained a theory that I think is wrong. Interesting and presumptuous.:eek:



Don't you see? I even provided possible evidence that James may have died just before the flashback of EP5. The flashback of EP8 is before the flashback of EP5 in terms of time. In the screenshot, we see Jill, who could be worried about a grieving Isabella. Since EP8's flashback is further in the past of the timeline, it shows a living James. It's that simple.:rolleyes:

View attachment 1864926
You know what, i had never really thought about it until now. My assumption and bias was that Bella consoled Jill as the older and maturer person. It could very well be that Bellas loss is more recent than Jills and its a more mutual friendship than that of an older mentor and young mentee. The amount of time both have had with their respective loss matters a lot actually if it is a death.
 

Vixen ♀

Member
Dec 23, 2021
187
2,303
How many times y'all replaying the game so far? :HideThePain:
Doing third time this round, I kinda wish there would be canon choice ya know, to enjoy something after story to each chapter and see how it turned out outcome eventually.
 

StultusAnglicus

Member
Donor
Jan 6, 2019
119
1,497
Bella and Jill bonded over something and became friends. High odds that its "death of a loved one"
  • dead child
Ohhhh coming in left field we have a new theory, James was supposed to be watching their kid but wasnt paying attention and the child drowned in the pool (she has been there for 10 years...) it caused horrible friction in their relationship and James left - Ergo the 'I forgive you' bit from Bella ;)
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes