I think the reason Jill and Maya get the most hate is they fall into overused tropes Jill is the virgin goblin princess and Maya is the lesbian waiting for the right dick. Quinn also as the same problem as the bad girl with a vulnerable side, however she gets less hate as her storyline is more interesting.
I don't think that's really it. Almost every character is built from a stereotype in this game, it's an easy way to fast track character building, but each character has evolved from these base stereotypes.
Maya's not a bad person, but she has some characteristics that some people find too annoying:
- She makes everything into a drama.
- She's often self obsessed to the detriment of her friends (Josy often feels hurt by her).
- She is a hypocrite (she admitted to it).
- She's got dodgy skin (ew).
- She expects others to solve her problems.
- She's looking for the easy way out.
- She misled the mc about her relationship situation.
Just being a drama queen is enough to put people off. Personally I don't think her mistaking her sexual identity as a lesbian as a significant reason why people don't care about her.
Jill is a different story. She actually comes across as a lovely person, but she also has flaws:
- She's stubborn, admittedly so.
- She decides she knows what's best for people and goes over their heads to resolve things.
- She's naïve as fuck but still thinks she knows stuff
- Her naivety sometimes borders on stupidity.
- She has a horrible looking face at times (but angelic at other times)
- Her public dumping of the mc (who didn't deserve the public humiliation, unlike Tybalt), has cost her some serious points.
I don't think her being a virgin has particularly made anyone not like her. Although we suspected it for a long time, she only recently confirmed to the mc that it was true, and we've solved that now.
And with Quinn, there are definitely people who dislike her, and not because of the stereotype, but because of exactly who she is:
- A drug dealer
- A pimp
- A cunt
But yeah, she has her fans because she's interesting, and it's fun to break her.
But anyway all these traits make these girls all the more human. Each main girl, and even a lot of the side characters, are more than just clichés, they have their own stories, their own issues, their good points and bad points. It's the fact that they aren't just simple stereotypes that makes them more confronting for some players.
A lot of these AVNs play to stereotypes, but they don't delve deeper. The bad girl says mean shit until she's tastes the mc's cock and suddenly she's putty in his hands, she doesn't continue to make mistakes and fuck her own life up. The girl next door is just sugar and spice and all things that want to make you throw up. You never get an insight into how she feels (other than how she feels about the mc's cock). The MILF teacher exists just to have a relationship with the mc, we don't know or care about her life. And so on. The characters exist to serve the mc. Once you've won them over, they all devolve into an empty shell.
That's one of the best things about BaDIK, each character has their own agency (not excessively though, this is still the mc's story), and they fuck up, just like real people. They don't exist
for the mc, they exist
with him, and you get to weigh up whether you like them or not. And even if they do fall for the mc, they still continue to exist for themselves too.
My personal preference (since I haven't seen listings for a while):
- Quinn: Even if she isn't an official mail LI, she's my favourite. It's not that I actually like her personality, but I enjoy the story with her the most. Watching her falling for the mc, breaking down her barriers and her behaving counter to her typical self, it's definitely enjoyable.
- Sage: She seems like the most fun person of all the characters. Early scenes with her were the best, having suffered through a breakup has had her down for a while, and I'm not loving how desperate she became for the mc once the breakup was official, so hopefully episode 9 puts things better with her. But is she a DIK or a Chick kinda girl?
- Josy: Unfortunately for Josy, she hasn't really managed to escape the shallow "girl next door" stereotype yet, she's the least developed of all the LIs, but I still find her to be pretty cool. If there ends up being a solo route with her, and she gets more exposure, she could jump up in my rankings. We do know a lot of things about her, but it'd be nice to know more. Oh, and she's very cute.
- Jill: I don't mind any of Jill's faults really, just didn't like the way she dumped the mc at the restaurant, she could have been more subtle and done it in private. Her being a virgin was handled well enough, her self consciousness was handled OK, and she over came that which is good. Hopefully she becomes a little more active in the sack, but for a first time she did well.
- Maya: I honestly find her kinda boring, there are some fun scenes with her, but mostly she's caught up in her own bullshit.
- Bella: She's the one LI I don't really give a shit about. I've played her route for completion purposes, but ultimately I find her to be insufferably unpleasant, and if I was the mc I would never have bothered to get to know her. Sure once you get past the Ice Queen exterior she's a caring person, but the age discrepancy between them is too much for me, and the authority dynamic (she usually acts superior to him) is not to my taste.
