maxthruster
Active Member
- Oct 4, 2025
- 680
- 1,678
- 143
I've seen this thrown around a lot before, and while I generally agree that Riona getting kidnapped and beaten for Quinn's scheme and then just let go is a pretty stupid plot point, I don't think the actual events in question are all that far-fetched. Keep in mind that in a gang it is the distributor, not the dealer, who determines prices; Quinn and Vinny silently raising theirs for their own profit is an act of insubordination, and thus doing nothing about it makes Buddy look weak. Physical violence is a very common form of retaliation used to instill fear and respect. And Riona is clearly important, mechanically if not emotionally, to Quinn, so using her to lure Quinn in makes sense.The fact that she was beaten is a stupid plot point. The dealer simply beat up his runner, even though she confessed everything right away. Having beaten her, she obviously wouldn't be able to continue working for a while, and as a result, she'll lose the money she earned from the sale. And all this because Quinn was selling at a higher price. It's nonsense.
Where it breaks down, for me, is the aftermath. If the goal was to make an example to show what happens when you step outside, giving Quinn herself a beating would've been the move. After all, that's what he did with Vinny. It could be that he was held back by some sentimentality for Rox, but Buddy states repeatedly that he doesn't even want Quinn around and that Rox is the only reason he took her in, so that seems unlikely. More affection from him could've changed that narrative, giving a reasonable excuse for letting her off.
If the goal was to strike at Quinn personally by targeting her friend, trying to break her down inside, then why the fuck would you let her go? Keep her hostage until you're sure Quinn is obedient and dancing to your tune, no matter how reluctantly. Because if you don't have any remaining leverage over her, what's to stop her from, oh I don't know, dropping a dime and bringing a raid down on you?
Tl;dr the price issue is a legitimate concern for Buddy, even though plenty of people don't seem to grasp that, but the way they treated Riona was a weird middle ground that shouldn't have happened.