That questionable for me if you watch tMax and Alice exchange on the patio the next day after the first time. I guess the scenario is subject to interpretation but for me she seems well aware of what she does when she's drunk. Even during the bathroom she is fully able to draw the line in the early scenes.
Mostly. In the beginning I think you will catch Ann and Eric at least once, but that's hardly NTR, since Ann is not Max' girlfriend.
I never claimed that the story telling is consistent ^^
Yeah my thoughts are she's faking it which mixes up a bit of the story. But I accept I can be completely misinterpreting the scene.
Bedroom, I think that was necessary to trigger something. If not, all the better.
The sofa scene is relevant for a couple of scenes, if you interrupt them and call Ann out for doing it on the sofa instead of her room, then he can go to Lisa and tell her that Ann wanted her for something, tricking her onto seeing what was going on.
Yes, but it has no effect. It's not necessary to progress in any opportunity. You can decide not to do it and everything will play out exactly the same way. You can still kick Eric out, you can progress with Lisa, there will be no change.
Depends on your perspective I guess. They're on the couch making out at that time on certain nights and they're also in Mom's room doing even more. Presumably they would still be doing that whether you actually saw them or not. So IMO you're not really avoiding it, just sticking your head in the sand. It still happens either way.
The question was not if it could be prevented that that other people have sex, but if NTR was avoidable. Sure, NTR means to lose a loved one (which Ann at this point isn't) to someone else, it means that the protagonist watches them and suffers. People usually ignore that point about the 'loved one'. But all interpretations of the term have in common that the protagonist actually has to catch the other couple. So if he doesn't, it's not ntr.
If that's the case then I can see why there's so much arguing about NTR. That's a pretty meaningless distinction to most people I would think. The only way to avoid "catching them" is to intentionally avoid going there when they're doing it, which means you know it's happening or you wouldn't know to avoid it and you'd be bound to eventually stumble upon the scene at random.
Well, if someone asks about ntr, I answer about NTR and not about something he didn's ask for.
Not possible. She is completely under his spell. You need to get rid of him if you want her (back).
