No you are not wrong...BDSM also usually entails the person getting spanked actually liking it (like Lisa did) and them actually being the ones in control...I agree with everyone saying that DS doesn't know how to write an incest game, but I also think that he doesn't have a clue about BDSM either. We've yet to see any good BDSM being played out. So far all it's been so far is;
Alice/Kate: "I'm in control."
Max: "Okay"
That's barely even submission. And how on Earth does a sub magically turn into a dom, then straight back to a sub?
Also, from what we've seen from mum, there's no real BDSM in play. From what we seen in the movie all she gets is a light spanking with a ruler. I don't know about you, but when I think about BDSM I think of leather, being chained up, whips, torture, pretty much ZERO fucking etc. Am I wrong?
So perhaps he doesn't get BDSM either for people who are REALLY into that fetish! LOL
It really was just used as a mechanism to get Max to control because he couldn't think of any other way anyone would fuck him in this game.
I suspect he makes the scenes and then throws whatever awful text he thinks will fit that scene with some lame text thrown in elsewhere to get to it.I wonder if DS even reads what he writes as a story sometimes. Like how does it even make sense ?