Well, that also covers Tommy and Amber. Amber chose the school with the expectation that the BS wouldn't be there, and Tommy was shocked as well. At the very least there was an expectation that all of the MCs crew had that the girls would not be here. Even if the MC was wrong, and they always planned to come to this college, then the questions changes slightly, but is still a question. Why did they decide to go to this particular school instead of all going to Harvard or whatever since they all had the grades and money to do so.In my playthough, this was the impression I got(and I don't do impressions, so bear with me here):
• Montecita was more of a last chance/final option for the MC to attend college because if his poor grades/lack of scholarships.
• The MC assumed that Kate and her friends were attending other, more prestigious schools 'in the east' due to their grades/money. etc.
I'm not saying that you're wrong about the point you made; just wondering if I missed something or it this is another thing that the dev might have left unclear.
Thought I will agree that clarity is a major issue as the game goes on. The opening doesn't really jive with the rest of the game, Annie's backstory timing seems incompatible for example. There are tons of questions that pile up with very few answers.