4.80 star(s) 84 Votes

Deleted member 4771842

Active Member
Mar 24, 2022
546
1,415
Don't be too rude to me please, I'm just spitting out crazy theories and trying to see if they can be completely refuted. Perceive this as a game please :3
(Is it me or it's giving vibes from Ace Attorney?)
 

Gterus

Newbie
Nov 24, 2018
28
36
Why does people in the YouTube comment sections(Years Ago 2020 or something) say that don't use F95 version?
If I recall correctly, the previous f95 version works just fine and also translated DLC3, albeit with slight translation errors. The official version has the better translation, and some of the music were changed due to copyright (mostly boss themes).
 

Phenir

Well-Known Member
Sep 28, 2019
1,944
1,250
Developer could unset flags by "resetting" the world, meaning that he'd add a script in the end of endings C and D that he already left for you to activate in the Holy Forest, but he didn't do it for your own convenience.
And your theory maybe correct too, though even if you reset flags by going into "another loop", you can't reset everything completely, you'll always be greeted by Leaf, knowing that you "looped".
So, it can be a combination of solutions for developer's convenience and user's convenience too, but it doesn't make my theory any less reasonable.
Ending C weakened Leaf and after ending D Grimm couldn't continue looping, unless Grimm was a part of Leaf's Dream (not just garden), that just slowly losing stability after TCO's attack and eventually crumbled completely.

I'll explain this prototype of a theory in a rough image. Different layers of existence:
View attachment 3244159
Anyway, I don't see everything I said before any less reasonable.
You're really missing the point that C end was completely planned by Mary Sue. She intended you to collect the fairy tales, pull the lever, and defeat her. It's all a show. Why would she risk her own garden in the process? Not to mention crawling one can be seen to have infiltrated before doing C end so it didn't really need any help in that regard.
Image: Azathoth's dream encompasses everything. BS 2 takes place in crawling ones garden mostly. The main reason there are so many outer ones running around in that game is to be able to mate with Grimm. As in to make children. Little difficult to do that in a dream. BS 1 takes place in Mary Sue's garden. See: chaos dungeon library.
There are 3 DLC in this version. For most people it's final version, but somewhere also Chinese, 4th DLC exists if I'm not mistaken.
You are mistaken. That's a fangame.
If I recall correctly, the previous f95 version works just fine and also translated DLC3, albeit with slight translation errors. The official version has the better translation, and some of the music were changed due to copyright (mostly boss themes).
Afaik, the fan translation does not cover dlc 3 at all.
The version here does not have the changed music.
 

Gterus

Newbie
Nov 24, 2018
28
36
Afaik, the fan translation does not cover dlc 3 at all.
The version here does not have the changed music.
So to clarify, the version here is the official version, but not the updated one with changed music?
 

Omnom88

Member
Dec 26, 2021
297
156
There are 3 DLC in this version. For most people it's final version, but somewhere also Chinese, 4th DLC exists if I'm not mistaken.
Huh? This is the first time i heard about a 4th DLC. DLC1-3 add Chaos Dungeon, Deep Sea & Winterbell/H end.
Unless people think the fan mod Toro partially helped out with is "official".

Why does people in the YouTube comment sections(Years Ago 2020 or something) say that don't use F95 version?
As sammo said both versions should be fine. The main differences are just the references to cosmic-horror/fairy tales book.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
You are going cu-cu-cu-crazy. Instead you should go to Alice!

No seriously. Reminder that BS1 is Toro`s second game. Also keep in mind Toros "age" at that time. Sometimes Alice is the madness we developed along the way & there is no deeper meaning to it.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: p23rklo

Deleted member 4771842

Active Member
Mar 24, 2022
546
1,415
You're really missing the point that C end was completely planned by Mary Sue. She intended you to collect the fairy tales, pull the lever, and defeat her. It's all a show. Why would she risk her own garden in the process? Not to mention crawling one can be seen to have infiltrated before doing C end so it didn't really need any help in that regard.
You are missing a few points as well.
1) Ending D is intended for players who got every other ending, meaning that players are strong enough to visit Sabbath Forest and Black Trial, the hardest locations in the game.
2) Getting ending C after getting ending D makes no sense, since after ending D Mary Sue is being almost killed and saved by Node after. Grimm can't "loop" nor do anything anymore. And in this case your logic has problems, since if nothing happened after ending C then it did nothing influential. Same with D end then, nothing happened right?
3) Both endings can be achieved once in one "loop"

Azathoth's dream encompasses everything.
I see, then move Azathoth's body and Dream beyond Cosmos and everything will make sense then, I guess.

BS 2 takes place in crawling ones garden mostly. The main reason there are so many outer ones running around in that game is to be able to mate with Grimm. As in to make children. Little difficult to do that in a dream. BS 1 takes place in Mary Sue's garden. See: chaos dungeon library.
Since Mary's Garden didn't crumble immediately after ending D in BS1 I just tried to justify it as a Dream (Mary's) inside a Dream (Azathoth's). But I guess it's just for developer's convenience.

You are mistaken. That's a fangame.
I see, my bad. Thanks for clarification.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 4771842

Active Member
Mar 24, 2022
546
1,415
You are going cu-cu-cu-crazy. Instead you should go to Alice!

No seriously. Reminder that BS1 is Toro`s second game. Also keep in mind Toros "age" at that time. Sometimes Alice is the madness we developed along the way & there is no deeper meaning to it.
1) Grimm/Carroll doesn't want real Alice Liddell, but the one he remembers in the past and wrote a book about: Alice's Adventure Underground or Alice in Wonderland. Or should I say that Grimm okay with TCO since he never knew little Alice, but Carroll did.
2) The Alice Grimm/Carroll met first in a Dream was TCO.
3) The Alice Carroll wanted was probably a doll, Alice-02, since she drops her fairy tale if you kill her, but it's just my theory.
4) (potentially Mabel) because "This world doesn't need two of the same girl", but Node saved her. Now Alice exists and not exists like a Cheshire Cat, while . Though it's just my crazy theory.

Who was a Cheshire Cat in Alice in Wonderland? It was Carroll, the avatar of the creator of the story.
And Cheshire tells you in this game " ", she could tell about herself in a second or third person. It can all be a dream of Alice...

But that sounds too crazy since there are inconsistences I guess.
 
Last edited:

Tachanka0203

Newbie
Oct 24, 2022
92
42
Ill ask again. Does anyone have a 100% + DLC save they are willing to share or do i have to put countless ours into the game again? :HideThePain:
 

Omnom88

Member
Dec 26, 2021
297
156
1) Grimm/Carroll doesn't want real Alice Liddell, but the one he remembers in the past and wrote a book about: Alice's Adventure Underground or Alice in Wonderland. Or should I say that Grimm okay with TCO since he never knew little Alice, but Carroll did.
2) The Alice Grimm/Carroll met first in a Dream was TCO.
3) The Alice Carroll wanted was probably a doll, Alice-02, since she drops her fairy tale if you kill her, but it's just my theory.
4) (potentially Mabel) because "This world doesn't need two of the same girl", but Node saved her. Now Alice exists and not exists like a Cheshire Cat, while . Though it's just my crazy theory.

Who was a Cheshire Cat in Alice in Wonderland? It was Carroll, the avatar of the creator of the story.
And Cheshire tells you in this game " ", she could tell about herself in a second or third person. It can all be a dream of Alice...

But that sounds too crazy since there are inconsistences I guess.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Phenir

Well-Known Member
Sep 28, 2019
1,944
1,250
You are missing a few points as well.
1) Ending D is intended for players who got every other ending, meaning that players are strong enough to visit Sabbath Forest and Black Trial, the hardest locations in the game.
2) Getting ending C after getting ending D makes no sense, since after ending D Mary Sue is being almost killed and saved by Node after. Grimm can't "loop" nor do anything anymore. And in this case your logic has problems, since if nothing happened after ending C then it did nothing influential. Same with D end then, nothing happened right?
3) Both endings can be achieved once in one "loop"
1: Yes, I never said otherwise. I believe ending D is the intended final ending considering it sets up the story of BS 2. However, getting D end (technically achieving the requirements for D end) also affects C end so there is an intragame reason to do C end last.
2: I didn't say nothing happened after ending C, I said it didn't matter (because of the loop mechanic). This is based off how it works in BS 2, where after every ending, canonically, everything gets reset. Essentially, whether ending C happens or not does not matter (but it most likely did happen given how pissed Grimm and everyone else is when they meet Mary Sue in 2). Additionally, most likely Grimm did loop after ending C, before D end, because of the 0 sen scene in hotel in 2. Grimm remembers using the hotel but Red Hood says he never actually used it. So either Grimm looped after reaching C end, resetting everyone including red hood, or he just had memories implanted in him or something. I am more inclined to believe the former happened since looping is an in universe mechanic. Basically, you need to separate looping as a game mechanic and looping as an in-universe mechanic. It's likely that Grimm is forced to loop after each ending, but the player is allowed to play after an ending purely for their convenience. Anything the player does after achieving an ending, including getting other endings, is non canon.
3: This is meaningless in respect to C end affecting/causing D end. Your logic implies that Grimm can only get D end after C end due to the effect of C end presumably affecting the stability of Mary Sue's garden. But Grimm can loop (which again is not merely a game mechanic, and most likely did happen as I said just before), resetting everything which would presumably also fix any instability, assuming C end even caused said instability to begin with. Which goes back to my point, you need to answer why Mary Sue would need to risk that instability in an ending she designed. If she created a world just for this ending, as shown in her individual ending (the one reached by touching the fog at Cinderella), why would achieving that ending suddenly make her garden vulnerable to destruction? Mary Sue is an asshole but not suicidal. Why was this instability necessary for D end when crawling one had been shown to have already infiltrated (and the more likely cause being Baphomet acting outside her role with Grimm's help)?
4) (potentially Mabel) because "This world doesn't need two of the same girl", but Node saved her. Now Alice exists and not exists like a Cheshire Cat, while . Though it's just my crazy theory.
Someone already pointed out that book is likely referring to Mary Sue killing her twin. This is supported by Jabberwock's dialogue just prior to entering the door to H route (she mentions taking care of some twins) and at the start of her solo battle in G route (in which she says she is the one who first gave Mary Sue fairy tales when she was a "child"). Finally, Mabel is ridiculously powerful. You really think a being that can encapsulate multiple powerful outer ones in their garden is gonna be killed by one that can barely handle one?
 

Deleted member 4771842

Active Member
Mar 24, 2022
546
1,415
1 & 2. I have no idear what the context for this is.
What is the point in looking for Alice? Alice Liddell did everything she could with a help of TCO to make Carroll forget real Alice and let his dream come true. If only Mary Sue and other Outer Ones didn't intervene... *sigh*

3. Carroll`s original wish was to be with the little girl again. Because he rejected the reality he saw at the party as in a grown up Alice Lidell. However he was also tortured before he was combined with all the fairy tale author`s into the black soul/Grimm.
So quite literally Carroll`s desires are even more insane/unhinged. With the only real conclusion Alice & Carroll have in G/white space scene. Carroll is just used as a driving factor/motivation for Grimm to make children with "Alice".
I meant that the Alice he truly wants was Alice-02, since she drops a fairy tale. But of course he can be easily manipulated into copulating with anything that looks and smells like Alice. If he was blind, perhaps he'd also have sex with a humming lady, since it's most probably mature version of Alice Liddell. Her drops are Girl's Photo and Girl's Scent.

4. The books are all most likely related to Mary Sue & what happend between the timeframe of BS1 & BS2. This connects with Jabberwock being a babysitter for Mary Sue. Plus the implications that Mary Sue had a twin which relates back to Nug & Yeb twins from Baphomet.
The reason why the Library was placed inside the Chaos Dungeon. Due the secret rebellion. As Mabel, Prickett & Node work together to free Grimm.
So all the information in there is laid out by Mabel for Grimm to find & understand the current world.
At least most of them the books related to Mary Sue or her family, my bad. Then Baphomet tried to kill Mary Sue because she didn't need two of the same girl?

I am not sure why you think that way about Chesire Cat.

Based on ingame lore.
Dinah aka Chesire Cat. Role in the story & her motivation. Trying to protect Alice in her own way & is doing her best to mislead Grimm so he wont find "Alice".
True identity/material being the pet cat of the Lidell family & managed get a role inside Wonderland like majority of the other actors. Made either a wish/contract with a outer god. Or was used as material by Outer Ones aka kidnapped from earth etc.

Main references one of the space cats of Lovecrafts books. The green cats of Venus or the space cat-pirates Carter(Lovecrafts self insert) encounters on his journey in outer space.
Sidenote:Funny enough that could also mean Mabel was the one who gave Dinah the oppurtunity to act in Wonderland. Because Carter in the story is a Silver Key(Avatar) of Yog. But that connection is far fetched due book knowledge & not really supported by ingame lore.

My guess Dinah most likely due her artwork visuals being a venus cat + dialog lines= she is housing the soul of Lidells house cat..
But if we are talking about Alice in Wonderland, Cheshire Cat is the author's avatar. I can only guess too what Toro choose in his own game, though I won't say that I'm 100% correct. Sometimes truth is much simpler than we may think.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 4771842

Active Member
Mar 24, 2022
546
1,415
2. However, getting D end (technically achieving the requirements for D end) also affects C end so there is an intragame reason to do C end last.
How does it affects ending C?

2: I didn't say nothing happened after ending C, I said it didn't matter (because of the loop mechanic). This is based off how it works in BS 2, where after every ending, canonically, everything gets reset. Essentially, whether ending C happens or not does not matter (but it most likely did happen given how pissed Grimm and everyone else is when they meet Mary Sue in 2). Additionally, most likely Grimm did loop after ending C, before D end, because of the 0 sen scene in hotel in 2. Grimm remembers using the hotel but Red Hood says he never actually used it. So either Grimm looped after reaching C end, resetting everyone including red hood, or he just had memories implanted in him or something. I am more inclined to believe the former happened since looping is an in universe mechanic. Basically, you need to separate looping as a game mechanic and looping as an in-universe mechanic. It's likely that Grimm is forced to loop after each ending, but the player is allowed to play after an ending purely for their convenience. Anything the player does after achieving an ending, including getting other endings, is non canon.
Mostly agree but Grimm is not forced to "loop" but potentially choose himself to "loop", though "looping" perhaps isn't what you actually expect it to be, it's perhaps more like a "time travel", but I can be wrong.
Also consider memories of Grimm/Carroll and Red Hood being rewritten for the sake of manipulating them or saving their minds. Unless everything what happened in BS1 was just Mary's Dream, which Grimm was a part of?

3: This is meaningless in respect to C end affecting/causing D end. Your logic implies that Grimm can only get D end after C end due to the effect of C end presumably affecting the stability of Mary Sue's garden. But Grimm can loop (which again is not merely a game mechanic, and most likely did happen as I said just before), resetting everything which would presumably also fix any instability, assuming C end even caused said instability to begin with. Which goes back to my point, you need to answer why Mary Sue would need to risk that instability in an ending she designed. If she created a world just for this ending, as shown in her individual ending (the one reached by touching the fog at Cinderella), why would achieving that ending suddenly make her garden vulnerable to destruction? Mary Sue is an asshole but not suicidal. Why was this instability necessary for D end when crawling one had been shown to have already infiltrated (and the more likely cause being Baphomet acting outside her role with Grimm's help)?
In my theory Grimm didn't "loop" after getting C end and tried to achieve D end immediately after C, though he may "looped" after A or B endings. Also I didn't say that everything should reset after Grimm achieved any ending, but Grimm himself choose to loop after A or B endings. Since Grimm didn't achieve what he wanted with C end he decided to finally visit Black Trial. Though it's just a theory.

Someone already pointed out that book is likely referring to Mary Sue killing her twin. This is supported by Jabberwock's dialogue just prior to entering the door to H route (she mentions taking care of some twins) and at the start of her solo battle in G route (in which she says she is the one who first gave Mary Sue fairy tales when she was a "child"). Finally, Mabel is ridiculously powerful. You really think a being that can encapsulate multiple powerful outer ones in their garden is gonna be killed by one that can barely handle one?
I meant that Mabel hated Alice for being the same as her and that words in book related to words of Alice who was killed.
So you say that book refers to the words of Mary's twin? " ".
Sounds quite weak for a daughter of Black Goat...
Those who born from black soul are abominations, born to destroy.
 

Phenir

Well-Known Member
Sep 28, 2019
1,944
1,250
How does it affects ending C?
Miranda talks down Lindamea instead of fighting him by telling him he and Baphomet are just acting like puppets according to Mary Sue's whims.
Mostly agree but Grimm is not forced to "loop" but potentially choose himself to "loop", though "looping" perhaps isn't what you actually expect it to be, it's perhaps more like a "time travel", but I can be wrong.
Also consider memories of Grimm/Carroll and Red Hood being rewritten for the sake of manipulating them or saving their minds. Unless everything what happened in BS1 was just Mary's Dream, which Grimm was a part of?
It's not time travel, in the sense that Grimm is going back to the past, as there are other things that carry over between loops. Node keeps a record of how many loops you have done, Grimm's own memory, red hood missing an arm.
In my theory Grimm didn't "loop" after getting C end and tried to achieve D end immediately after C, though he may "looped" after A or B endings. Also I didn't say that everything should reset after Grimm achieved any ending, but Grimm himself choose to loop after A or B endings. Since Grimm didn't achieve what he wanted with C end he decided to finally visit Black Trial. Though it's just a theory.
I didn't say you said that either. Read what I wrote and not what you want to see.
I meant that Mabel hated Alice for being the same as her and that words in book related to words of Alice who was killed.
So you say that book refers to the words of Mary's twin? " ".
Sounds quite weak for a daughter of Black Goat...
Those who born from black soul are abominations, born to destroy.
But Mabel wouldn't be fine seeing it? That logic (if you can call it that) works both ways.
There's much more support for Mary having a twin than Mabel killing Alice (but being ok with all the other Alices running around?) for some reason.
 

Deleted member 4771842

Active Member
Mar 24, 2022
546
1,415
Miranda talks down Lindamea instead of fighting him by telling him he and Baphomet are just acting like puppets according to Mary Sue's whims.
...
Then ending D makes no sense for me. Mary Sue should have lost her powers after ending D. How Grimm can see her and reset the world? How can he achieve ending C again? Hmm... unless again, Mary's Gardens existed in her own Dream, where Mary Sue and Leaf were just her own avatars. And after ending D her Dream was slowly crumbling. Or is there a better explanation?

It's not time travel, in the sense that Grimm is going back to the past, as there are other things that carry over between loops. Node keeps a record of how many loops you have done, Grimm's own memory, red hood missing an arm.
This is why I can't call it "looping" nor "time travel" since it works very selective. You are not just walking into another layer of the same world like in Chaos Dungeon, nor you are going back in time since at some point Mabel creates a door to the DLC 3. saying "time only goes forward". So, it's just a partial reset, where Grimm, Outers One are not affected, and Red Hood is not affected for some reason (if you ignore her being as good as new until ending H).

I didn't say you said that either. Read what I wrote and not what you want to see.
I don't understand then why you implied that Grimm is forced to "loop" in every ending, since I didn't say that. But nevermind.

But Mabel wouldn't be fine seeing it? That logic (if you can call it that) works both ways.
There's much more support for Mary having a twin than Mabel killing Alice (but being ok with all the other Alices running around?) for some reason.
If that words in book belongs to Alice, what is the problem if Mabel hates her? I know that words "Seeing screaming, bleeding me being dragged into gears and crushed, I averted my eyes." can be perceived as if Mabel seeing Alice being dragged but not necessarily, Alice could talk about herself in a third person. Though I'm not asking you to believe it, I know that it sounds less believable than theory including Mary Sue.
Why she is okay with other "Alices"? She can't kill Outer Ones without consequences, since certain Alice belongs to Jub-Jub, Jabberwock and Bandersnatch, and other ones to The Crawling One.

(I hope your SEN is not going up too much :D)
 
4.80 star(s) 84 Votes