CREATE and FUCK your own AI GIRLFRIEND TRY FOR FREE
x

Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (UPD: 10/18/24!!)

Nov 5, 2022
193
146
*Note: The "wholesome" in the title is NOT sarcasm. This is genuinely a list of vanilla games.


Take a break from all the NTR and Hardcore, wayward traveller.
(i'm still traumatized from accidentally seeing some..)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.


Hey guys! Butter(scotch) here.
If you know me from any of the discord servers I'm in (MDRG, S:C, Headpat Club), you'll know me as the guy ranting ON and ON about how Vanilla is the best and the non-believers shall be destro-... anyways I always wanted to post my wholesome list somewhere without that pesky 2K char limit (curse you discord!).

Recently I found Voltage's list of his favorite games (super good btw, check it out when you can!), and realized that- 'Hey, I have a list too! Maybe I should find somewhere to post it..'

Soo... here's the list. Quick rundown on how it works first though!


(This list isn't based on how much I enjoyed the game, and is instead based on how wholesome I found the game, based on a variety of factors.)


My list is divided into THREE FOUR main categories:

- HIGH TIER -
(que that one angelic choir sound..)
The HOLY GRAIL of wholesome games, I absolutely LOVE these ones. Little to no problems in the wholesomeness department, or they're my personal favs : D
Ex: Teaching Feeling, MDRG
I also have Doujins included in this list, and well, all of them are high tier. SO they'll also be here!


- GOD TIER-
(THE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVERTHE BEST EVER)

Reactionary tier for the 2 most wholesome games on the internet (as of now); also known as my personal favorites. While other games might come close in terms of wholesomeness, these games have elements that take it FAR beyond the boundaries of a normal game.
(usually due to having an amazing & happy ending)



- MID TIER -
While still wholesome by my standards, games in this tier have some issues that prevent them from reaching PEAK wholesomeness. These are often RPG games with a romance mechanic, that might have some.. unsavory parts that can be disabled.
Ex: Lillith's Throne, Dog Princess (and the steele)

Getting riskier..

|- Sub Section: Sex Sims -|
Mostly added for DLotN.
Includes short sex simulators with consensual sex, but little shown relationship or romance; also includes games with no plot.
Unlike the rest of mid tier, these games usually don't have wholesomeness issues- just lackluster romance.
*Marked with an (S)*


- LOW TIER -
:sob:

Well.. this tier only has one game at the moment (since well, it's kind of hard to be in this tier?)
This tier is reserved for a game that's.. technically wholesome? Honestly I only needed this tier for
FAIRY ADDICTION

(dun dun DUNNNN!!)
Maybe this should just be renamed the Fairy addiction tier. That's the only game weird enough to fall into this tier..

- EXTRAS -
Section for wholesome games that aren't on the list for any reason, either because of a tag, or simply because I haven't gotten around to playing them!
Since a lot of people are into tags that I'm not, I added this section to help those people out! Though, they're all unreviewed for obvious reasons..
----



I'm always open to new suggestions on games to play! I love finding new games to recommend, and I would love input on it.
Personal Favorites are marked with a (!!) !


Click on the game name to see the links!

(Also, if you think my list is a bit empty or missing your favorite games..
..I don't play gay/yaoi, lesbian, futa, femboy, or incest games. I'm really sorry D:
** But, I have just added a new section thats ONLY those games! (though, I haven't actually reviewed or played those games for obvious reasons) **


oh my god i can talk FOREVER ABOUT THESE GAMES WITHOUT THE DISCORD LIMIT!!

High Tier
(Paragons of Love and Headpats)

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Mid Tier
(Maybe a little less Love and Headpats?)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Low Tier
(Reserved for the absolute ENIGMA that is Fairy Addiction)
(try not to recommend me these..)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Extra Section
Section for games not on the list for any reason! (either tags I don't like- eg. Yaoi, Yuri, Futa, Shota; or just games i haven't gotten around to!)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Well, thats the end of my list for now! Please feel free to recommend me anything you want (as long as it fits here). I'm always happy to chat and expand my list! Have fun!!

oh wait, before you go if you want to read my about me so you know why I love wholesome stuff, here it is!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

This took me like a whole day to write lol
27K characters..
Update: Also i can link doujins now!!




 
Last edited:
Nov 5, 2022
193
146
update: i added the doujin links!
i love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimarui love danimaru
 
Nov 5, 2022
193
146
now that im active on f95 im only just noticing how many people are into ntr
so casually too..
no kinkshaming though! you do you
its uh
getting slightly more insane the more i look through these threads-
really no filter on some of these people huh?

i must bring them back to the light side..!
or not, it's their choice anyways : pensive:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tecquo
Jan 21, 2022
110
149
I'm honestly pretty sure I don't want to play Fairy Addiction, but my inability to even find the game is making me morbidly curious. Where did you find it?

Also really glad I saw the My Maid Dreams of Electric Sheep because I was considering playing it and even if I can occasionally enjoy rough scenarios, an important part for me is the framing of it and in that one it sounds too vile for me to enjoy personally. Searched up Yui and it seems like there's only the bad end for her at the moment which I really hope is the actual case and not a random person spreading misinformation. Either way I'll definitely push it deep down in the list of games I still need to play.

For Heads Will Roll I'm assuming you mean the first one or whatever it is and not the reforged one right?

Keep up the good work (y)
 
Last edited:

YuKandayo32

Member
Aug 13, 2021
219
235
I played Fairy Addiction in its entirety with all the scat/piss/guro turned off (not my thing) and it's pretty good. just turn those settings off and you'll have a good time

My judgement might be biased tho because I didn't actually play the game completely and havent seen all of the stuff the game has to offer (I refuse to 100% the gallery). With the gore/scat settings off, you'll lose like half of the game's content so take what I say (about the other, wholesome half) with a side of salt
 
Nov 5, 2022
193
146
I'm honestly pretty sure I don't want to play Fairy Addiction, but my inability to even find the game is making me morbidly curious. Where did you find it?

Also really glad I saw the My Maid Dreams of Electric Sheep because I was considering playing it and even if I can occasionally enjoy rough scenarios, an important part for me is the framing of it and in that one it sounds too vile for me to enjoy personally. Searched up Yui and it seems like there's only the bad end for her at the moment which I really hope is the actual case and not a random person spreading misinformation. Either way I'll definitely push it deep down in the list of games I still need to play.

For Heads Will Roll I'm assuming you mean the first one or whatever it is and not the reforged one right?

Keep up the good work (y)
If you search up fairy addiction in japanese (妖精中毒) you SHOULD be taken right to fairy addiction (in japanese forums though)

And yeah, electric sheep is a really wholesome game if you completely ignore what happens to Yui. I've heard that there's going to be a good ending for her eventually, so I'll pick up the game again if it happens
 
  • Like
Reactions: AggressiveCheeto
Nov 5, 2022
193
146
I played Fairy Addiction in its entirety with all the scat/piss/guro turned off (not my thing) and it's pretty good. just turn those settings off and you'll have a good time

My judgement might be biased tho because I didn't actually play the game completely and havent seen all of the stuff the game has to offer (I refuse to 100% the gallery). With the gore/scat settings off, you'll lose like half of the game's content so take what I say (about the other, wholesome half) with a side of salt
Yeah, Fairy addiction IS a really cute game if you turn all the settings off. The ending is cute, dialogue really nice, and the FMC's design is adorable.
It just confuses me on how the same guy who made all the wholesome parts had the heart to have so many unwholesome parts that its a whole gallery page
 

Arxels

New Member
Aug 2, 2024
1
1
The ending for
*Note: The "wholesome" in the title is NOT sarcasm. This is genuinely a list of vanilla games.


Take a break from all the NTR and Hardcore, wayward traveller.
(i'm still traumatized from accidentally seeing some..)
Hey guys! Butter(scotch) here.
If you know me from any of the discord servers I'm in (MDRG, S:C, Headpat Club), you'll know me as the guy ranting ON and ON about how Vanilla is the best and the non-believers shall be destro-... anyways I always wanted to post my wholesome list somewhere without that pesky 2K char limit (curse you discord!).

Recently I found Voltage's list of his favorite games (super good btw, check it out when you can!), and realized that- 'Hey, I have a list too! Maybe I should find somewhere to post it..'

Soo... here's the list. Quick rundown on how it works first though!


(This list isn't based on how much I enjoyed the game, and is instead based on how wholesome I found the game, based on a variety of factors.)


My list is divided into THREE main categories:

- HIGH TIER -
(que that one angelic choir sound..)
The HOLY GRAIL of wholesome games, I absolutely LOVE these ones. Little to no problems in the wholesomeness department, or they're my personal favs : D
Ex: Teaching Feeling, MDRG
I also have Doujins included in this list, and well, all of them are high tier. SO they'll also be here!


- MID TIER -
While still wholesome by my standards, games in this tier have some issues that prevent them from reaching PEAK wholesomeness. These are often RPG games with a romance mechanic, that might have some.. unsavory parts that can be disabled.
Ex: Lillith's Throne, Dog Princess (and the steele)

Getting riskier..


- LOW TIER -
:sob:

Well.. this tier only has one game at the moment (since well, it's kind of hard to be in this tier?)
This tier is reserved for a game that's.. technically wholesome? Honestly I only needed this tier for
FAIRY ADDICTION

(dun dun DUNNNN!!)
Maybe this should just be renamed the Fairy addiction tier. That's the only game weird enough to fall into this tier..


I'm always open to new suggestions on games to play! I love finding new games to recommend, and I would love input on it.
Personal Favorites are marked with a (!!) !
(Also, if you think my list is a bit empty or missing your favorite games..
..I don't play gay/yaoi, lesbian, futa, femboy, or incest games. I'm really sorry D:


oh my god i can talk FOREVER ABOUT THESE GAMES WITHOUT THE DISCORD LIMIT!!

High Tier
(Paragons of Love and Headpats)

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Mid Tier
(Maybe a little less Love and Headpats?)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Low Tier
(Reserved for the absolute ENIGMA that is Fairy Addiction)
(try not to recommend me these..)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Well, thats the end of my list for now! Please feel free to recommend me anything you want (as long as it fits here). I'm always happy to chat and expand my list! Have fun!!

oh wait, before you go if you want to read my about me so you know why I love wholesome stuff, here it is!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

This took me like a whole day to write lol
27K characters..
Update: Also i can link doujins now!!



[/QUO
I'm honestly pretty sure I don't want to play Fairy Addiction, but my inability to even find the game is making me morbidly curious. Where did you find it?

Also really glad I saw the My Maid Dreams of Electric Sheep because I was considering playing it and even if I can occasionally enjoy rough scenarios, an important part for me is the framing of it and in that one it sounds too vile for me to enjoy personally. Searched up Yui and it seems like there's only the bad end for her at the moment which I really hope is the actual case and not a random person spreading misinformation. Either way I'll definitely push it deep down in the list of games I still need to play.

For Heads Will Roll I'm assuming you mean the first one or whatever it is and not the reforged one right?

Keep up the good work (y)
For Yui Ending in Maid Sheep game they will add another Ending to it. Currently they are working on something else so pls dont do the bad thing to Yui bc if u did u wont be able to save her
 
  • Like
Reactions: AggressiveCheeto

Arabi1

Member
Donor
Oct 23, 2023
789
1,678
Haven’t tried any, but why do nearly all of them have a rape/cheating tag?
The male MC is the one being forced into it and men can't be raped so I don't see a problem. Personally, I have problems with this tag because I don't care if a man gets "raped" - that's a privilege reserved for women.

Only summer and winter memories got the cheating tag so I understand if you want it to be entirely wholesome, if not it is still cute if you do not mind things not being perfect because nothing is perfect.
 
Nov 5, 2022
193
146
The male MC is the one being forced into it and men can't be raped so I don't see a problem. Personally, I have problems with this tag because I don't care if a man gets "raped" - that's a privilege reserved for women.

Only summer and winter memories got the cheating tag so I understand if you want it to be entirely wholesome, if not it is still cute if you do not mind things not being perfect because nothing is perfect.
I really don't want to argue- especially not on my wholesome list but I'm of the opinion that men CAN be raped, especially if they're physically weaker/emotionally manipulated. Men don't always want sex, and forcing them into it would be something i'd consider rape- in the same way that forcing a woman into sex would be rape.

Also uh.. I really don't think I want cheating in my romance game (..)
 

Oh-Taco

New Member
Jun 19, 2023
12
16
Hey, I love what you are trying to do here and I have a few games I can send, but take some with a grain of salt. (I have either not played them or it's been a long time)

Links might not go through since I never post comments (I'm a huge lurker and very anti-social/socially awkward) and I think you need a certain comment count (The warning is not showing up though)

Butterfly Affection I Love this game personally. It has the same creator as Teaching feelings.
Appendix/addendum (idk which one to use) Butterfly Affection is not really that wholesome
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
but the curious story and my massive intrigue in how Ageha expresses herself makes it hard not to recommend this.

The Runaway Girl and Me Same idea as 1Room

Bottle Biosphere is another 1Room esc cohabitation game, this one can also be wholesome, but a little dark if my memory serves me right

Do you have AKIRA Points? I have not played this game, but people heavily recommend it

The Land Where One Can Make Monmusu Pets - Elf Girl Mimia This game might not be for you, but I'll include it just in case

Kaiju Princess is one of now Several Kaiju Princess games (The Arrogant Kaiju Princess and The Detective Servant and the upcoming Kaiju Princess 2)

Oni Boku ~Molesting Ogress Girl~ This game is the only "wholesome?" Laplace game that I know of (the rest contain rape so stay away)

Robolife-Days with Aino Is pretty good if you like it there is a second game

Homunculus Research Record I'm unable to be 100% certain this game is "wholesome" as my VM can't run it properly so I used a full save (there is a "bad end" route that contains group sex not including MC or what could be considered NTR I think?)

Maid Life I have only played it a little bit, quite wholesome if I recall

Angel of Echidna: Love-colored Cohabitation Same as above

Hush Hush Good game, but watch out for the bad ends

Renryuu: Ascension Is another personal favorite

Kon's lesson! Wholesome if I recall also very horny

Your Waifu Foxgirl Konko - Furfect Edition If you have not played this game you are doing yourself a disservice I'll say that much for my opinion on it

Vampire OO Diary I like it, but sadly it was cut short (last I checked) as the dev wanted to make a new game from the ground up with what they learned making this one

Secret with Sophia Same dev as Konko, great game if smaller

Gran Ende II Have not played this one yet, but you can head pat the elf so it must have a full wholesome route right? P.P.S. gonna try to play this game seriously soon you can head pat on command from my short experience of the game from a different point of time.

Doris ❤ Lady of the Night Again have not played it, but seems wholesome

Divine Dawn I'm a bit behind on recent updates (and have not played far into it) You can have a harem, but I do believe you can also choose one or none.

There is also Monster Girl 1000, but I can't find it here anymore sadly.

I do have more games, some being Japanese only and such (I recommend Sugoi toolkit for TL, but do make your own decisions as I can't guarantee it or anything is safe really. I run everything on a VM and soon a second computer for extra security)

Anyway, I hope this comment goes through and you can at least enjoy some of these games, I think it's about time I crawl back into my cave.

P.S. Do write to me if you want any more recommendations or need a bit of help as some of these games do need a bit of elbow grease for the best experience, especially RPGM games (can you even DM on F95?) and I'll try to respond. But I'm very much out of my comfort zone just making this comment so do be lenient with me (Or we can DM on Discord idk)
 
Last edited: