Grumpy Ol' Dude
Newbie
- Jan 27, 2021
- 60
- 59
- 123
I don't think the open relationship thing is misleading at all, it perfectly fits Jaye's character. I've said before, but this game is mostly about Jaye and the relationship between her and MC. That girl loved MC since she was 9, that's when she wanted that ring and imagined MC proposing to her with it. MC loved her too already back then (the tingling feeling during the bed fort scene that he did not understand).Yes this is true for the good and for the bad, Jaye is very well written and the dynamic between her and the MC is powerful, but on an extreme example, there is some very well written villains around and even though I guess many more will still cheer for the hero even if has less depth than the antagonist.
I'm with darkcaptainfighter, even though the former is true I enjoyed more the fresh relationship and dynamic between the MC and Mal, so no you are not an oddball and you are not alone in your preference for sure but yes I believe that probably there is more Jaye fans than Mallory's and it is understandable.
On the players choice statistics your signature it the best answerFacts don't care about (our) feelings, and as former scientist student and later/now Quality technicien I rely a lot on facts and statistics/probabilities so I also "follow" (not blindly) that motto.
If I wasn't that kind of player that plays almost every path possible, and I did play all the 4 main paths and the alone path (later after chapter 9 was released), probably I only would play the solo Mallory path that was my main playthrough all the way (but wouldn't play the game over) when I replayed all the paths after the release of chapter 9 misleading conclusion of Jaye and Mallory open relationships that didn't gone the way I thought it would and at the time it was my only playthrough. Got pretty pissed at the time but the game is so well written I decided to start a new main playthrough focusing on Mallory that at the time already was my favorite.
Side note : sorry about the last paragraph, English isn't my first language and had troubles to put my train of thought into words, after read it, it seems confusing even for me. Hope is clear enough hehe.
For Mal, the open relationship option is understandable exactly because she does not have a past with MC, they've just met and she knows there're some unresolved feelings between MC and Jaye but she still wants to get involved with MC, that's why she keeps trying even after learning that something's already developed between MC and Jaye.
Jaye on the other hand must know that MC wants her and her only above all before she could consider bringing in Mal. She loved that guy since she was 9!!! They had a 16 years long past. She had an attitude sometimes? Yeah, but MC was the one who tried to push her away and even if he had good intentions that move obviously hurt Jaye a lot. They were kids. He did not even succeed by the way, despite the "attitude" she was with him (and vice versa) at all the important moments of their lives! She went to each and every game MC played in for many years, took revenge when someone hurt MC. Also, she's still a virgin at 25, never dated (the Christian thing is very well explained, wasn't close to dating), never touched another man because she was and IS in love with MC. She even accepts how MC was dealing with his feelings in the past without any jealousy.
Then MC is fooling around with Mal and tells Mal he wants an open relationship AFTER the naked night in Jaye's bed (fort) and the shower scene with Jaye. They've just stared to (re)build their relationship and got physical too. MC also told her he isn't dating anyone, and while it was true back then he forgot to mention that that's changed, Jaye finds out by chance when running into Mal in front of MC's door at night. It's quite reasonable for Jaye to feel betrayed and to avoid that poly relationship in this scenario. I did not try that option yet, does she dump MC too or the solo option remains?
The poly route comes when Jaye feels she is the only one MC needs even though she suspects that MC has feelings for Mal too. And it's perfectly fitting!
Focus on Jaye all the time and obviously be as nice as one could be to Mal always but don't stop her when she leaves the room after getting in because of Amanda. The choice to confess feelings to Mal and the poly option from Jaye comes up then, no trickery and walkthrough needed.