Dec 2, 2019
53
48
The only sharing path that makes sense for me, (the way the story has evolved so far) is with Elena. Everything else seems forced. I personally like all the girls in the game, and I have different saves for each one of them, (not for the dudes thought. I don't want any other "D"s near D...) but that's the only path that makes sense storywise. But that's probably because I play these games to take my mind off things, and not to jerk off, so I prefere games with a decent storyline. People who just want fap material will probably go for quantity over quality which seems to be the "theme" of the recent updates. The game is still good if you play it a certain way. Not as good as it was before they moved, but good enough to keep playing it.
I think the sharing path with Olivia/Graham makes sense, they are basically the older version of D/MC. They've helped MC/D more than the other characters in the game. MC has also had sex with Olivia and Olivia and D are starting to do what D/Elena did earlier in the game. (touching, kissing etc.). If you remember, Graham already gave Olivia permission to have sex with MC in chapter 2 and he "shared" her with MC when they went to their apartment after the club.
It's a more well rounded rationalization to be sure.
 

armion82

Devoted Member
Mar 28, 2017
11,998
16,160
It makes sense to be friends, not to fuck each other. The Olivia thing was optional, you didn't have to fuck her if you didn't want to, but even if you did, it seems more like Graham let you fuck his daughter because he wanted to fuck yours, than a natural thing. And the touching-kissing you mentioned isn't something mutual, but Olivia trying to fuck D in every chance she has. Every single action was initiated by her.
Just drop it.You can't win this one.Talking about making sense in incest game.You have lost from the start.
Just play the path you like and if there is no such try another game.
 

eddie987

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2018
1,527
6,966
Just drop it.You can't win this one.Talking about making sense in incest game.You have lost from the start.
Just play the path you like and if there is no such try another game.
You obviously didn't read my previous comments but that's fine. It's better to get into a conversation from the start though and not from the last thing you heard/read.
 

Doxxi

Member
May 19, 2019
381
565
"They are also a father-daughter couple, we have something in common, so let's fuck each other's daugher. Oh! And we also owe them..." relationship?[/ISPOILER] It's actually interesting how much less sense the game makes, just because you are on a different path.
the only sharing stuff that feels remotely flushed out, unfortunately, is Elaina/ Jenna stuff, Olivia's stuff could be interesting but is mostly rushed. to me the parts that make the most sense are the "implied path' the other stuff is their for the fans who want that kind of content.
 

eddie987

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2018
1,527
6,966
the only sharing stuff that feels remotely flushed out, unfortunately, is Elaina/ Jenna stuff, Olivia's stuff could be interesting but is mostly rushed. to me the parts that make the most sense are the "implied path' the other stuff is their for the fans who want that kind of content.
That's what we were talking about with Casual Observer. That some stuff seem "forced", like the devs put them in the game just to appeal to more people and not because they wanted to. Like I said before, from the sharing paths, only the one with Elena makes sense to me. The way the characters developed up to the second chapter at least.
 

absalon1977

Active Member
Jun 5, 2018
938
600
i am also not too fond of the sharing paths, but its fine as long as its optional, having more build up for those paths is ofc not possible with the amount of updates left, but i think there will be at least one more thing d or f need too say yes too before graham or martin do something with d, it would not make sense that those encounters would be on rails now maybe with martin, but d have not indicated in anyway that she is interested in graham. Something else in the info for this update mr. dots mentioned that love points will have an impact on endings, thats interesting you loose a lot of points by going some poly routes or share route and combining them even more, i hope the team is not planning on doing it like in melody, in that one a perfect ending could only be achieved on a pure route.
 

北方玄武

Member
Sep 11, 2017
133
337
I don´t get why some people don´t understand that this is a porn game and it´s not intended to be too close to reality just like with porn itself. What options the author of this game chooses to be in it, is on his own accord.

Ladies and gentlemen, why you don´t enjoy this cool game and forget about all unnecessary things?
 
Dec 2, 2019
53
48
Just drop it.You can't win this one.Talking about making sense in incest game.You have lost from the start.
Just play the path you like and if there is no such try another game.
Fair point, but I don't think it's too much to ask to have stories add up to the results. It's a visual novel so the story being plausible shouldn't be too much to expect but I realize that it would take a lot more content to get it to those ends within the bounds of the story line and accept that there are limitations to whats realistically possible to expect on delivering it.
 

absalon1977

Active Member
Jun 5, 2018
938
600
and from that it should be clear i have a playthrough with all sharing on, including elena and jennifer mostly too see how the story progress like that, but will most likely not continue it if it will not be possible at some point too avoid a encounter with another guy.
 

Ed B

Active Member
Sep 24, 2017
679
491
No, they actually can't because the game is no longer being developed on Patreon, even with Mr. Dots still being on Patreon. If Patreon tried to do that, they would have no leg to stand on because they cannot prove that the money being obtained for Melody is being used for DMD. This is even more true with DMD being developed on SubscribeStar now. Patreon is not as all encompassing on the internet as many people think, it just feels that way because they are still the biggest crowdfunded site out there, but with all these bullshit rules, they have been slowly, but surely, driving people away. This is why SubscribStar has started to get a foothold in this market. Finally, as far as Melody is concerned, it all comes down to content and nothing in that game violates Patreon's rules. So, Mr. Dots is free to make DMD however he wants as long as it does not involve Patreon, while also making games like Melody and being compliant to Patreon.
Go back a few hundred pages and read discussion on this before...Or even just go to his site and read issues game is having, Depending on which type of funding account was at time available or one Mr. Dots has with Patreon, they can still control his funds. Patreon (Which is owned by PayPal) wasn't only looking to get this type of game off their site, they were looking to stop them completely. We all might follow Mr. Dots on his various pages but Patreon also has access to see what he's doing and as long as he's on Patreon they will have that access. DMD was making an INCREDIBLE amount of money monthly and if by any chance that funds are still being held from him (None of my business if they are or not) Melody could possibly be the main support and that's not making nearly as much a month as DMD once did
 

eddie987

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2018
1,527
6,966
I don't get why some people don't understand that this is a fucking thread and people will talk about what they like and dislike about the game they played. If someone says that he doesn't like something about a game, or he finds that something doesn't make sense it doesn't mean he disliked the whole game or that he's trying to be an asshole. That's the point of a thread ffs! For people to exchange opinions about specific topics!
 
Dec 2, 2019
53
48
Just drop it.You can't win this one.Talking about making sense in incest game.You have lost from the start.
Just play the path you like and if there is no such try another game.
btw you could have rewritten this whole story with the same art as an older man/younger woman story and it would have still played out as well. I personally don't really go in for the incest kink but will follow along any story that has attractive characters and a fair plot and I would probably have preferred they had written it different but still appreciate a lot of whats there from various angles.
 

Ed B

Active Member
Sep 24, 2017
679
491
I don't get why some people don't understand that this is a fucking thread and people will talk about what they like and dislike about the game they played. If someone says that he doesn't like something about a game, or he finds that something doesn't make sense it doesn't mean he disliked the whole game or he's just trying to be an asshole. That's the point of a thread ffs! For people to exchange opinions about specific topics!
Used to be a thing on here that after every release people didn't talk about what went on in it so it gave everyone the chance to play without the spoilers from people....but that got blown to shit as well lol lol
 

eddie987

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2018
1,527
6,966
Used to be a thing on here that after every release people didn't talk about what went on in it so it gave everyone the chance to play without the spoilers from people....but that got blown to shit as well lol lol
That's easy to work around, since you can use the spoiler. I'm talking about the people who get upset if you say that you don't like something about a game and they urge you to play something else instead! Of course there will be something I won't like or I won't get in every game! Noone can develop a flawless game. It doesn't mean I don't like the whole thing because I pointed out something that I don't think it makes sense!
 

Ed B

Active Member
Sep 24, 2017
679
491
That's easy to work around, since you can use the spoiler. I'm talking about the people who get upset if you say that you don't like something about a game and they urge you to play something else instead! Of course there will be something I won't like or I won't get in every game! Noone can develop a flawless game. It doesn't mean I don't like the whole thing because I pointed out something that I don't think it makes sense!
Didn't even need to use the blurring. Was just done out of being courteous towards others where it may have not been released yet. Now you get people spilling out all details couple of hours after it's been released
 
  • Like
Reactions: eddie987

Doxxi

Member
May 19, 2019
381
565
That's easy to work around, since you can use the spoiler. I'm talking about the people who get upset if you say that you don't like something about a game and they urge you to play something else instead! Of course there will be something I won't like or I won't get in every game! Noone can develop a flawless game. It doesn't mean I don't like the whole thing because I pointed out something that I don't think it makes sense!
to be fair most people here are not paying for anything so yes while you can disagree with anything you want, the people who make these games have to take into account that probably 80% of the opinions here are irrelevant because they will never get money from those people but will bitched at by them. and a lot of the people who shoot stuff like that down are patreons/ subs on subscribestar.
 

eddie987

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2018
1,527
6,966
to be fair most people here are not paying for anything so yes while you can disagree with anything you want, the people who make these games have to take into account that probably 80% of the opinions here are irrelevant because they will never get money from those people but will bitched at by them. and a lot of the people who shoot stuff like that down are patreons/ subs on subscribestar.
So you can only say how amazing something is, unless you're paying for it? What's the point of the thread then? Sure, most people here don't pay for the games, but the devs use this site and other similar ones for exposure, they don't do it because they are kind harted people who want to help those who can't buy their product. And I don't say it in a bad way. It's an easy way to advertise yourself, so of course they'll use it. It's the same way I won't support someone on patreon before I try his game out and see that he is consistent with the updates. Anyway. My point is that some people need to understand that you can talk about something you don't like, without bitching about it. Not every criticism is spiteful, malicious or whatever. People can just talk about something because they find it interesting even if they don't get it or like it. It doesn't mean they are attacking the dev or anyone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ed B
3.80 star(s) 325 Votes