VN Ren'Py Completed Dating My Daughter [Ch. 1-4 v1.01] [MrDots Games]

3.80 star(s) 333 Votes
Discussion Reviews (333)
M

Mommysbuttslut

Forum Fanatic
Feb 19, 2021
4,191
10,275
Segnbora said:
Really? Really?

Now i'm worried about you.
Click to expand...
Honestly it's a pretty valid question within the specific context of daddy daughter AVNs. Technically every single MC in the entire sub genre fits that description.
There's also the fact that how much F pushes D into shit depends on the choices you make. F only brings up watching gang bang porn with her in episode 3 if he's cheating on her for example. Someone who plays for all content is going to have an entirely different opinion of F than someone who plays a vanilla loyal playthrough. On the loyal route he's a lot less pushy and all around a lot less creepy.
 
Segnbora

Segnbora

Well-Known Member
Aug 30, 2017
1,803
3,217
Well, I agree that it's a persistent trope in the incest genre. There are a lot of problematic tropes in adult games (e.g. sleep rape), but even on a really vanilla route, the F is unquestionably grooming his hopelessly defenseless daughter for sex. Is that the point of the game? Yes, it is. It doesn't mean he's not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sasarko99
DarkDaemonX

DarkDaemonX

Engaged Member
Mar 31, 2020
2,576
2,833
Segnbora said:
Really? Really?

Even on a playthrough in which he doesn't routinely cheat on her and lie about it, he slowly but persistently manipulates a hopelessly naive and profoundly unintelligent young girl, who just happens to be his own daughter, into sex.

Now i'm worried about you.
Click to expand...

I guess we look at the game differently, because D isn't stupid at all, just sheltered, like I said before, and he doesn't manipulate her into it, as she is the one that wanted it too, you also have to remember, D made the first move, not F.


If you call what happens manipulating, I guess every person in a relationship making the other comfortable with having sex, is manipulating them.

F didn't intend for all of what happened between him and D to happen, it just naturally went that way.


What are you even doing here, if all you want to do is shit on the game and its characters?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Charl9, _baka_, guardianfather and 1 other person
DarkDaemonX

DarkDaemonX

Engaged Member
Mar 31, 2020
2,576
2,833
Segnbora said:
Do you think D is emotionally and intellectually able to consent to a sexual relationship with her father? Because I sure don't.
Click to expand...
I do, why do you keep insisting she's unintelligent anyways, I jeep telling you she's not, and just sheltered as that's the truth.

She's perfectly capable of consenting to anything.
 
M

Mommysbuttslut

Forum Fanatic
Feb 19, 2021
4,191
10,275
Segnbora said:
Well, I agree that it's a persistent trope in the incest genre. There are a lot of problematic tropes in adult games (e.g. sleep rape), but even on a really vanilla route, the F is unquestionably grooming his hopelessly defenseless daughter for sex. Is that the point of the game? Yes, it is. It doesn't mean he's not.
Click to expand...
The internal monologues make it pretty clear that D is pushing things on F before he starts going for it.

Segnbora said:
Do you think D is emotionally and intellectually able to consent to a sexual relationship with her father? Because I sure don't.
Click to expand...
Is anyone intellectually able to consent to a sexual relationship with their father? D is old and mature enough to consent to sexual relations with someone who isn't in a position of trust or power legally. There's an argument to be made that F isn't in that position because he hadn't raised her for the last 10 years or w/e, wasn't her guardian, had no visitation rights and wasn't responsible for her, at least until the end of chapter 2. Still illegal because it's incest but it'd be an argument to claim he was or wasn't in a position of trust at the start of their relationship. Some suspension of disbelief is required with all incest games around the topic of consent though, if that bothers you that much then I'd kinda wonder why you're playing this genre tbh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wookie, DarkDaemonX and Uthuriel
DarkDaemonX

DarkDaemonX

Engaged Member
Mar 31, 2020
2,576
2,833
Mommysbuttslut said:
The internal monologues make it pretty clear that D is pushing things on F before he starts going for it.


Is anyone intellectually able to consent to a sexual relationship with their father? D is old and mature enough to consent to sexual relations with someone who isn't in a position of trust or power legally. There's an argument to be made that F isn't in that position because he hadn't raised her for the last 10 years or w/e, wasn't her guardian, had no visitation rights and wasn't responsible for her, at least until the end of chapter 2. Still illegal because it's incest but it'd be an argument to claim he was or wasn't in a position of trust at the start of their relationship. Some suspension of disbelief is required with all incest games around the topic of consent though, if that bothers you that much then I'd kinda wonder why you're playing this genre tbh.
Click to expand...


Well said, you said everything I wanted to say even better than I could say it myself.
 
Segnbora

Segnbora

Well-Known Member
Aug 30, 2017
1,803
3,217
It's not a complaint. I just prefer games in which I think all parties are equally into it and equally cognizant of exactly what they're doing. D is hopelessly naive and not very bright, and if you don't see that in the script that I don't know what to tell you. F is manipulative even on routes where he's not cheating on her. (Which, again; I'm playing it with the mod and everyone who can have sex with someone else is having it, because I've zero emotional investment in some sort of perfect romantic ending between D&F. It is, to me, largely mindless incest porn with side options. If I truly cared about the game, F would end up with Georgina and D would find someone age-appropriate. But it's an incest game, and so the "best" ending is gonna be between F&D, which is fine.)

And I already said it: at this point, with DMD, it's sunk cost. I'm going to finish the game because it's been years at this point. Since I'm not paying for it, I've no justification for complaint anyway. But it would be a better game if D was brighter and more worldly. Instead, everyone manipulates her, and she never notices.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: RedPillBlues, _baka_, Uthuriel and 1 other person
B

Bigapee

Member
Jul 19, 2017
367
492
Segnbora said:
And I already said it: at this point, with DMD, it's sunk cost. I'm going to finish the game because it's been years at this point. Since I'm not paying for it, I've no justification for complaint anyway. But it would be a better game if D was brighter and more worldly. Instead, everyone manipulates her, and she never notices.
Click to expand...
just cut the cord bud, i did. i stopped playing back when it became clear she would always be attached to F's hip (Martin made that absurdly clear to me) . i drop into this thread from time to time on the off chance that ever changes, but if you aren't enjoying it no amount of time spent is worth continuing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Segnbora and Sasarko99
E

Eradawn

Newbie
Jun 20, 2017
96
162
The planned routes , sleeping with other men like Martin and Ryan, should be more considered. And even the Players that dont like this stuff, can switch to normal route or ignoring these pathes. I think that would be a great solution for all when there would be a option for future content to skip these scenes if you dont like them. So the dev could do some of this sharing scenes.

Iam always a fan of variation when it comes to different routes. So Iam also open for more kind of routes or scenes that you cant get on one playthrough.


Maybe there will be some more of this who knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kintarosmash
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
3.80 star(s) 333 Votes