Rastafoo

Well-Known Member
Jun 6, 2018
1,742
3,672
Comments critical of this game are slowly being deleted. But that can't hide its mediocrity.
 

Jamonkey32

Newbie
Jan 7, 2019
17
4
Anyone else have problems with saving in rpg maker games? I know there are multiple problems involving them but I cant find the right solution. When ever I save in a game if I close it and reopen it there are no saves.
 
Last edited:

Korrupt

Newbie
Jul 26, 2017
19
24
Okaaaay, I think I am seriously out of the loop here. What's going on with the hate on Kagura Games? This trend is kinda also apparent on steam where it's currently standing at 60% Mixed with only one written review as of writing this.

It's a Clymenia game and they haven't disappointed me. But is the general negativity really justified? Or is the game actually quite bad?
To add onto another comment, they stole + didnt give credit + threat
Don't want to call anyone specific out but I know this is a blatant lie. I followed the projects of one of the fan translators they stole from. I cannot say for sure they add nothing to it but I know that they have done some scummy stuff.
Yeah, I can verify this as well. One of the KaguraGames translations is definitely NOT their own work, whatever they may claim. The original translation for said work was posted for free several months before KaguraGames released it.

That being said KaguraGames does good work and monetizing translations isn't something I'm upset about.
 

PrivateEyes

Member
May 26, 2017
152
257
Comments critical of this game are slowly being deleted. But that can't hide its mediocrity.
Are they? That's pretty wrong if that were the case.

As for the game however, I would rank it second/third best out of Clymenia games. Nowhere near as good as Salvation, but much better than that nobleman hypnosis one. Than again, I'm not a fan of male MC's outside of a long RPG eroge (such as the Rance games, Eiyuu Senki, etc.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sid Lut

Rastafoo

Well-Known Member
Jun 6, 2018
1,742
3,672
Are they? That's pretty wrong if that were the case.

As for the game however, I would rank it second/third best out of Clymenia games. Nowhere near as good as Salvation, but much better than that nobleman hypnosis one. Than again, I'm not a fan of male MC's outside of a long RPG eroge (such as the Rance games, Eiyuu Senki, etc.)
This game is their second best game?
And Salvation is their first?

Civilian Justice League 2 had a public reputation system and impregnation mechanics.

Liz & Tower Town had publicly random sex encounters with significantly more events than any other game plus a unique item gathering/crafting system.

Hypnosis Aristocrat allowed you to mind control adventurers or go out and be one yourself as you slowly strengthen your mind control powers and eventually make yourself the ruler of the town you live in.

If we count Salvation as the top, that makes Detective Girl their 5th best game bro. Unless you think Detective Girl somehow beats ALL of these games, even though it lacks features they all had.

Detective Girl has no impregnation, no item gathering/crafting to raise public affinity, no mind control mechanics leading to literally usurping your uncle as Town Noble.

All Detective Girl has is a tomboy protagonist.
 

PrivateEyes

Member
May 26, 2017
152
257
This game is their second best game?
And Salvation is their first?

Civilian Justice League 2 had a public reputation system and impregnation mechanics.

Liz & Tower Town had publicly random sex encounters with significantly more events than any other game plus a unique item gathering/crafting system.

Hypnosis Aristocrat allowed you to mind control adventurers or go out and be one yourself as you slowly strengthen your mind control powers and eventually make yourself the ruler of the town you live in.

If we count Salvation as the top, that makes Detective Girl their 5th best game bro. Unless you think Detective Girl somehow beats ALL of these games, even though it lacks features they all had.

Detective Girl has no impregnation, no item gathering/crafting to raise public affinity, no mind control mechanics leading to literally usurping your uncle as Town Noble.

All Detective Girl has is a tomboy protagonist.
I'm a simple man with a very simple criteria. All I care about are 1) the hentai scenes 2) Potential freedom of action. If the mechanics of a game don't play into that, they simply don't matter on my scale.

1) Okay, the public reputation system was fun, but it also felt like an extended lewd counter than anything. However, the impregnation scenes were "eh" to me.
2) Male MC + hypnosis? Automatic 2 outs for me
3) Okay, I'll give you that one as well.

So I guess this would be my 3rd or 4th favourite Clymenia game, all things considered. Objectively, I guess it could be argued that this was one of Clymenia's weaker games. However, I merely stated my subjective opinion.
 

Alice12

Newbie
Dec 20, 2017
71
11
Sorry for late reply, I've downloaded the latets version but what should I do next? Do I need to copy paste the new njws version to somewhere? If yes then to where? Sorry for so many question
Can anyone please help me with this?
 

SakuiSama

Newbie
Jul 16, 2019
25
58
Anyone having issues like the one pictured? I am running this on a Linux distro and using a rpg maker mv tool located on this site to help launch the game since it does not launch normally.

There might be something with the package from Detective Girl that is causing problems.

Got it to work with RPG Maker MV 1.61 after making the TFF change to tff to one of the fonts. But I did come up with a problem. Im also curious to see if the package that has 1 mb more than the other is at fault for the resource missing. By package I mean resources.pak
 

Corbeau

Newbie
Dec 3, 2018
72
157
High production value but pretty disappointing tbh.
The normal game doesn't mix with the porn aspect at all. There's no real reason for her to do anything lewd.
And who asked for 100% non-pornographic fetch quests in their porn games?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stretta

Gervoh

Member
Jul 20, 2019
397
564
High production value but pretty disappointing tbh.
The normal game doesn't mix with the porn aspect at all. There's no real reason for her to do anything lewd.
And who asked for 100% non-pornographic fetch quests in their porn games?
Yup, excatly my thoughts. It almost feels like they wanted to focus on the story in this one instead of the porn aspect. The only reason she does anything lewd is because we decided so, she gains nothing from it and it really sucks. For me the game's overall lackluster because it doesn't have random lewd encounters in public, no real mechanics etc.
 

Ion.TemUS

Active Member
Jun 8, 2017
879
923
I like the game for its unique ideas and I like the gameplay too.
I agree the excecution of the latter half was a bit lackluster and imo the content towards the end could have been more, esp some routes felt a bit short and ended apruptly and there wasnt a lot of follow-through for a lot of the side stories.

Same on the half-asses excuses for her to do the things she does, there should be more of a lead-in for some of the scenarios.

Aside from that its an okay game and miles better than some of the other ones I see here. Idk about the devs beyond the fact that they made a couple of games like CJL 1 and 2 and that Kagura made the translation, but i dont get the hate.
 

eosar

Active Member
Aug 11, 2016
846
1,198
Aye, half-assed.

Much more could have been done with those detective skills. The game was very attractive at first, but it just doesn't have the stuff for what it was going for. Or maybe i'm just greedy.
 

asd dsa

New Member
Mar 19, 2018
7
1
I can't find the supplies shop in slums. Can anybody help with location or with editor to make this go away?
1564594732369.png
 

Stretta

Member
Nov 21, 2018
238
739
High production value but pretty disappointing tbh.
The normal game doesn't mix with the porn aspect at all. There's no real reason for her to do anything lewd.
And who asked for 100% non-pornographic fetch quests in their porn games?
I felt that too. I went the lewd route (which takes an annoying amount of work) and the game kept telling me her personality was so drastically different and how she can only "think with her womb". But in the actual dialogue there were few notable changes to her behavior. The art in the porn itself isn't even good. The girls look good, but the men look like weird, lumpy freaks and they're so bad it's distracting.

Feels like they just tacked porn on at the last minute.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PerpetuallyAmiss
4.30 star(s) 86 Votes