Were you the one who added Domina to Tiermaker, if so thank you very much
No no, I said someone else did it, I'm just sharing my own list and letting others do the same if they like to.
As for why I placed Mary above Franzkesca, it was because, despite Mary's obvious cheating and angel torment, Franzkesca does far worse over nothing. Mary's one saving grace is that, in her own words, she does not torture for the sake of fun. If I had to choose one of those two to be enslaved to, I would rather be bent over Mary's throne and fucked with her emerald strapon than have my body torn apart all over the room.
I wasn't asking anything about Mary, I was asking about why you placed Franziska between the male characters, like in the middle, and I kind of thought she would be lower for you since it's not hard to imagine why you would likely dislike her so much. Maybe it has something to do with Franziska having some qualities that the rest of the F tier characters don't have that isn't enough for them to outclass her in your eyes. Sorry for the overthinking.
I also did place her at the bottom of my Domina list, though there are some things that I do like about her, but sadly her excessive sadistic nature along with her grim, in-your-face scenes ruins it for me.
As for putting Best Girl anywhere lower than S tier, shame on you for making her cry. If she regains her power maybe she will make you her next champion for that...
Welllll that's gonna be a no, I think she may be forgiving for that since she represents a being full of light after all, and she should feel lucky that I did not choose her to be a bottom tier, haha.
All joking aside (you can skip this paragraph if you want a summarized version of it), I thought of putting Llavanya at S rank since I appreciate her attitude and character design. At the same time, she is the one Domina I could actually lower her rank with, but hear me out, I only put her fairly high on the list (next to Madeline) since I'm giving her a chance. But it's just that the ways she is written, especially after you-know-what happened to her, it makes me worry about what she is about to become next that may potentially affect my impressions about her, though I can't say for sure what the future holds. She is strong (even mentally), though she doesn't even push Mary off of her even at full strength. Sure, Mary is stronger in her realm, but it was said that Llavanya is stronger than even just 1 Domina (and she is a light Domina which she somehow didn't take advantage of it), though I guess it's not explicitly explained about her power scaling versus the evil Dominas, but my only assumption is that she is weak to her darkness since they both are polar opposites to each other (and she implied she doesn't like darkness). Also she thought that it was not an issue to stand
right in front of the unlucky number 4 death door (it represents bad luck in some countries) for some reason, which the MC did not complete yet, and she pretty much let herself be a defenseless victim that it doesn't make sense for a Goddess of Light (stronger than a single Domina) that we met briefly to fall so quickly though I guess that's part of the story element in the world of Domina we have to accept.
So yeah basically, Best Girl gets nerfed by Worst Girl without enough given explanation and her lack of cautiousness became her undoing and fell easily despite being one of the strongest of their kind. It's honestly a vague way to write a major character like that, who is forced to live her life in ruin. Sorry for the absurd amount of text but I wanted to point out some issues regarding Llavanya and I hope she does get better at the end of this conflict, and the MC too.
I guess she doesn't necessarily count on the tier list like other Dominas for some people, because even if she is a Domina, we only met her for a short amount of time with few interactions so far. All in all, I wonder what secrets Llavanya might be hiding from the MC, if she has any. And also when you said that she may regain her powers, I do wonder where that will go from there... It's getting me pretty pumped for the future with Llavanya in the story even though I also have some fears on what will happen next.
