Alright the issue with John in this game people have brought up they are not threatened by him but they don't want him around. well in the game you end up fucking maria and you want to get rid of her husband and continue to do so. I understand that some people want their pie and eat it as well but in this case that is not going to happen. I know a great many swingers and some of them will swing without their partners, and I know that many will not swing for long without their partners being involved in some way. IT is part of the game, you can stop him from fucking dana but you still have to be there when he is doing maria and mila.
This game is about the MC who is honestly a guy that will not give up other women even when he finds the one he wants and finds out she's also interested. I'm sorry the John haters I do not understand why you are so against him in the context of the game. there are other games out there that you can avoid the other guys. Logically I do understand why you do not want him around, and logically I do understand why you hate him so much... but he is part of the game and the creator has him in an active role. there seems to be no inclination that both John and the MC will have sex with each other ("gay sex") so just make your choices, accept that in some circles it's a great thing that the husband of one of the conquests for the MC is willing to share and enjoys watching others etc.
Also I've known a great many people like Andrea as well in the BDSM community, and when there is alcohol and abuse the abused ends up making a choice, one to go into and enjoy something along those lines but in a way that it's safe, or to completely become what many would call "frigid" because she (or he) does not want the same to happen to them again. When the former happens they usually become a "little" and enjoy having an authority figure to tell them what to do, when to do it and that they are doing it great. One thing to note this is not why everyone that enjoys being a "little" is there for that same reason, I am only talking about the type of person that comes from a background like andrea's as well as talking in generalities as there is always people that do things differently than others or than the expected.
Last thing for this post,
@Maragdus you said you recommend changing the beginning of the game because some others tried it but does not like it, what are your specific suggestions? so that
@Ptolemy can look at it and decide if he feels it is something that is worth doing, as he has said he will go back and fix up things just currently he is more interested in progressing the story, but if you have specific ideas i'm sure he'd at least entertain them and keep it in mind when he does go back and change the beginning up.
Lets all just enjoy the game. stop hating on the characters that
@Ptolemy has created for us and just enjoy a game that has a good story line, great imagery and keep enjoying it as he adds more to it!