So, i started a playthrough more than a month ago. Kinda stalled...maybe i subconsciously dreaded reaching the temporary end of a more immersive AVN title. After finishing or dropping a few other incomplete titles i felt ready to return. While i still only progressed in small steps, i felt ready to join the best-girl gang wars.
Since i have only just reached the start of the roman server, you can speculate how my list is likely to change and how it compares with your own impressions of the girls from more than a 1,5 years or so ago. Considering how likable they all are, i refuse to spread them across 7 ranks and instead use = and > to distinguish them.
1st: Luna (1st place by the time i knew enough to validly compare them. Like my heroines a little strange)
2nd: Annie ( love how pure and genuine her joy is when you join Eternum and meet up)
Shared 3rd: Nancy (Refreshing how she isn't that ashamed about her lewd train of thought in the beginning, only physical actions) and Nova (Love how her social inexperience and chaotic energy comes into play)
Shared 4th: Penelope (I really like how much she breaks the mold and isn't a ditzy bimbo doll)
and Alex (At this point she still feels more like a friend who needs a trusty ally. Love her dirty mouth though, thats for sure).
5th: Dalia (Not too unlike Alex, she feels more like a friend or Eternum teacher. A little too much into the whole sport thing for my tastes).
As for the secondary comments others have made, boobs are indeed more important than ass. But ass likely have stronger allies in the thighs and hips, than boobs do in the stomach and back. The conflict is only a stalemate because SameBoomSyndrome is a dominating trend across AVN's, especially in the HS engine.