3.80 star(s) 65 Votes

omegabox

Member
Jan 3, 2018
178
135
There are one man made or small studio made porn games and some of them have solid gameplay. I can only imagine what developers of those games would've made if they had more budget and manpower. Solas City Heroes, Eris Dysnomia, Holy Knight Ricca, Karryn's Prison, Lona RPG, Station Master, Monster Girl Dreams, Goblin Burrow, Last Evil... I've played all of them, not only they are porn but they are also games and good ones at that so if you are going for "it is impossible to create a good porn game" argument don't bother.
"if they had more budget and manpower", you basically answered your own question. Have you thought about the reason why the developers who actually focus on gameplay are mostly tight on budget and porn viewer makers can swim in cash? The reason is simple: the majority of paying customers don't give a shit about how good the gameplay is in a porn game, it's the quality of porn that make them pay. It all boils down to the principle of economics: the financial return of making gameplay is negative, no matter how important you claim it to be.

Not to mention that gameplay wise those examples you gave are all shitty compared with sfw games of similar theme, genre, budget and price (Lona RPG - elona, Last Evil - Slay the Spire, etc), it's only rational that most people would just download saves to unlock all the porn and forget about the rest. Basically all porn games have a gallery for a reason: we all know that time is money, it's better spent elsewhere than "playing" for porn. (however if your time isn't worth that much that's another story.)
 
Last edited:

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,478
4,077
"if they had more budget and manpower", you basically answered your own question. Have you thought about the reason why the developers who actually focus on gameplay are tight on budget and porn viewer makers can swim in cash? The reason is simple: the majority of paying customers don't give a shit about how good the gameplay is in a porn game, it's the quality of porn that make them pay. It all boils down to the principle of economics: the financial return of making gameplay is negative.
You can't prove any of those claims though. For example:
"majority of paying customers don't give a shit about how good the gameplay is in a porn game"
How can you know that? You can't. And for all you know thousands of people might've decided to not support said games precisely because they lack gameplay. Your point is moot.

Not to mention that gameplay wise those examples you gave are all shitty compared with sfw games of similar theme, genre, budget and price (Lona RPG - elona, Last Evil - Slay the Spire, etc), it's only rational that most people would just download saves to unlock all the porn and forget about the rest.
But does slay the spire have porn? If I am looking for a porn game why would I play slay the spire when last evil exists?

Basically all porn games have a gallery for a reason: we all know that time is better spent elsewhere.
Basically all games have people who ask for 100% save files. That's not exclusive to porn games. What is your point?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: kolevro and anon241

omegabox

Member
Jan 3, 2018
178
135
You can't prove any of those claims though. For example:
"majority of paying customers don't give a shit about how good the gameplay is in a porn game"
How can you know that? You can't. And for all you know thousands of people might've decided to not support said games precisely because they lack gameplay. Your point is moot.
lmao you are dense. The logic is so simple: if focusing on gameplay brings in revenue efficiently (your hypothetical "thousands of people might've decided to not support said games precisely because they lack gameplay" really buy or are willing to support the porn games with elaborated gameplay), those cash grabbers and patron milkers you hate fiercely would be updating their project's gameplay monthly instead of cramming more porn into their "glorified sex animation viewer", and the majority of successful porn games would be featuring good gameplay instead of visual novel and animation player now. Alas, this is apparently not the case in reality, there's not even a trance of trend pointing to that direction.

Can't believe I need to make it this clear for you to understand.

But does slay the spire have porn? If I am looking for a porn game why would I play slay the spire when last evil exists?
Why the hell play a low quality STS copycat in order to earn tidbits of low quality porn at all? It sounds outright pathetic. To each their own, I guess.
 
Last edited:

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,478
4,077
those cash grabbers and patron milkers you hate fiercely would be updating their project's gameplay
Yeah, they would do it because cash grabbers are known for their efforts for actually finishing their games :FacePalm:

Why the hell play a low quality STS copycat in order to earn tidbits of low quality porn at all? It sounds outright pathetic. To each their own, I guess.
>willingly comes into "Adult Games" forum
>why would anyone want to play a porn game it sounds outright pathetic
Why would anyone want to watch a porn game, it sounds outright pathetic. To each their own, I guess.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon241

omegabox

Member
Jan 3, 2018
178
135
>willingly comes into "Adult Games" forum
>why would anyone want to play a porn game it sounds outright pathetic
Why would anyone want to watch a porn game, it sounds outright pathetic. To each their own, I guess.
Why the hell play a low quality STS copycat in order to earn tidbits of low quality porn at all? It sounds outright pathetic.

I added highlights in this sentence for you in case you still have difficulties understanding. You are welcome.
 

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,478
4,077
Why the hell play a low quality STS copycat in order to earn tidbits of low quality porn at all? It sounds outright pathetic.

I added highlights in this sentence for you in case you still have difficulties understanding. You are welcome.
Thanks, here's the fixed version of previous post:
>willingly comes into "Adult Games" forum
>why would anyone want to play a porn game for porn, it sounds outright pathetic
 

Nihil5320

Member
Jul 2, 2022
388
966
lmao you are dense. The logic is so simple: if focusing on gameplay brings in revenue efficiently (your hypothetical "thousands of people might've decided to not support said games precisely because they lack gameplay" really buy or are willing to support the porn games with elaborated gameplay), those cash grabbers and patron milkers you hate fiercely would be updating their project's gameplay monthly instead of cramming more porn into their "glorified sex animation viewer"
This logic doesn't seem that simple and can also be inverted relatively easily: if pure animation viewer approaches were more profitable then wouldn't the majority of adult games adopt this model?

Realistically both versions of this argument are dumb as they presume that porn game studios form a completely efficient market where a majority of actors have perfect information, are following a money motive and have the capacity to execute a coherent strategy. I haven't seen much evidence that any of this is true.

In reality most porn devs are winging it by the seat of their pants. They might have a good idea for a project but it's limited by funding, some might not be in it for the money, most seem unlikely to conduct thorough market research and some of them (and I'm including Helius here) are severely limited by ability.

I think if you want to find a proxy for what users want the best point would be looking at the most popular games, and those almost universally seem to have some kind of gameplay loop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon241

omegabox

Member
Jan 3, 2018
178
135
This logic doesn't seem that simple and can also be inverted relatively easily: if pure animation viewer approaches were more profitable then wouldn't the majority of adult games adopt this model?
the majority of successful porn games would be featuring good gameplay instead of visual novel and animation player now. Alas, this is apparently not the case in reality, there's not even a trance of trend pointing to that direction.
Are you living in a parallel universe? The majority of adult games are indeed like I said visual novels and animation players, which hardly have any gameplay (if clicking through dialogues is some sort of gameplay).
 

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,478
4,077
Are you living in a parallel universe? The majority of adult games are indeed like I said visual novels and animation players, which hardly have any gameplay (if clicking through dialogues is some sort of gameplay).
Majority isn't visual novels and animation players.
This site allows you see how many visual novels novels it has compared to other games, look at the results:
Untitled.png
And "animation players" are also few but since they don't have a tag there is no way to know their exact numbers. But if you go to latest updates page and filter tag:"3d game" then sort them by views or likes the first page results should only have these "animation viewers" out of 30 results:
  • Wild Life
  • Fallen Doll
  • Honey Select 2
  • Virt A Mate
  • Home Together
Out of 30 results for "3d game" just 5 of them are animation viewers. If that's any indication even the combination of "animation viewers" and virtual novels don't make up the majority of games on this site.
 
May 3, 2020
31
68
Okay, I got quite a good answer: The consumers who paid for the patreon promises are now seething that "it's just a scene viewer bro, we don't need more." Years after years of work for a scene viewer? You guys are really high on copium.

EDIT: and before anyone rushes over to the reply button, crying "b-but the other scene viewers!", a bunch of them listed above have gameplay attached. This game is what... 3 years old now? Since the first release, and I don't even know when was the first development message... so you're basically saying that you waited 3+ years for a handful of characters, some clothing options and a rotating camera around the scenes? Bruh.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Purple_Heart

omegabox

Member
Jan 3, 2018
178
135
Majority isn't visual novels and animation players.
This site allows you see how many visual novels novels it has compared to other games, look at the results:
View attachment 3706470
And "animation players" are also few but since they don't have a tag there is no way to know their exact numbers. But if you go to latest updates page and filter tag:"3d game" then sort them by views or likes the first page results should only have these "animation viewers" out of 30 results:
  • Wild Life
  • Fallen Doll
  • Honey Select 2
  • Virt A Mate
  • Home Together
Out of 30 results for "3d game" just 5 of them are animation viewers. If that's any indication even the combination of "animation viewers" and virtual novels don't make up the majority of games on this site.
bruh is F95 your entire world? I almost feel pity.
Do you know a genre called galgame exists? Most of porn games in visual novel form have not been translated into English due to the sheer volume of texts and are not in this forum.
 
Last edited:

Nihil5320

Member
Jul 2, 2022
388
966
Okay, I got quite a good answer: The consumers who paid for the patreon promises are now seething that "it's just a scene viewer bro, we don't need more." Years after years of work for a scene viewer? You guys are really high on copium.

EDIT: and before anyone rushes over to the reply button, crying "b-but the other scene viewers!", a bunch of them listed above have gameplay attached. This game is what... 3 years old now? Since the first release, and I don't even know when was the first development message... so you're basically saying that you waited 3+ years for a handful of characters, some clothing options and a rotating camera around the scenes? Bruh.
This game is a touch older than 3 years, the Patreon launched in 2016 and it existed before that. Daisy in Summer (the first prototype) was 2015. Development probably started in 2014 when Epic changed their licensing for UE but it was solely on ZOD Forum at that point.

And yeah the animation viewer argument is an odd one.
 

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,478
4,077
bruh is F95 your entire world? I almost feel pity.
Do you know a genre called galgame exists? Most of porn games in visual novel form have not been translated into English due to the sheer volume of texts and are not in this forum.
This site also has untranslated games and a genre that basically only exists in japan literally doesn't change anything. My point still stands, either present your own stats like I did or continue coping...
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Misguided/Entity

cocksucker42069

New Member
May 2, 2024
2
1
Whenever I launch kirito mod this shows up

[17:53:43] KiritoCore: Couldn't init python ImportError: bad magic number in 're': b'\x00\x00\x00\x00'

At:
logging\__init__.py(26): <module>
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(241): _call_with_frames_removed
<frozen importlib._bootstrap_external>(883): exec_module
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(703): _load_unlocked
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(1006): _find_and_load_unlocked
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(1027): _find_and_load
E:\New folder\FallenDoll 0.4.9 rip\Operation Lovecraft Fallen Doll Playtest\Paralogue\Binaries\Win64\debug.py(1): <module>
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(241): _call_with_frames_removed
<frozen importlib._bootstrap_external>(883): exec_module
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(703): _load_unlocked
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(1006): _find_and_load_unlocked
<frozen importlib._bootstrap>(1027): _find_and_load

[17:53:43] KiritoCore: Init failed.
[17:53:43] KiritoCore: Something went wrong, press any key to exit.
Press any key to continue . . .
 

SortaLewd

Member
Feb 26, 2019
397
528
Majority isn't visual novels and animation players.
This site allows you see how many visual novels novels it has compared to other games, look at the results:
View attachment 3706470
And "animation players" are also few but since they don't have a tag there is no way to know their exact numbers. But if you go to latest updates page and filter tag:"3d game" then sort them by views or likes the first page results should only have these "animation viewers" out of 30 results:
  • Wild Life
  • Fallen Doll
  • Honey Select 2
  • Virt A Mate
  • Home Together
Out of 30 results for "3d game" just 5 of them are animation viewers. If that's any indication even the combination of "animation viewers" and virtual novels don't make up the majority of games on this site.
Ngl I think your example is kinda skewered. I use the latest pages with filters to find games too and using your own example, if you showed some of the games posted you'd see most of them are 2dcg/3dcg(a good chunk of 2dcg and 3dcg games are similar to VNs being games that are more dialogue based - Summertime Sage is an example of a 2dcg game)... Meaning a lot of them lack actual gameplay in the sense of what Helius originally promised with the combat mode and are more like visual novels despite not having the visual novel tag. I'd recommend everyone curious to try this and take a look at the games left. Go to the Latest Updates page and click the 'X' on VN to filter them out, then under exclude tags filter out 2dcg and 3dcg and you'll see there's significantly less games available. Now if you also filter out abandoned games and games onhold you're left with a whopping 1k games, and if you looked at some of those a lot of them are still lacking gameplay.

1717673241622.png
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Wlms

Wlms

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2021
1,039
1,653
Ngl I think your example is kinda skewered. I use the latest pages with filters to find games too and using your own example, if you showed some of the games posted you'd see most of them are 2dcg/3dcg(a good chunk of 2dcg and 3dcg games are similar to VNs being games that are more dialogue based - Summertime Sage is an example of a 2dcg game)... Meaning a lot of them lack actual gameplay in the sense of what Helius originally promised with the combat mode and are more like visual novels despite not having the visual novel tag. I'd recommend everyone curious to try this and take a look at the games left. Go to the Latest Updates page and click the 'X' on VN to filter them out, then under exclude tags filter out 2dcg and 3dcg and you'll see there's significantly less games available. Now if you also filter out abandoned games and games onhold you're left with a whopping 1k games, and if you looked at some of those a lot of them are still lacking gameplay.

View attachment 3710287
Leave MY Purple_Heart alone, you impolite bird feral feathered menace !!!

And, huuu, something something wild life something, idk I'm dealing with one hell of an headache atm I can't think straight.
 

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,478
4,077
Ngl I think your example is kinda skewered. I use the latest pages with filters to find games too and using your own example, if you showed some of the games posted you'd see most of them are 2dcg/3dcg(a good chunk of 2dcg and 3dcg games are similar to VNs being games that are more dialogue based - Summertime Sage is an example of a 2dcg game)... Meaning a lot of them lack actual gameplay in the sense of what Helius originally promised with the combat mode and are more like visual novels despite not having the visual novel tag. I'd recommend everyone curious to try this and take a look at the games left. Go to the Latest Updates page and click the 'X' on VN to filter them out, then under exclude tags filter out 2dcg and 3dcg and you'll see there's significantly less games available. Now if you also filter out abandoned games and games onhold you're left with a whopping 1k games, and if you looked at some of those a lot of them are still lacking gameplay.

View attachment 3710287
Those games DO have gameplay mechanics and they are NOT just animation viewers AND most of them have nothing in common with virtual novels(unless you think having a dialogue system is same as being a virtual novel?). For example, you eliminated Karryn's Prison(KP) for being a 2dcg game and basically put it in the same catagory as virtual novels but KP doesn't have any similarities to virtual novels or animation viewers.

I suggest instead of excluding those games try including/searching them. That way you would understand how many unrelated games(unrelated to virtual novels and animation viewers) you are eliminating because you think they are similar to virtual novels and animation viewers when they have basically nothing in common with them.
 

SortaLewd

Member
Feb 26, 2019
397
528
For example, you eliminated Karryn's Prison(KP) for being a 2dcg game and basically put it in the same catagory as virtual novels but KP doesn't have any similarities to virtual novels or animation viewers.

I suggest instead of excluding those games try including/searching them. That way you would understand how many unrelated games(unrelated to virtual novels and animation viewers) you are eliminating because you think they are similar to virtual novels and animation viewers when they have basically nothing in common with them.
This is why I said a good chunk of 2dcg/3dcg games and not all of them. I recommended looking at the games left with your filters and with 2dcg/3dcg filtered out because this is what I do anytime I come to this site to see what's new or have been updated. If you search using these filters you will see most of them are heavily dialogue based and lacking actual gameplay, unless you consider choosing between multiple dialogue options as form of gameplay. This is why I said they're similar to visual novels and not identical and named SummerTime Saga as an example.

Try filtering using 2dcg or 3dcg tags by highest rated with abandoned/onhold games filtered out and it becomes even more apparent. The 3dcg tag in particular is full of examples with an unholy amount of those being Ren'Py games(not shitting on Ren'Py devs).
 
Last edited:
3.80 star(s) 65 Votes