- Dec 10, 2017
- 288
- 740
I was referring to the side story, specifically.- Emphasis mine.
Really? Every girl in this game (with the exception of Susan, who is no longer a factor in the plot) is extremely honest and open with MC and each other, except Karina. Karina lies. Karina manipulates. Karina causes issues for others for her own benefit. You don't have to dislike her (I find her more complex character oddly appealing) but she certainly has given cause.
But in the main game itself, let's talk about "extremely honest with MC and each other". Leah sent Karina to pose as MC's girlfriend as a prank, causing issues for literally everyone there (herself included). Then she expects him to do for her what she failed to do for him. Melody lies to his face about what she's getting all dressed up for (in her defense, she's not required to tell him, but that she lies about what it is, is the opposite of "extremely honest"). Alice is the only one who really hasn't lied to the other girls or the MC. None of them are saints. Even Karina herself has said that she just wants to be treated like an adult. Do the things that Leah does.
What has Karina done that's so wrong? Lied to try and get some booze at a party just like most 18 year-olds would? She sees someone she likes, and decides to try to move things forward with them? Sure, she's lying to her sister, but her sister lied to her, too. And their parents. They behave very much the same way, yet Leah still treats Karina like a child (when the game establishes that they're only a year apart), so Karina does the only thing she knows how to do: play into it, and go behind her back to do what she thinks she's old enough to do. Sure, she's got flaws. They all have flaws. The only reason people focus on Karina's are because they're afraid that the non-canon story will come true, and they won't get to be with Alice, or Leah, or Melody. Hers are highlighted because she "looks too young" or "acts too immature", when that's not a fair argument. She's done nothing worse than some of the things that anyone else has. If you don't like her, that's fine, but she shouldn't be treated like the only one who does anything wrong.