So a few caveats before I say what I want to say:
All that said, something that I think has kept me from enjoying this as much as I should is a lingering feeling of paranoia or jealousy about Alice and Leah. I know that sounds insane/hypocritical/possessive considering how much sex MC has with all the girls, but I can't shake it. I just finished chapter 18 so maybe something in the future will change my mind, but Alice's reaction at the sleepover choice... she just seemed so excited to sleep with Leah. I can't help but think "I'll never really be able to make her happy, if she wasn't worried about her family's reaction, she'd just be with Leah and leave me behind."
I know the game is set to be pretty straightforward with just small branching decisions, so I'm not really looking for a Alice solo route or anything like that, but I wish there was a way to have a conversation with Alice where you both come out and just say something along the lines of "hey we are both having some fun, but at the end of the day you are the only one I really care about". I feel like there is some stuff kinda sorta like that (and maybe there is something more definitive I missed or that is coming up/planned) but I just think too often these games create drama by limiting the player's responses and not letting the characters have deep,honest conversations (you also see this all the time in romantic comedies, for example).
Like I said, this is probably not the reaction of a well-adjusted human
and it doesn't keep me from thinking this game is awesome, I just wanted to get this off my chest. Sometimes getting my thoughts out of my head and onto paper, so to speak, helps me not obsess so much.