In defense of the Rothschild dude. He's been through that routine before.
- His daughter is a troublemaker.
- He wants to keep her under strict control.
- She appears with Guy at home.
- They go to her room.
- Past experiences say they're taking drugs, fucking or both.
So telling the "new" dude to stay away from your daughter is normal in that scenario.
Yeahhh, this was kind of my thought process. It's a pretty standard, "Fuck off and leave my daughter alone," speech, tailored to Guy's specific circumstances. One person in the playtesting phase of Chapter 9 said that they felt like that scene flowed weird. A couple more said the same thing post-release. I don't entirely see it, but it's been brought up by a few people, so I'm willing to believe there's something there. Or rather, something missing.
The supporter who critiqued the scene basically said some things that others here have said -- why didn't Guy push back? He could point out all he's done for the community. He could try to explain to Carl that he has Risa's best interests at heart. He could criticize Carl's 'self-made man' image.
Originally, there was actually a bit where Guy could point out that Carl's real estate empire benefited from an entirely different market, that he grew up in a time when wages were more commensurate to productivity, and so on. But, it just felt off. Like Guy's response was a little too, "Haha, suck it
boomer!" So, I ultimately decided that what made the most sense was for Carl to sit there and recite a little treatise, and for Guy to endure it until he finally either tried to smooth things over, or respond aggressively.
Ultimately, their first meeting was a little bit of table-setting: "Back off, or I'll make life uncomfortable for you." So, that hopefully sets up a more interesting second meeting.
While I have your attention, could I offer a penny for your design thoughts on Mason? With him going through some pretty brutal tough times, I was especially careful handling this one. Starting off, I just wanted to help him get back on his feet and cultivate faith in the idea that there is good in humanity still. As he clearly depicted heterosexual tendencies, my intent was to be a good friend and be there for him. But then as the story progressed, I started getting the feeling that he might be bisexual. And so, I decided to go down the rabbit hole a bit and in one of the engagements, the MC has the opportunity to refer to him as a "her".
So my ultimate question is: how do you plan to handle Mason's character growth? If pursued in a romantic way, will he have a gay/bisexual route with the MC? Or perhaps a threesome love angle with a female LI? Or perhaps the player can pick choices based on meaningful and well meaning interactions that can feminize his character in both personality and looks to be a more "her"? Please note, my intentions are to not invoke a woke based discussion, as that is the last Pandora's box I want to open here. I'm however very curious as to what is in the realm of positive relationship when it'd come to this character without pushing it too far. As far as sexual orientation preferences go, I've none when it comes to games so long as I'm in for a good story.
I'd say Mason is pansexual. I think the mention of him having a girlfriend in his youth kinda threw people. It was just intended to represent that he went through a period of figuring himself out, before he arrived where he is now.
As for ultimate plans: that's a big question. :'D Mason really has three basic routes lined out.
- Love/Corruption - you're nice to Mason, have sex with him, and refer to him by the masculine pronouns he prefers, but you can still refer to him as a girl during sex.
- Friends - you're nice to Mason, and have no sexual interest in him.
- Dark/Corruption - you refer to Mason by feminine pronouns both during and outside of sex. You can be nice, or kind of a dick.
The friends route is pretty self-explanatory. Likewise, the masculine love route, and feminine dark route are pretty straightforward. For the corruption path (call Mason a girl, but otherwise be decent) I see Mason as accepting it as Guy being a basically decent person, who just has some views that aren't entirely in alignment with Mason's. For the love corruption route (call Mason a girl only during sex, but otherwise be nice) I see Mason as accepting it, because it's probably pretty in line with his experience as a sex worker.
Mason's kind of distinct from some of the other love interests, because he is uniquely vulnerable, but also has a uniquely high tolerance for bullshit. Like, another love interest may not be down to be Guy's secret friend-with-benefits, while Guy's in a relationship. Mason has fewer compunctions, because by this point he's slept with a few guys who took their weddings rings off before they fucked him. Likewise, with your question re: threesomes -- it's nothing he hasn't done before, so why be overly precious about it now?
The love route is probably the main exception. I see that one as being just as much about Mason giving, as Guy teaching himself it's okay
not to.
As for the question about changing outfits, looks, etc.. Unfortunately, that's just a
llllot of extra work (and double images), for every scene Mason appears in. I'd expect something similar to what we've seen so far -- Mason presenting fairly masculine/neutral, with special events based around genderplay.
I'm curious is Mason disappointed if I kick the hobo and get his bag back?
Or does he like that I stood up for him?
He doesn't care much, though he does seem pretty freaked out by violence, and eager to avoid it. In that scene, a Good Guy is basically well-intentioned. He's trying to do the right thing. But, he's not looking at the whole picture. He's focused on being the righteous hero and booting a foul-mouthed moron in the balls. But, then he gets to go home to his penthouse. Mason has to continue living in this area, where he could be at the mercy of a guy who's now angry, humiliated, and looking for revenge.
One thing I try to drive home in FiN, is that violence often causes just as many problems as it solves.