I agree with the poster above who suggested she's not as experienced as she is making out, and is winding up her bro for a reaction. It has a high chance of backfiring. After the conversation with his father, I foresee a pre-school visitation from the MC to the alleged rapist, involving a cylindrical, wooden sports object, perhaps whilst wearing full-face, climate control-wear
Thing is, it's called Haley's Story, but by making all the choices, you are defining her story (technically it's your story, the two of you, plus your side bitches!) so far. I started following my heart, and without a walkthrough have a perfect score. So far I haven't noticed any score checks in the script. The dev may decide to wake you up from a coma and use your score in subsequent episodes, IDK but it seems odd to me that bad choices have had no effect on Haley except make her pout :/ (but she loves you, can you really do no wrong?)
I'm rambling now. I'm gonna shut up
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Stick out tongue :p :p"