In other words: you are just salty about the removal of loli and shota from the official release. If you want that stuff go find a mod or add it yourself. Because that's actually the only fetish content that has been removed from the game. Everything else is still there or never existed in the first place.
That screenshot about the fetish selection in the first post here is misleading because it also shows fetish categories for stuff that was never present in the game. I just added some more fetishes to that selection in case mods want to make use of them. But when I changed the code to allow mods to add their own fetishes to that list, I removed all the obsolete entries that were not used in any official content and not likely to ever be.
You are half right.
Like you said the fetish selection had stuff on it that was never in the game.
THAT is the real reason I am "salty".
Also you say it was just shota and loli, but I remember there being SOME bestiality, after the purge however, it seemed reduced. My point is:
You teased people with this big ass checklist of fetishes that people can filter (keyword being FILTER as in choice) depending on what kind of content they wanted. The SCOPE/range of options was the interesting hook for me. Scat? No thanks. Necrophilia? Hmmm, not big on it, but wait.... we can be a killer? Might be cool to do that kind of playthrough. I don't remember them all, there were a lot though. I recall rape content was pretty toned down too. You can downplay it, but the game that had literally a checklist of fetishes pretty much just ended up being a very vanilla experience with some mild mind control (aka soft rape), and what one futa and one trap? If the game still does have bestiality im sure its 1-5 images max. I remember looking at the pics folder for 1.9.5 a year ago or so most folders had 20-30 year old looking male and females in missionary either banging the same or opposite sex. Sorry that's hyperbole there was plenty of standing and doggystyle, maybe even the rare cowgirl, my bad.
"Wow, this game has loli/shota, AND bestiality? Wow they want to add all this other fucked up shit too? The monotonous gameplay seems almost worth it now."
Teasing all this taboo shit, only to go hyper vanilla. Its why the game fell into obscurity if you ask me. Its like planetside 2; nothing else like it out there, but its such a sad sight seeing how wasted its potential became.
Side note: About the whole "just find a mod thing". I was actually helping make a "uncencor" mod for HHS. The dev I was working with straight up dropped it because he was tired of how the modding/creation tool worked.
It seems like the modding tool was too complex for laymen, while being too cumbersome for people who know what they are doing.
I was able to mod a few scenes myself, but the guy I was working with was right, its just cumbersome and not worth it, especially for anything halfway inventive. Just seems so hyper niche why bother. Like figuring out how to host a custom space station 13 server...though that example doesn't hold up since its hit mainstream thanks to certain youtube people.
Honestly though it does suck that the dev I was working with dropped interest, considering he was one of the literal 3 or 4 people that could actually mod HHS. He almost got a whole new feature into the game before leaving too.
One that actually gave lockpicking more worth. The mod would essentially create a new selectable location at the residential screens where you could [lock pick random house] you do the mini game, succeed? Maybe steal some cash and leave, OR RNG scene based on corruption and other factors, ranging from basic family living, to NTR housewives, to incest orgies, you know to support the voyeur fetish crowd? OR maybe do it at night? Boom, sleep rape gameplay. Adding in that one thing opens the doors (intended) to explore multiple new types of scenes that fit different fetishes. So maybe make that a thing, IDK. Seems fairly easy enough since it only took him a few days of me simply describing it and giving the stats it should affect.
Lastly
I would tell you to rename the game to "Hentai University" or something given the type of H content HHS has but someone clearly saw HHS and said "I can do that, and faster too" so they made this:
https://f95zone.to/threads/hentai-university-v9-5-noodlejacuzzi.37312/
*can we just appreciate how the version number is literally one number off too? Shit made me giggle*
I mean LOL look at the second sample pic, ITS PRACTICALLY THE SAME GAME! At least they gave it the more fitting name since the H in that game being full of adults makes sense given its university instead of highschool. Calling HHS, HMHS (Hentai movie highschool) would be more appropriate, cause you know, the people who play teens in movies are in their 20s sometimes 30s.
I just like things that make sense ok?
Imagine you own a pizza joint with a big ass menu, you got veggie lovers, meat lovers, bbq sauce pizza, buffalo, even pineapple (ew amiright?). If someone were to order from your big pizza menu, say the veggie lovers? And I order the pineapple. Then that guy over there orders the meat lovers. Except, when they bring out our orders we are all given cheese pizzas. Except the guy who ordered meat lovers...your pizza parlor definitely has that.
Its not about one fetish in particular, its about teasing that your game would have all these different fetishes and we could pick and choose, only for there to be no choice at all...except people who love meat.