DigitalFire

Member
Aug 20, 2017
440
719
After such a long time, one might think supporters deserve at least a full sex scene with Hermony. Nope! Just random new characters and expansion to existing Minerva scene... We had slow devs and we had directionless devs but we never had slow directionless de... Actually we had, so many of them and this one is the best example so far.
:whistle:
 

Khan

Member
Game Developer
Apr 4, 2017
472
743
After such a long time, one might think supporters deserve at least a full sex scene with Hermony. Nope! Just random new characters and expansion to existing Minerva scene... We had slow devs and we had directionless devs but we never had slow directionless de... Actually we had, so many of them and this one is the best example so far.
:whistle:
All patrons know that we don't rush with sex scenes only for scenes, need enough level of corruption and story. We easily can make a sideshow of scenes for wankers, but Noone will play the game again
 

DigitalFire

Member
Aug 20, 2017
440
719
All patrons know that we don't rush with sex scenes only for scenes, need enough level of corruption and story. We easily can make a sideshow of scenes for wankers, but Noone will play the game again
So writing is the one causes delays? Really? Like the "oh so great story" of your game earned much praise? Also it's not even about the "slow progression" because you seem to "progress" any other character but the main ones since 2018, lol. You adding ugly house-elf bs characters is nothing to do with "slow progression" or "story". You are just baiting people with the main characters and just run circles with BS characters you keep adding to the game. We are talking 8 years of development time, not months.
 

Fuku95

Newbie
Jul 27, 2023
29
6
The Patreon gets $24,000 a month (nearly $300,000/year)--this is the highest I have personally seen for any Patreon page. I would hope it is more than just a hobby with that kind of support.
Wow, Just Wow. It's not nice of game developers to take advantage of slow people like this. 8 years of development with little content? That's some pro milking right there, no wonder people want to become game devs.
 

Jimwalrus

Active Member
Sep 15, 2021
807
3,037
Wow, Just Wow. It's not nice of game developers to take advantage of slow people like this. 8 years of development with little content? That's some pro milking right there, no wonder people want to become game devs.
They're certainly among the of those who still display their monthly earnings.
 

Khan

Member
Game Developer
Apr 4, 2017
472
743
So writing is the one causes delays? Really? Like the "oh so great story" of your game earned much praise? Also it's not even about the "slow progression" because you seem to "progress" any other character but the main ones since 2018, lol. You adding ugly house-elf bs characters is nothing to do with "slow progression" or "story". You are just baiting people with the main characters and just run circles with BS characters you keep adding to the game. We are talking 8 years of development time, not months.
https://f95zone.to/threads/innocent-witches-v0-11-alpha-sad-crab.330/post-8178925
https://f95zone.to/threads/innocent-witches-v0-11-alpha-sad-crab.330/post-9566284
Nothing new to say
 

DigitalFire

Member
Aug 20, 2017
440
719
LOL, these comments have nothing to do with what I just wrote except the last sentence. You just get annoyed at any criticism and start hitting random buttons. I just explained your "strategy" or maybe the lack of confidence. Most likely explanation is that you refrain from main characters and focus on new bs characters that nobody cares because you think if you give enough content for main girls, your audience will be satisfied and be done with the game or maybe they won't be satisfied at all, considering the quality drop of characters in scenes. So you continue with endless bs character content and hold on to the "carrot" as long as you can. Also hide the slow performance of creating scenes under the disguise of " it's a different game, with story, with depth and so on". Come on. You fool enough people, you do you but don't get annoyed when a few of us call it out.
 

suprisedcrankyface

New Member
Dec 7, 2019
8
5
LOL, these comments have nothing to do with what I just wrote except the last sentence. You just get annoyed at any criticism and start hitting random buttons. I just explained your "strategy" or maybe the lack of confidence. Most likely explanation is that you refrain from main characters and focus on new bs characters that nobody cares because you think if you give enough content for main girls, your audience will be satisfied and be done with the game or maybe they won't be satisfied at all, considering the quality drop of characters in scenes. So you continue with endless bs character content and hold on to the "carrot" as long as you can. Also hide the slow performance of creating scenes under the disguise of " it's a different game, with story, with depth and so on". Come on. You fool enough people, you do you but don't get annoyed when a few of us call it out.
The game has free public releases (and not like a freemium game where u then need to pay) & Patreon supporters do so voluntarily. The reason people complain of milking is because they voluntarily show their earnings?

Personally I am not a patreon supporter on this one as I tend to support smaller projects that are getting underway (once they have shown its not a cut & run). Patreon supporters are free to stop at any time, its their choice how they spend their money.

This game is more Hogwarts focused than Hermione focused, so its more expansive in terms of the characters. If you checkout Witch Trainer Silver it also has slow updates and often focuses on side characters (given the game was entirely about hermione) but again I like that game, when its ready for a release they release something.

Is the dev time slow - yes, but if i am getting a free dinner the chef can take their time.

My big complaint? The game is extremely mod unfriendly outside of altering images. If they are going to take huge gaps for updates at least let people make their own fun in those gaps.

Edit: Second complaint, Daphne never does the things in the cover art (if you use it as art to promote your game then probably should have a storyline like that in there).
 
Last edited:

RoninKai

Newbie
Sep 5, 2017
52
84
I want to enjoy this game so much I love the art and it actually tries to pull of a story, like an actual story instead of just an excuse for porn! Ok well it is just an excuse for porn but they try damnit!

The problem is, as it almost always is, the MC. I just can't stand Marcus. Rarely have I seen an MC that makes the worst possible choices literally all the time. Not a single thing he does makes sense for anyone past puberty, seriously how did he graduate school let alone go into medicine? Last I checked you need to be smart for that and Marcus doesn't have 2 brain cells to rub together. Pretty much every student in the school is more competent than him and watching him fumble around trying to do anything is like watching mister magoo except Marcus isn't even funny!

Yes I know I know the bumbling idiot is supposed to be funny to make the story less serious and lighthearted but he isn't! Nothing he does is charming or funny or endearing it's just cringe and I want to slap the stupid out of him everytime he talks. The only girl that should remotely like him is Daphne and that's only because he would be so easy to manipulate so it would be less her liking him and more her getting a new puppet. Fuck Marcus, he should just go to the lake and let the mermaid take him for good, game over end of story. The entire school and magical world would be better off with him dead and gone.

Either go the Witch Trainer route and make something actually funny and sexy with minimal plot or remove the attempts at humor and make Marcus actually likeable by making him the bare minimum of competent. That way we can actually care about him as we sit through hours and hours of story. I mean seriously ask yourself this, if Marcus took the place of Harry Potter in the original HP story would any of you get past the first chapter? Rhetorical question the answer is no. Making us suffer through his bullshit just to get some decent lewds is not worth the headache it takes to get there.
 

Xante

Newbie
Jul 24, 2017
47
17
how's the porn in this now? i played this ages back closer to when it first came out and it was just a bunch of tease content at the time?
 
3.00 star(s) 318 Votes