DIRTY FILTHY Animal

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 11, 2020
7,913
25,907
I also miss more male competition for MC. Zach is okay but as we know he betrays MC. I think it would give the game more exciting situations if there would be other male characters who are after the same girls like MC. Because you are fully right...all the girls seem to like the MC only just like he is the only guy in town.
Please I wish some other male character would take Layla away from me
 

mnotwoke

Active Member
Apr 11, 2022
637
2,066
Valeria only shows up if you have high points with her.
I personally prefer the "John comes to the rescue" scene since he is prime suspect of being Erynn's father, it's good to get him involved in this story at the earliest possible point.
He also looks like good backup rather than someone who we'll need to rescue later.

Nothing wrong with the Val path but this particular appearance felt very gratuitous.


I do see the vision, unfortunately it's an overly dark, heavy handed, vision.
The story of a girl who is hurt and damaged... and the situation just keeps getting worst.
Enjoyed the drama in this game when it was girl vs girl drama... Will they find out? How they'll react? That was fun to me(and it's being written out in a rather quick fashion btw)...
Putting abuse into the story... it's pushing it.

This contrasts big time with the story of most other girls who are all about dating and fun sexy times.
And this game being a "pick one" kind of game, it leads to a bunch of people simply being "i'm out" despite her being the one that is actually instrumental to the story.


Good news for Elena fans, hopefully you won't to wait much longer.
Candidates for 3some? Elena+Layla seems the most likely choice to me.
Gabi is not a happy ending it seems, being older, his teacher and married to the likely bio father of the MC, it doesn't surprise me.
I still wanna see how this shit blows up :p , specially on the "shoot inside route" :cool:.

As for Zach... the choice has been made, it's death.
After reading your reply, and now that I think about it, I agree that the John save works better for the narrative, especially how this relates to Erryn's problem. And the emotional reveal will really be potentially explosive and moving once John and Erryn learn of their relationship.

Elena-Layla threesome seems the most plausible since Layla is exploring all these fetishes. I'm guessing Elena is more sexually experienced than Layla.

I agree, Gabi and MC plus his dad will go very badly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

mnotwoke

Active Member
Apr 11, 2022
637
2,066
I got once John and once Val as my hero in this sequence. The Val scene ends very romantic.
As i remember to get Val it does not matter if u have Alexis or Layla as GF u just need to get enough hits on Val at every chance. One guy just posted a few days ago here that there is also a third option i wanna try out where u get only hit by Zach and Ethan just curse you verbally without a fight. This happenes if u never help Erynn anyway and may u must be on Laylla path.

Thanks for the advice on Valeria.

I wonder if the third option also happens if instead of training with Layla, you have sex with Alexis in your room, Erryn catches you both and you choose to either lie about Erryn which causes her to end her relationship with you or tell the truth which causes both women to end their relationship with you.
 

mnotwoke

Active Member
Apr 11, 2022
637
2,066
Some more thoughts and observations on the game


At her best, Nyx uses similar characters ,scenes, situations, and finds interesting and fun character and plot progression variations that aren't repetitive or redundant

Narrative Mirror Scenes, Parallel Narrative Lines, Parallel Scenes, Plot Devices, Motifs, Comparison and Contrast, Scene Variations

-Meet your past on the airplane - Alexis, Iris

- Feel how fast my heart is beating MC- Alexis, Valeria

- Truth or Dare Positive or Negative - Layla, Cara, secondary-Valeria, Elena

- Ho Lady - Tori, Julia, Rachel

-Bar Temptations - Tori, Julia

- Oedipus Complex variation - screwing your dad's wife who's not really your mom

- Photo Op plot advancement plant, payoff - Iris, Alexis, Erryn, Layla, Andres evidence of cheating

- MC Terrible dancer, but you're not as bad as you think - Layla, Nikki

- Bar Make Out Moment - Cara Birthday Kiss, Layla pretend girlfriend

- Beach fun, banter, pranks, suntan lotion, water pranks, pull shorts down - Layla, Nikki, Elena

- Bucket list sex - airplane rest room, dad's motorcycle

- Three Guy Gang-up on MC - Emmanuel Gang, Ethan Gang, Lucas (Aborted, turned solo assault)

- Parental Figure Surprise Reveal to Child who rage walks out - Andres I'm engaged and we're moving in with them, Emily He's not your dad

- Sister Action with MC - Alexis-Layla, Cara-Nikki, Iris-Erryn

- Nip slips - Emily, Layla, Elena

- Throw in the Pool Play with MC- Melissa, Erryn, Layla, Val, Elena, Gabi

-Cock Block the Violent Douche-Ethan-Erryn, Lucas-Layla

- Driving Mr. MC - Alexis, Erryn, Nikki, Nathan, Cara (reverse)

- Clothing Device - MC- Nikki White workout shirt, underwear swap maybe more important for Valeria than Layla

-Lick My MC - Iris, Valeria

-Shower Sex-Alexis, Nikki

- He's (not) my boyfriend - Erryn clothing store lady, Layla MC wins race sports agent

-Elena Lockers Slap Ass - Slap MC post Layla pretend girlfriend scene, slap Layla post Spanish test results

-Carry the drunk Lady - Elena, Nikki

-Early morning romance runs - Nikki, Valeria

- Raspberry shampoo - Alexis, Valeria

- Taste in Music - Alexis, Valeria

- Workout Partners - Nikki, Layla, Valeria, Elena

- Tattoo Terror Tag Team - The best guy to have with you in a fight, also has tatoos, Nathan, John

- Tattooed Ladies - Lakeyn, Melissa

- We repeat our patterns if we are not aware - MC-Alexis-Erryn triangle and other triangles, potential Emily-John-Melissa triangle

- "I should have knocked" scenes - MC, Cara, Nikki

- It's important the MC to make the ladies laugh and smile, enjoyment or cheering them up (Cara birthday dance, Erryn cappuccino post Ethan assault, Gabi training camp sexy time)

- Seat Partners - Elena-MC, Alexis-MC, Valeria-MC, Layla-MC, Iris-MC

- He's so much fun thought bubble - Alexis, Layla, Nikki, Elena

- Always make a good impression on their mothers - Melissa, Haley, Adriana (and fathers John)

Miscellaneous

- Why are John's tattoos different or missing from the time the MC first meets him (more tattoos) to the time you reconnect in the garage (less tattoos)?

- Ladies are either sexually experienced, like to flirt and tease, sexually inexperienced or have sexual trauma

- The black characters' depictions needs a lot of improvement

- If the MC is 6 foot 1, there seems to be a lot of tall ladies in this game.

- Is it difficult for the MC to have more male friends because of his upbringing?

- Like LSC82 said, will their be life altering pregnancies for this generation of characters like what happened with Emily's generation?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

NewTricks

Forum Fanatic
Nov 1, 2017
4,423
9,511
I got once John and once Val as my hero in this sequence. The Val scene ends very romantic.
As i remember to get Val it does not matter if u have Alexis or Layla as GF u just need to get enough hits on Val at every chance. One guy just posted a few days ago here that there is also a third option i wanna try out where u get only hit by Zach and Ethan just curse you verbally without a fight. This happenes if u never help Erynn anyway and may u must be on Laylla path.
The Val scene was funny as hell. She comes in like Miss Piggy and just goes "hi ya!" with the flying jump kick and then dude pulls her hair like it is two girls fighting. I don't think that I liked Val much until that scene. She was just another girl in a game too full of girls until that point. It was the first thing that made her stick out from the crowd.
 

Talmadge

Well-Known Member
May 7, 2018
1,570
1,238
Hold the phone. I've seen where people are talking about how your relationship with Lexi ends when she finds out your messing around with Layla or something like that. But I just got to the point where Erynn found out about the Lexi and the MC. I would have thought that, when the MC confronts Lexi, that it would be the end of the relationship.
 

SolarEclipsed

I may be wrong it happened once.
Donor
Nov 6, 2017
1,508
3,967
Hold the phone. I've seen where people are talking about how your relationship with Lexi ends when she finds out your messing around with Layla or something like that. But I just got to the point where Erynn found out about the Lexi and the MC. I would have thought that, when the MC confronts Lexi, that it would be the end of the relationship.
You can choose to end the relationship there, however you can choose to forgive her and continue the relationship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Talmadge

Talmadge

Well-Known Member
May 7, 2018
1,570
1,238
You can choose to end the relationship there, however you can choose to forgive her and continue the relationship.
Cool. I guess I ended it because I chose the angry approach. Liked the Lexi character, but since Erynn is the main LI of the story, I thought only fitting to make my first run through focusing on her mainly. I'll play through again for different girls later on.
 

Canto Forte

Post Pro
Jul 10, 2017
21,164
25,947
Pretty wholesome experiences there:
The main LI of the story, the babe some consider the girl talked about above
well, she is constantly seeing some other dudes,
kicking MC out because she needed to think only to let another dude inside ..
pretty sure that is what girls with many guys do every day.

Then she she goes out with another dude, guess going out with MC was not what she wanted.

She keeps going to parties with different men every time, pretty sure anyone seeing her knows what she does.

MC cannot be any less angry after so many duded keep taking the supposed LI out while he gets the boot.

To each their own, I guess.
 

Puma1978

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2022
1,496
1,845
The Val scene was funny as hell. She comes in like Miss Piggy and just goes "hi ya!" with the flying jump kick and then dude pulls her hair like it is two girls fighting. I don't think that I liked Val much until that scene. She was just another girl in a game too full of girls until that point. It was the first thing that made her stick out from the crowd.
Yes the approach to Val was a little carefully written in my opinion...seems the Dev Nyx has some special ideas regfarding the relationship between Val and MC..one of the rumors is that Val is Gabi's daughter and Gabis husband is real father of MC so that makes Val and MC....:)...
 

Puma1978

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2022
1,496
1,845
Pretty wholesome experiences there:
The main LI of the story, the babe some consider the girl talked about above
well, she is constantly seeing some other dudes,
kicking MC out because she needed to think only to let another dude inside ..
pretty sure that is what girls with many guys do every day.

Then she she goes out with another dude, guess going out with MC was not what she wanted.

She keeps going to parties with different men every time, pretty sure anyone seeing her knows what she does.

MC cannot be any less angry after so many duded keep taking the supposed LI out while he gets the boot.

To each their own, I guess.
Thats why i think the best eritten LI from the very beginning until current end of chapter 9 is Lexi.
Of course a lot of girls are maybe mor interesting but the script so far works and fits best with Lexi. She is as GF the best integrated character so far. May Nyx will add deeper details also to other LI's later.
 

Talmadge

Well-Known Member
May 7, 2018
1,570
1,238
Pretty wholesome experiences there:
The main LI of the story, the babe some consider the girl talked about above
well, she is constantly seeing some other dudes,
kicking MC out because she needed to think only to let another dude inside ..
pretty sure that is what girls with many guys do every day.

Then she she goes out with another dude, guess going out with MC was not what she wanted.

She keeps going to parties with different men every time, pretty sure anyone seeing her knows what she does.

MC cannot be any less angry after so many duded keep taking the supposed LI out while he gets the boot.

To each their own, I guess.
I agree with some of what your saying. But maybe she goes out with these other guys and pushes the MC back because she doesn't feel like she deserves his love because of what happened when he first confessed it all those years ago. Now, to fill that void, she goes out with other men, subconsciously knowing that it's the MC she really wants to be with. But afraid the MC will reject her like she did. I don't know. Just my opinion. I haven't gotten very far yet, just had the mom tell the MC who his father is. But from what I've read, sounds like a part of it is Ethan's blackmail as well. Maybe he is making her go out with some of these men.
 

NebulousShooter

Engaged Member
Donor
Oct 24, 2018
3,213
22,404
Yes the approach to Val was a little carefully written in my opinion...seems the Dev Nyx has some special ideas regfarding the relationship between Val and MC..one of the rumors is that Val is Gabi's daughter and Gabis husband is real father of MC so that makes Val and MC....:)...
Most of Val's reactions when Gabi is around and the formal way she responds the Agent after Zack embarrasses her in front of him, makes me be 99% sure there is some connection there. Don't know if its mother-daughter, aunt, but something is going on.
 

Canto Forte

Post Pro
Jul 10, 2017
21,164
25,947
Problem with any of her antics is that MC is kept wanting but fed up with her rejections.
Right now, MC is a bomb of rage because she is essentially cucking him with all the other guys.
This game is well made to push MC further and further away, which she does every chance she gets.
MC cannot get too much of a win here and there before she goes out with some other dude.
MC is helpless and is angry to feel so much of what he is and what he does just does not register with her.
In his life, he broke any and all communications once she showed him she was more interested in ethan,
that has not changed, time and time again she shows MC she is more interested in ethan,
whatever the interes is, much more invested in that dude, the same one she rejected MC over,
than she ever showed interest in MC.
I agree with some of what your saying. But maybe she goes out with these other guys and pushes the MC back because she doesn't feel like she deserves his love because of what happened when he first confessed it all those years ago. Now, to fill that void, she goes out with other men, subconsciously knowing that it's the MC she really wants to be with. But afraid the MC will reject her like she did. I don't know. Just my opinion. I haven't gotten very far yet, just had the mom tell the MC who his father is. But from what I've read, sounds like a part of it is Ethan's blackmail as well. Maybe he is making her go out with some of these men.
Even removing any ill intent from ethan .. .
Would you pursue a girl you had passion for if she spent that much time with someone from work?
The same guy she rejected you for? The same guy she had all the time and effort and passion to spend with,
whatever they talked about, she wanted to cater to that dude first and MC was and still is on the last place.


She treated MC like a homeless childhood friend she felt and still feels sorry for.
MC is angry with himself as he cannot let himself just forget about her and dissapear again.
On the other hand, there can never be any healthy relationship with a girl who disses MC so cathegorically,
while still to this day dating and going out and spending the time with ethan rather than MC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alternativ8

Puma1978

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2022
1,496
1,845
Problem with any of her antics is that MC is kept wanting but fed up with her rejections.
Right now, MC is a bomb of rage because she is essentially cucking him with all the other guys.
This game is well made to push MC further and further away, which she does every chance she gets.
MC cannot get too much of a win here and there before she goes out with some other dude.
MC is helpless and is angry to feel so much of what he is and what he does just does not register with her.
In his life, he broke any and all communications once she showed him she was more interested in ethan,
that has not changed, time and time again she shows MC she is more interested in ethan,
whatever the interes is, much more invested in that dude, the same one she rejected MC over,
than she ever showed interest in MC.


Even removing any ill intent from ethan .. .
Would you pursue a girl you had passion for if she spent that much time with someone from work?
The same guy she rejected you for? The same guy she had all the time and effort and passion to spend with,
whatever they talked about, she wanted to cater to that dude first and MC was and still is on the last place.


She treated MC like a homeless childhood friend she felt and still feels sorry for.
MC is angry with himself as he cannot let himself just forget about her and dissapear again.
On the other hand, there can never be any healthy relationship with a girl who disses MC so cathegorically,
while still to this day dating and going out and spending the time with ethan rather than MC.
I also had to learn from Erryn Fans that its a little more complicated to understand the actual relationship between Erynn and MC. There is a dialog scene where we learn that Erynn was trying to contact MC and writing him letters after he left. Then there is obviousley the fact that Erynn is not with Ethan and never had sex with him. But she had a boyfriend Zane ( i guess thats the name) and when she had first time sex with Zane, Ethan was stalking her and recorded the video of her defloration. And with this video now Ethan is blackmailing her to do things she doesn't really want to do but she must do it otherwise Ethan will publish the video that she cant get any other job.
Also for me all about Erynn is not really written on a way tvat i feel close to her. My opinion is that the Alexis path is the best written currently throughout the whole story with many details, romance, sex and surprises.
 
Dec 29, 2018
414
2,545
My opinion is that the Alexis path is the best written currently throughout the whole story with many details, romance, sex and surprises.
One of the good things about the Alexis path is that it is very believable and easy to understand. She meets a guy who she thinks is hot, only to find out that it was someone she knew as a kid who she thought was adorable and sweet. She's a bit conflicted because knows that she should tell him the truth about her and Erynn, but she decides to be a little bit selfish and things quickly spiral into a bigger problem. From there, she just keeps avoiding the problem by putting it off and telling herself that she can deal with it later when the time is right. Everyone knows how is it is to get stuck in a procrastination loop, so even if people think she is being foolish, they can at least understand why she keeps freezing up like a deer in the headlights instead of biting the bullet. She's afraid that all of the fun she's having will come to an end when she tells the truth, so she just wants to hold on a bit longer. It's selfish, but understandable.

Another good example of a simple and effective path is the one for Elena. She meets a nice guy, but never considers him as a potential boyfriend because she's too busy for one. He starts to date her best friend, which leads to them spending a lot of time together. She sees how nice he is, and has a lot of fun with him, and starts to get feelings for him. Which puts her in an awkward position because she also sees how happy her friend is and doesn't want to ruin that. It's simple, easy to follow, and understandable.

An example of a route that's a bit too complicated and difficult to understand would be Erynn's path. There are a bunch of small details that make it different from a standard love triangle, and it gets a bit too convoluted for me. I don't understand how Ethan could almost break up Alexis and Erynn by claiming to have slept with Alexis? Why would Erynn be upset by that if it was before Ethan started blackmailing her? And how does Erynn think that we can save her from Ethan if we aren't allowed to say or do anything about it? And when did she start to view the MC in a romantic way? Did she call dibs on him sometime in the five years they weren't in contact with each other? He was only twelve when he left, so that would be a bit odd, no?

There's a lot of unanswered questions about Erynn, and they keep me from getting invested in her story. Maybe things will change when some of these questions are answered, but for now I just don't care.
 
4.40 star(s) 274 Votes