According to the story,
Flashback - Emily is 18 (Had MC at 18), Melissa is 20 (Had Erynn at 18), Adriana (Always busy may be she had Alexis) are freshman and are kind of room mates.
Erynn and MC are 3 years apart. After Santiago knows Emily is pregnant, Santi's parents came and said Emily that "they have their whole lives ahead and they offered money", Emily rejected and had MC (MC called Andres dad and then the PROMISE to not tell him).
Present - Alexis and Erynn are sophomores and are best friends. Alexis is older than MC. MC and Layla are in same class. MC can do anyone.
Gabi's relationship with Navarro isn't established yet according to these photos.
View attachment 3518268
View attachment 3518216
View attachment 3518243
How come Navarro alias Santiago/Mc's dad/Gabi's (likely Husband or Bro)/Alexis and Layla's dad all be same?
Am I correct? or Am I missing some plot in the game?
My theory is either Santiago is a Player alias Manwhore or there is some plot hole in this story.
Right order (May be):
First: Navarro + Adriana (Highschool and college) -> Alexis (Before MC)
Second: Navarro + Emily (Highschool and college) -> MC (Navarro may be cheating)
Third: Navarro + Adriana (After Emily) -> Layla (May be both Emily and Adriana are pregnant at the same time)
Fourth: Navarro + Gabi (Either bro/husband) -> Navarro may be cheating again all these years. So Gabi got divorced.
It doesn't seem like Navarro is Alexis and Layla's step dad (reason being they are very close in the game like a real dad and daughter)
My verdict: This is either a brilliant game or a weird story game where friends don't talk to each other.
My plot hole points:
1. As Emily said that she met Santiago a few times, she would have asked who did he marry?
2. Why would Emily want to date John? (Erynn's dad)
3. Who is Gabi to Navarro? (Husband or Brother)
4. Do Adriana and Gabi not talk about their lives (husbands)?
5. Do Melissa and Adriana not talk about their lives (husbands)?
6. As Alexis and Erynn are best friends, do they not talk about their moms? (Emily doesn't even know Adriana is Alexis mom and a principal of that school)
7. As Melissa and Emily are best friends, do they not talk about their Ex-husbands? Like what are they doing?
There are still many plot holes wandering in my mind. God knows what developer is thinking. I need clarification.