justin.case

Member
Sep 14, 2023
298
356
I think the only 100% absolute thing Nyx has said is there will be no incest. Until she shows anything else in the game it'd be safe to assume she's just trolling the incest fans, as she seems to enjoy doing it.
MC and Melissa is not related, nor John and Emily. So no incest going on there. Iirc, she gave LI list which included Melissa and excluded Val.
Nikki was also supposed to die, according to Nyx, but she is now a LI. You can't take a lot that Nyx says seriously, other than it might be trolling. Unless it's in the game, it's not set in stone.
Iirc, it was an answer to that on discord. She said she changed Nikki's path but not going to change Val's. Though, you are right, nothing she said can be trusted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
498
615
MC and Melissa is not related, nor John and Emily. So no incest going on there. Iirc, she gave LI list which included Melissa and excluded Val.
Ahh misread your first part. You mentioned Emily's name, then John, then said if they were dating it could open an LI path. You were referring to Emily and John dating, and that possibly opening Mel's path? I hope not.

If the MC has enough Emily Points, and he says he'd prefer she didn't, then she won't date John. So that'd lock anyone out of a possible Mel path for anyone that didn't let them date. There'd have to be an alternate path to Mel's if it's added, should you decline Emily dating John. If Mel gets a path, I think/hope it'll be unrelated to Emily dating John.

Iirc, it was an answer to that on discord. She said she changed Nikki's path but not going to change Val's. Though, you are right, nothing she said can be trusted.
That's making an assumption that Nyx didn't/doesn't have a path worked out for Val and just hasn't been talking about it. Or more deliciously, trolling about it.
 

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,082
2,159
I can see Nyx pulling some shit where she dies on one path and not the other as with previous LI like Alexis and Erynn if you fuck up bad Nyx has no issue basically getting rid of them from your path / game unless you have to interact with them
I'm completely opposite on this. I can't see it at all because it would vastly increase development time. You suddenly need double the scenes/dialogue related to the aftermath of her death from now until the end of the VN.
It's why most deaths in other VNs (Megan/Melissa, Stella) are canon events that happen regardless of route.

Nyx has no problem dunking the MC for the player making bad decisions but Alexis isn't going to wind up dead in a ditch somewhere if you two time her and Erynn. She will end up dead in a ditch if she calls Melissa a milf though.
 

justin.case

Member
Sep 14, 2023
298
356
Ahh misread your first part. You mentioned Emily's name, then John, then said if they were dating it could open an LI path. You were referring to Emily and John dating, and that possibly opening Mel's path? I hope not.
Yeah, I had to check Melissa's name, could not remember so it was kinda hard to understand that part. I feel like Mel waiting for John's return so, if she learns about John and Emily and how happy Emily is, then she could give up on John. This could mean she could give a chance to new opportunities. If Emily realizes John is the Mel's ex, I don't think she would go against MC&Mel relationship. I think MC not being on Erynn's path, MC helping Erynn also needed.

If the MC has enough Emily Points, and he says he'd prefer she didn't, then she won't date John. So that'd lock anyone out of a possible Mel path for anyone that didn't let them date. There'd have to be an alternate path to Mel's if it's added, should you decline Emily dating John. If Mel gets a path, I think/hope it'll be unrelated to Emily dating John.
Could be, I thought that's a likely possibility, that's all.

That's making an assumption that Nyx didn't/doesn't have a path worked out for Val and just hasn't been talking about it. Or more deliciously, trolling about it.
She is basically trolling about everything but she said she is serious about that. Still though, Nyx being Nyx is possible.
 

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
498
615
I feel like Mel waiting for John's return so, if she learns about John and Emily and how happy Emily is, then she could give up on John. This could mean she could give a chance to new opportunities. If Emily realizes John is the Mel's ex, I don't think she would go against MC&Mel relationship. I think MC not being on Erynn's path, MC helping Erynn also needed.
I would say if Emily and John dating was canon in the game, it'd be an easier sell. The only problem is that there's a 50/50 chance that a player will chose that route, assuming they have enough Mel points.

All my main playthroughs (all LIs) I declined Emily dating John. So I'd never get to see Mel's path then until I get around to the secondary ones. That'd be annoying to me. Emily and Brooke will be together before I get Emily and John together.

My secondary playthroughs (also all LIs) Emily is dating John, but they are not my first interest so I'll get to them at some point. If I can't get Emily and Brooke together, Emily and John will be my bottom priority.
 

justin.case

Member
Sep 14, 2023
298
356
I would say if Emily and John dating was canon in the game, it'd be an easier sell. The only problem is that there's a 50/50 chance that a player will chose that route, assuming they have enough Mel points.

All my main playthroughs (all LIs) I declined Emily dating John. So I'd never get to see Mel's path then until I get around to the secondary ones. That'd be annoying to me. Emily and Brooke will be together before I get Emily and John together.

My secondary playthroughs (also all LIs) Emily is dating John, but they are not my first interest so I'll get to them at some point. If I can't get Emily and Brooke together, Emily and John will be my bottom priority.
Maybe but it's not uncommon in this game. If you don't choose Layla, you can't get Elena or if you choose Layla you can't get Val. I can't remember all but I think there were some paths to choose to reach other paths. So hiding Mel's path behind Emily&John dating is not against dev's MO. :unsure:

Btw, I don't get Brooke obsession, she is weird and possibly a murderer. :LOL:
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

cooldevo

Member
Jan 30, 2021
498
615
Maybe but it's not uncommon in this game. If you don't choose Layla, you can't get Elena or if you choose Layla you can't get Val. I can't remember all but I think there were some paths to choose to reach other paths. So hiding Mel's path behind Emily&John dating is not against dev's MO. :unsure:

Btw, I don't get Brooke obsession, she is weird and possibly a murderer. :LOL:
Elena's path, assuming there will be a full LI path, is virtually impossible to just stumble across. Same with the ASP path. If you don't know it's there, the chance of just stumbling across it while playing is near zero.

Brooke's personality, outgoing nature, and passion, would be a fantastic fit for Emily. She needs someone just like Brooke to draw Emily out of her quiet restaurant-oriented life. Mel is very similar to Brooke, personality-wise and Mel and Emily go very well together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maviarab

Ozymandias037

Member
Sep 25, 2023
107
330
From a storyline perspective, it makes no sense to murder a character that we're still learning things about and who has mysterious things about her in the game.
From a porn game perspective, it makes no sense to get rid of a li before we even clap those cheeks.
Finally, in that final scene, it sounded like Ethan's bitch ass feared Val. I imagine it's likely due to who her parents are, which is why we still don't know who they are.
I agree with all of this. I would also add, nothing about Ethan so far has made me think "this dude is dangerous." Ethan is not capable of murder. He's an entitled douchecanoe who thinks the world owes him what he wants because he's daddy's special boy. He orders henchmen around because it makes his balls feel big but he can't handle his own business.

This isn't to say that he's not capable of some fucked up things. I wouldn't put sexual assault or rape past him even a little bit. He'd probably beat the snot out of MC if his goons tied MC up first so he coudn't fight back. He'd definitely slap a woman around. But murder? Nah. He doesn't have it in him.
 

TonyMurray

Engaged Member
Apr 8, 2024
3,101
5,342
Talking of canon and possibilities and incest... If Emily and John end up going well and they get married, that would make John MC's step-father. That would make Iris MC's step-sister. Once things are (presumably) confirmed, that would also make Erynn MC's step-sister. Given that Patreon's rules include stepcest, that would mean Erynn (and Iris) would be taken off the table as LI's/lewdables.

Therefore, it won't work out, John will end up going to Melissa once they are reintroduced, and Mommy Brooke will become Step-Mommy Brooke (it's okay, we've already tried and she said she's not into guys).

Slight joking aside though, I don't actually think this will be an issue because the game won't go on for long enough for Emily and John to get married, and the step-stuff wouldn't come into play unless they do.

Can't wait for the Intertwined spinoff all about Brooke's murder spree.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I'd absolutely play that one!
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

minibaer12

Well-Known Member
Oct 1, 2023
1,189
1,840
Talking of canon and possibilities and incest... If Emily and John end up going well and they get married, that would make John MC's step-father. That would make Iris MC's step-sister. Once things are (presumably) confirmed, that would also make Erynn MC's step-sister. Given that Patreon's rules include stepcest, that would mean Erynn (and Iris) would be taken off the table as LI's/lewdables.
I'm more thinking that John is Erynn's father and then there are three very interesting consequences:

- a very interesting conversation between Melissa and Emily
- how will John react to the blackmailing of his daughter, then
- how will Erynn and Iris react

let's just wait and see what Nyx decides
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82
4.40 star(s) 302 Votes