He's not entitled to come around acting like an asshole, after he was an asshole for the last 5 years... i'm starting to wonder why you consider this "reasonable" or he is in a position to make demands.
It's good that he spoke his mind, but he was out of line acting like that.
I'm confused: how is he an asshole for speaking his mind here and getting to the bottom of what really happened 5 years prior?
Asshole for not doing it sooner, agreed 100%. Probably the same for not just getting the elephant out of the way sooner too.
She witnessed some of it yes, which is why she understands why the MC doesn't like Ethan.
She would still be within her rights to hang out with him, if she thinks that he's grown and became a better guy since.
We don't get to chose who our friends are friends with.
And all this discussion is a fucking moot point as it relates to Erynn because both you and i know that Erynn hangs out with Ethan against her will and not because she wants to.
That's not the point of contention. Its her continued relationship with Ethan while trying to rekindle the friendship with MC, AND knowing it will come out, but delaying when it does.
But you are correct on one thing:you did allude to Erynn trying to get it out sooner, and during my replay of the scene from the past and the aftermath, i see the dialogue there so I stand corrected on that.
What exactly are you holding Erynn accountable for, getting blackmailed?
Yeah she could've handled it better, i just made a post to
Maviarab touching on that.
This right here,she needed to nip this in the bud much sooner. As with most things in life that people try to hide, the more you do so, the more it will hurt when it comes out.
And if you
JeSinclair (not the MC anymore)comes around from your position of oversight and knowledge, criticizing characters for not handling things exactly the way that you want them too, you are judging.
I respectfully, disagree.
I don't judge Erynn the character - but I hold her accountable for the bad choice, which while many people would probably make the same mistake, it never turns out well.
As the MC states:
MC : "How do you know for sure that he really has a video if you didn't see it?"
Erynn: "..."
MC: "Erynn, seriously. You are one of the smartest people I know, I'm sorry but that's pretty dumb!"
MC: "For fuck sake... you know he can't be trusted..."
Now we as players know the video is real and out there. But at this point, she didn't. She did exactly what MC does: assume.
That assumption is what I hold accountable. Just as we hold MC accountable for being a massive prick with 5 years of no contact based on an assumption.
Her assumption has kept her a victim.