Veronica is definitely an interesting character, but
1) She requires specific TFs, including having breasts, which is a big no for me (it's especially unpleasant for me because I just naturally have A-cup breasts as a cis guy and they are pissing me off tremendously)
2) Both Alice and Natalie are just more appealing to me. Not by much, but they are. Alice ticks all of my kinks and Natalie is just so wholesome I get diabetes.
Personally story wise of all the characters not only did she have the best earth scene (at least in my opinion) but despite her quirks and attitude like Natalie and Alice Veronica does truly care for Eric(a). Plus while Natalie does also have the bar for saving Eric(a)'s life so does Veronica (assuming you choose to lose to the life drinker magico and you had a dinner date aboard her ship) This and the fact that out of all of the girls she has the greatest tech smarts turned me towards her character.
Alice has my #2 spot for the girls on the team. Despite her quirks I am a sucker for tragic pasts and while Natalie also has this unlike Alice Natalie choose to stay with her abusive sisters when she could have very well just left with the archangel. Alice had no such luxury. When I see Alice she reminds me of the doll Sabrina held in the old pokemon series. In other words she was just a lonely girl who wanted to make friends. Sure she goes about it the wrong way (using mind control to try and make friends) but with what happened to her in the past and how fucked up in the head she was I honestly can't fault her for this. P
Natalie sadly bottoms out my list. Now don't get me wrong Natalie has some things that I do like going for her such as having the demon girl thing (since she is the daughter of a Lilith) and out of all the girls she seems the least violent and sane however the term stereotypical blonde describes her perfectly. If I could choose any character to describe her she would basically be a slightly smarter Lindsay from Total Drama series since unlike the former she can remember people's names.
I mean this girl is so dimwitted that she literally handed one of the cores they worked so hard to acquire to the very same thief who stole the Mimic core just because it was 'too cold'. I mean come on. She had literally 3 other people she could have given the core to (Eric(a) Alice, or Veronica) that were on her team, and even prior to this Veronica literally mentioned that Eric(a) was originally the designated core collector so why did she not only decide to change this now, but with an core that she knew she couldn't hold. While many could argue Veronica cost them the life drinker core I can at least say with her she did what she did to because she anticipated Yoshida trying to steal the core and her did what she did to try and stop her unlike Natalie who just up and gave the core to the enemy for the reason I already stated.
then there is the fact that Natalie willing choose to stay with her abusive sisters instead of going with the archangel. I get that she was just a little girl here but come on now. She experienced all the horrible things her sisters did to her, and as I pointed out before unlike Alice she actually had a way out of it. However she instead choose to stay with her horrible sisters until they decided to throw her out. Yes she had a horrible life, and yes like Alice she was abused by family. But the very fact that she had a way out but choose not to leave when she had the chance child or not really turned me off.