Well, the logic is simple. I'm not worried about save games or the grind at all. I played wow 14 years and still do

I want to be able to play through the game from start anytime i want and enjoy the parts i like and prefer.
You can do that with most games unless they have an aweful game setup or grind that never ends.
With MoTH there is only 1 issue for me in this matter. I fail to see the logic in the cross between Clair, Amy and Veronica for some massage Oil that adds many extra hours of gametime if i want to replay for example the Ashley only, Clair only or Veronica only routes. And i am pretty sure you want people, to want to replay the game
Have a look at the thread and count how many posts read "I can't find the massage oil" or "Where is the Sex shop?"
I bet they will stay the most asked questions on this board for a long time to come. Phone tips only tell you to work on something else but provide no explanation as for why. Even some events are locked behinde these blocks. Taking a backseat will not trigger untill after you get the oil because Amy can't go higher then 5 stars. So to get an achievement for driving Veronica home from the Neon club and getting a HJ in the Taxi i need to almost complete Clairs route. This is where i fail to see the logic.
Obviosly i say all of this with nothing but respect and if i didn't care for the game, well, i wouldn't even be here to speak my mind

( Or nag like crasy

) As always you do a great job and put a lot of hard work into the game. And even if it turns out i'm the only person on the planet who hates the massage oil setup, thats a good thing i guess

Cheers mate