I don't think this game is that "dated". Games like Being a DIK are still a rarity, most games here are sadly still shallow and all about random fucking..not interesting stories and characters.You're crazy. The next update which would be the last will be rushed, the games you shitted on (BAD for example) have this game beat on the writing and characters, no one who has played this has honestly said that the writing is the strong point of this game (except for some simps in the 100's of pages here who i won't name)
Honestly, I dont know how someone can play this and actually put it top for adult VN's when everything about this game is dated now. The only reason i check in on this is because of comments that are completely delusional (putting ICSTOR on a pedestal) and i get a kick out of laughing at them. It's telling that some of the most prominent people here on this site who posted regualry on this game haven't shown up for weeks if not months.
So if the dev kept delivering on this game it would still be popular and well liked here but he fucked up and got lazy & greedy