MadMonk

Member
May 26, 2017
133
552
it hasnt bit the dust, its on hold
i know but if you look how many projects got set on hold and then abdoned to start something new or rushed to an end with one more updated you see what "bites the dust means" and the sign are there for this one too.
 

fried

Almost
Moderator
Donor
Nov 11, 2017
2,313
6,103
First of all what is the developer of the game actually developing in the game? :D
Is he the one who make the renders? Or he is the one who is doing the codding? Or may be he is the one who is doing both! In that case I believe that what is he saying, because codding + rendering is something that requires a lot time. But otherwise if he is doing half of the job I don't believe in a single word of that what he said. I know what is to do renders of animations and pictures and once you got the right settings you are going to set the scenes pretty fast and the PC will do the rest, so I don't see how he can suffer from that. Else if He is doing the codding, that might be actually true, codding is thinking, codding is testing, codding is very difficult, but for a game where your choices are not effecting the story of the game or the end of the game I don't see it so painful. Most likely the problem is way more deeper and He just cant share it with us. Even if He quit the game, which is very unlikely to happen, don't blame him. That's his project, no company owns him. As the Joker said: " if you are good in something... don't do it for free" so yes he is going to work for money.
This post is sort of all over the place and seems to offer contradictory messages at times, but on your clear assertion that the graphical aspect of game development is straightforward compared to the code development . . . it sounds as if you might not have very much experience with scene composition, modelling, animation, lighting, texturing/shaders, compositing, asset management, etc. - to say nothing of the story work and editing, plot development and possible storyboarding.

The actual rendering is computational power at work, but to reach that point takes a great deal of technical and creative effort for those that do a beyond-average job in their graphical presentation aspect of game dev; one doesn't simply game Dev into Mordor plop characters into a scene and get the effective perspectives and character expressions+body language, convincing figure-on-figure interplay (which is difficult in Daz - for a character-oriented 3d posing program, it has remarkably limited collision/physics capabilities) and especially compelling+smooth animations (again, extremely difficult in Daz). To say nothing of getting the lighting trials and/or post-work+possible render layer compositing consistent across steps in a scene.

I will confidently assert that the better game Devs - and ICSTOR is one of them - put in a great deal of time and effort to getting out their high quality installments, as a rule.
 

fried

Almost
Moderator
Donor
Nov 11, 2017
2,313
6,103
So, I haven't been in this topic for awhile and come back to experience sincere disbelief at so many people literally accusing ICSTOR of being a lazy, rich fraud and all.

I mean, we're talking about ICSTOR: this person has churned out a number of games over the years, with consistently high quality. It boggles my mind, the intensely immature and whiny demands of so many commenters here as of late (many of whom seem to have low post counts, from my casual notice - perhaps I'm wrong.) But, what have you done for me lately? Why I can't I get what I demand NOW? What a load of Veruca Salt-wannabees, I tell ya.

That said ...

It seems his outfit may be taking a break soon, if I understand the gist of comments in the past week or so, which sounds pretty reasonable: again, this game dev has put out an impressive history of complete games and hey ... turns out that humans are behind it all, wouldn't you know!

If this was Epic or such, there would be other employees to take on tasks when some folks go on holiday or sick leave. That's often not an option for these small, self-publishing outfits which use Patreon, SubscribeStar or similar.

The marked lack of appreciation for effort required to create these games from scratch - and the glass-half-empty assumptions filling in their lack of knowledge - is just astounding to me. I have a tough time believing people with these displayed levels of unsympathetic impatience, superficial judgement and willful ignorance exist in large numbers, but I guess this helps explain some truly perplexing and astonishingly foot-shooting choices in some elections of the past couple of years ...
 

MadMonk

Member
May 26, 2017
133
552
So, I haven't been in this topic for awhile and come back to experience sincere disbelief at so many people literally accusing ICSTOR of being a lazy, rich fraud and all.

I mean, we're talking about ICSTOR: this person has churned out a number of games over the years, with consistently high quality. It boggles my mind, the intensely immature and whiny demands of so many commenters here as of late (many of whom seem to have low post counts, from my casual notice - perhaps I'm wrong.) But, what have you done for me lately? Why I can't I get what I demand NOW? What a load of Veruca Salt-wannabees, I tell ya.

That said ...

It seems his outfit may be taking a break soon, if I understand the gist of comments in the past week or so, which sounds pretty reasonable: again, this game dev has put out an impressive history of complete games and hey ... turns out that humans are behind it all, wouldn't you know!

If this was Epic or such, there would be other employees to take on tasks when some folks go on holiday or sick leave. That's often not an option for these small, self-publishing outfits which use Patreon, SubscribeStar or similar.

The marked lack of appreciation for effort required to create these games from scratch - and the glass-half-empty assumptions filling in their lack of knowledge - is just astounding to me. I have a tough time believing people with these displayed levels of unsympathetic impatience, superficial judgement and willful ignorance exist in large numbers, but I guess this helps explain some truly perplexing and astonishingly foot-shooting choices in some elections of the past couple of years ...

i don't think many on here accouse him of beeing a lazy or a fraud since like you said yourself he put quality work out in the past and this game is no difference, it is way above 95% of other stuff you will find on here.

I think people fear more that the game will find an abrupt end even when he comes back, getting burned out on a project and takeing a break leads often to to finding new projects that bring more joy in once work.
i don't want to say that this will happen here but i would totally understand if he comes back after his break and puts one other update out and then moves on, no one wants to work on something that pulls them down, that will only lead to a lost in quality and if i judge him right that is something he doesen't want.

But also this site is full of abdoned projects so i understand the feelings of some of the louder posters on here.

i hope he will find new strenght after his break and keeps working on this game, or works on another one.


(also sorry about my english, not a native speaker here)
 
  • Like
Reactions: tall tale

Dependable_223

Engaged Member
Jan 3, 2019
3,043
4,933
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

He is right though he never got a vacation he do deserves abreak. Sometimes a break is all you need to get everything sorted and clear the mind. even with a fultime job you also need a full break from that or you will get health decline.
 

ꜱᴛᴀɢᴡᴏᴏᴅ

Bush Rustler
Donor
Aug 23, 2018
1,080
2,053
-I will pause my Patreon account during this time so you will NOT be charged.
-Everyone who pledged for this month will be getting the next Caroline and Celia update for free.
This here is why nobody has a right to complain in my opinion. How many times have we seen a Patreon account continue to operate while the dev has all but disappeared from the face of the Earth without so much as a hat tip?
ICSTOR is literally passing on more than $5k per month (and that's if all his pledges are the lowest tier, which they most definitely are not), that's not something that I think anyone would do if they felt that they had another choice. This break must be unavoidable.
 

Hones

Forum Fanatic
Compressor
Aug 10, 2018
4,156
8,649
Wait, wait, does that mean we have to wait for version 0.6 until June? Or is he taking a break after posting it?
Just expect the release to drop ~June then if it drops earlier it will be a pleasant surprise for you.
There are plenty of other games here to keep you occupied till then.
 

Trapezio

Engaged Member
Sep 28, 2017
2,226
3,230
Guys, honestly...

I wrote it on Nergal's games threads (both, many many months ago), I wrote it on Veqvil's LaS thread (many months ago)... therefore I'm quoting myself (once again):

THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT LESSON I LEARNED HERE on F95 ZONE forum: whenever an author openly starts talking about his personal issues on Patreon/Discord/his blog his game is DOOMED.


This game is dead. Deal with it and move on to something else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blitzen

J II D

Member
Aug 22, 2018
240
472
This here is why nobody has a right to complain in my opinion. How many times have we seen a Patreon account continue to operate while the dev has all but disappeared from the face of the Earth without so much as a hat tip?
ICSTOR is literally passing on more than $5k per month (and that's if all his pledges are the lowest tier, which they most definitely are not), that's not something that I think anyone would do if they felt that they had another choice. This break must be unavoidable.
I mean.. yes and no.
Is he better then the large amount of developers that just keep the cashflow going knowing full well that they are done.... 100% yes... And he has my respect for that decision.

But does that also mean that his loyal pledgers....people who are paying for the development of this project...have no right to be angry or disappointed..... No....

If i payed a couple hundreds buck for a project and the developer suddenly decides to take a break because he lost motivation/energy to go on with the project, they have full right to question that.
I also believe that it's large based on fear because these days we all know full to well what it means when a developer decides to "take a break"... Especially with the history of Icstor.

I also don't believe for 1 second that he didn't take a couple breaks during those 4 years, like i said... I followed the development cycles of multiple games under his wing and am fan of almost all of them, and i followed those years enough that there where enough breaks in development where he didn't do any work. (This is of course 100% personal thoughts and don't have any facts for it, just my own personal observation).
But it just seems that every time around a half way mark of a game he just loses motivation and focus for his current project and loses motivation and starts thinking about new ideas (and that causes even more loss of motivation because now he wants to do that new thing).

But to end on a positive note.
Icstor will not vanish from the face of the earth, i don't believe that for 1 second.
Will this game get another update or 2... Yeah... I do think so yes.

Are we going to get all the things he promised and is this game going to be completed.......
Well, i think that's in the same category as Gumdrop releasing his game this year.... Not likely......
 
  • Like
Reactions: prika1

ꜱᴛᴀɢᴡᴏᴏᴅ

Bush Rustler
Donor
Aug 23, 2018
1,080
2,053
@J II D While I understand your sentiment and kind of agree to a point, isn't the entire model behind Patreon that you are pledging to a creator and not their product? Some creators subvert that model and treat it like those pledging are in fact paying for a product, but I'm sure that Patreon's own descriptions refer back to the Renaissance and how people with excessive amounts of money would help artists with living costs and expenses just to keep their creativity flowing and not particularly to receive something back. Getting something back such as the first refusal on works etc. was obviously incentive to keep supporting the artist but that's just good relations.
 
3.70 star(s) 438 Votes