TheeSonus

Well-Known Member
Mar 30, 2020
1,454
1,547
How many girls have dateable romance routes at this point. I like some of the random fight encounters, but the best girls will be the ones who I can visit several times and see all their stuff. (Still waiting for lizard girl route kthx).

The only routes I can name (because I don't know much) are mika and the wyrm and I'm not even sure if those are actually complete.
Mika, Jora, Kotone, Feng, Ancilla, I think Elly but not sure, I think Venifica or whatever her name is, and I think the minotaur girl who runs the bar.
I'm fairly sure NO routes are definitively "complete" due to the current nature of the game itself not being complete.
 

NinjaNamedBob

Member
May 3, 2018
200
322
You predicted whole plot, including revelation at the end of a game? Because I dont.
I mean, in third chapter when she said "Kill her!!! -No!? -Fine, Il do it myself" it wasnt even a revelation for me. She hate monsters and whole game before that she appears with "kill monster boss" several times, so...
I predicted it to the point of "lets kill all monsters...", but not to the point "...and also humans".
It was fairly predictable that Ilias was going to go genocide route if Luka ever ended up renagging on the whole "wholesale slaughter of monsters" front. She likely pushed him to killing the monster lord with the full knowledge that doing so would easily spark a conflict between the two races, and allow her to swoop in with her pseudo-monsters and properly commit a genocide in the name of "world peace." That she actively berates you for losing fights rather than presenting a more forgiving front even implies that she's less focused on your safety and survival and more on the fact that you failed her.


Paradox still unfinished and it was released after original MGQ. And I never played it. So....what you trying to say here?
Read: it's a well-known meme from 4chan that the prevailing problem with Luka's dream of co-existence is that due to the inherent superiority monsters possess over Human's, the latter species will simply go extinct due to dwindling birthrates. Promestein has an entire TEDtalk in Paradox where she brings this up as a major concern to fairly apathetic-looking audience. That's it.


I played it
1) long ago
2) without tutorial/manual
And I dropped it because overall game experience wasnt that satisfying for me nor "hmmmm, what happened next? I should know that!!!!"
This is a bit too incoherent. I would encourage you to type it out slowly and try again.


Yes, but again, you should figure out why what and with whom in shrift FOR EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER personally. Which means grinding and repeating same actions over and over to increase you stand with species, to trigger that specific cutscene variant, about of which you could have know only after you trigger that cutscene 'normally', without knowing about it. OR you just 'cheat' and use walkthrough.
You do figure out why and who, though. It's part of the main plot and individual character interactions in their personal recollection rooms. Hell, you can only get Mu if you do her side quest. And no, it doesn't mean grinding actions repeatedly. There are methods to circumvent any kind of grind. If you're talking about the random battles, it's actually a mechanic that you run from Mother Rabbit rather than directly engaging her. It's a mechanic to resist Haru and Liz. It's also a mechanic to choose to spare a demon rather than keep blasting. It's also impossible not to know when the game makes no effort to disguise what your two options are, and the fallout from either.

While in undertale glimpse of what going on reveals in the end, when you already have some "are we the baddies?" doubts. Plus, its impossible to miss it, just reach the end of a game. And its didnt matter what path you have chosen, path of pacifist or path of war crimes, truth will be revealed in any case.
Same case with Shrift. It's presented at the beginning that the demons were the aggressors from the start, but as you go through and choose to spare them (or, in genocide, are basically told "bro, not to rain on your parade, but maybe cool it on the xenophobia?"), you start to unfold the nuances of the conflict itself. Human's are notoriously shit, and Shrift makes a point of it repeatedly.

Like, yeah, I get that not everything is so clear in shrift on both sides of war. I remembered that moment when one demon killed another for refusing attacking you which you were talking about. Alraune if Im correct. But it raises more questions, especially if you previously became friends with that alraune. Dont remember exactly what questions, that was long ago, but I remember that I facepalmed til blood at this moment. And somewhere here I dropped it. Because eh..wh...ho...pf...sh....eh...pffffffff....hmmmmm.....shrift folder -> shift delete -> launch quake 3 arena -> "to win this game you must get more kills or frags than enemies".
You quit the game when your positive morality resulted in a subordinate questioning her superior's commands, thus demonstrating that the demons aren't just mindless cum-sucking abominations? I'm not sure I can take you seriously anymore.

Before deletion I launched game with complete pacifist save, just to make sure that its not me an idiot who didnt realized all geniality of it. But it make even less sense for me after I checked last boss.
What I defenitely figured out is that its typical japanees game with all "main" content hidden outside of main plot line. And Im also figured out that I not a lover of such kind of games.


That was exaggeration. Game activelly tries to squeeze tears from you but present you not to the blind poor orphans but green dog with....how much??..six IIRC...human female breasts. Eh? I dont get it.
Because she's a demonic abomination? Shrift is pretty keen on reminding you that, despite the similarities these creatures may have with respect to everyday things from our world, they're still otherworldly creatures. Shame on Devil's Office for making an effort to make monsters look, y'know, like friggin monsters rather than over-compensating cosplayers.



Hmmmm.... You know, I don't mean to be "that guy". I honestly, truly don't. However, there's something that's been bugging me for awhile. A sort of curiosity, if you will.

If Kotone was a man rather than a woman, still a kitsune and with the same backstory and tendency towards hypnotizing people, would the people who are sympathetic towards her still sympathize?
I think the one guy still defending her would actively condemn Kotone if she were a male. Personally, I'd still call Kotone an abusive piece of shit, regardless of pronouns. Just because the genitals and preferred pronouns are different doesn't mean that the person gets a pass either way. A piece of shit is a piece of shit, gold spray-paint or not.

Meh, it's useless to try.
Peoples have have pasts. In MGD monster girls are people. Simple as that. 'Suck it up' is the only anwer, including in RL :LOL:

I'm really bummed Thresh completely forgot Perpetua, the best girl as everyone knows yet shily pretend they don't. I hope she'll play a grand part in the "True sigil" challenge, where we'll see what becomes of this Dungeon system.
She gets a few lines in the Labyrinth, much to the disbelief of everyone in the room. The Hellhounds are way too confused by the entire scene to offer a convincing rebuttal beyond "o-okay then..."
 

MadFoole

Member
Feb 8, 2020
183
249
At least those discussions help me realize I'm out of touch with the lore of this game.

Just a small question, but for you, considering all the monsters girls introduced into this game, who is ;

- The kindest Monster Girl ?
- The most evil one ?
- The most "neutral" one ?
Kindest MG: I'd say there's a strong argument for either Mara, Galvi, or Belle here. They're all non-combat NPCs, the first two just want to show the MC a good time, the last one is just working as a bartender and needs occasional help with her lactation issue.

Most evil MG: If we're basing it on the whole of the lore, arguably it's Sophia because she used to snack on souls like they were Goldfish crackers. Yes, I'm aware she's reformed now and regrets those youthful indiscretions, but she undeniably has the highest casualties of any character. If we're going by how the characters act within the game, it's either Kotone for stripping the MC of their autonomy or Vili for making the MC into her "Titty slave." I'm leaning towards Kotone because at least Vili is up front about what she's planning to do to the MC.

Most neutral MG: There's actually a long list here, because a lot of the named MGs are just trying to do their job. Ancilla seems particularly indifferent as to whether the MC succeeds or not. Venefica does just want to be left alone to run her sweet shop. Feng is a playful puppy in a room she wishes had a space heater. Mika is just punching a clock in the Forest Dungeon. Nara's just being paid to be a last test for adventurers at the mountaintop. Nikki is just looking to trade her nectar for a decent meal. Sofia (as she is now) just wants to nap. Minoni is just overseeing the Power Temple trials and trying to keep them honest. I'm sure I could list more, but I'd be listing all the named MGs that aren't explicitly listed in the above two categories.
 
Jan 5, 2019
192
88
Ugh is there a map for the 3rd floor of the Labyrinth? It's really annoying I've been save scumming running around in circles for over an hour and found one extra key but seem to be missing more? Fighting Beris is too much of a pain, I don't really understand why they level up seemingly uncapped, I don't care how many times I shove her up against a wall, your telling me she was stronger than arch succubus this whole time but was just holding back?
 

VespidV

Active Member
Dec 11, 2016
640
350
Ugh is there a map for the 3rd floor of the Labyrinth? It's really annoying I've been save scumming running around in circles for over an hour and found one extra key but seem to be missing more? Fighting Beris is too much of a pain, I don't really understand why they level up seemingly uncapped, I don't care how many times I shove her up against a wall, your telling me she was stronger than arch succubus this whole time but was just holding back?
When I did the third floor I went out of my way to remember where every key is leaving the four in the middle for last and I'm pretty sure it ended up spawning an extra fifth key in a new path on the far left of the map once the floor layout was altered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NicCag

Quintilus

Engaged Member
Aug 8, 2020
2,687
7,640
You quit the game when your positive morality resulted in a subordinate questioning her superior's commands, thus demonstrating that the demons aren't just mindless cum-sucking abominations? I'm not sure I can take you seriously anymore.
First of, they still "cum-sucking abominations", even if each of them have...what, quantum physics, AI and abstract mathematics PhD. Game literally builded around it.
Second, that was cruel for a boss to kill its subordinate. Like, really? She have inexhaustible amount of 'soldiers' to do so?
Third, that was dumb, to refuse to attack me when her boss definitely not in a good mood. Put at last some fight to save a face and life. She brave, but also incredibly stupid.
Fourth, game tries to make me feel bad for it. Why? It was her personal decision to do so, nobody forced her doing it with a gun at her head.
Fifth, what was it all for? Just to show up that they not only a "cum-sucking abominations" but they also have feelings? Again, I get it long before this scene.

Game is just dont work for me.
Yes, art is good....well mediocre, okay.
Yes, story is good...maybe a little bit silly.
Yes, world building is good...again, silly in some concepts but meh, moving on.
Gameplay? "Default" RPGM kind of gameplay, nothing to hype on.
Porn part...makes me laugh several times but overall 'gud enuff'.
But overall it tries to do thing that does not work for me, like
Human's are notoriously shit, and Shrift makes a point of it repeatedly.
I already know that. Is there are more than that to it?......No?! In trash bin than.

Same case with Shrift. It's presented at the beginning that the demons were the aggressors from the start, but as you go through and choose to spare them (or, in genocide, are basically told "bro, not to rain on your parade, but maybe cool it on the xenophobia?"), you start to unfold the nuances of the conflict itself.
Well, no. Undertale was "an ordinal rpg that not so ordinal at all...more on that next". Whole game was builded on it.
Like EXP was was abbreviation for EXecution Points, LOVE for Level Of ViolencE, etc. That why it worked. And yes, undertale is JUST an interesting game, not a masterpiece GOTY 12 out of 10
And what we have in "blue shrift"? Ehhh.....demons are not evil?! First of, its debatable...I mean they all womans, which is...but anyway, is that all?!
....
Yes.
Yes, it is.
 
Jan 5, 2019
192
88
When I did the third floor I went out of my way to remember where every key is leaving the four in the middle for last and I'm pretty sure it ended up spawning an extra fifth key in a new path on the far left of the map once the floor layout was altered.
Giving up, updating the game and going in on fresh run let me get through it with sooo much less hassle.
 
Jan 5, 2019
192
88
Also fun thought, if hellhounds stem from a cerebrus monster, what do y'all think the odds of them fusion hahing into a cerbus would be? The sisters are kinda 3 heads and snake (making the last sister the tale in this scenario) would make for a tough fight I bet.
 

DeadlyHit

New Member
May 9, 2018
2
0
Could someone enlighten me as to how I can get rid of Venefica's milking pet perk? Also, is there any point to sparring with Venefica after beating her once with Elly?
 

NinjaNamedBob

Member
May 3, 2018
200
322
First of, they still "cum-sucking abominations", even if each of them have...what, quantum physics, AI and abstract mathematics PhD. Game literally builded around it.
So are MGD and MGQ. What's your point?

Second, that was cruel for a boss to kill its subordinate. Like, really? She have inexhaustible amount of 'soldiers' to do so?
I mean, the barghast and lampas are effectively frontline infantry so yes, it's likely that the boss has plentiful more soldiers to throw at the world. Also, every cruel dictator throughout history has practiced a similar methodology of handling insubordination. The Red Army was infamously liquidated and re-organized under Stalin's regime, to great effect.

Third, that was dumb, to refuse to attack me when her boss definitely not in a good mood. Put at last some fight to save a face and life. She brave, but also incredibly stupid.
I believe in the genocide route, you've demonstrated numerous times over that you can easily handle the entire lampas species. Being given an order to effectively commit suicide seems fairly unreasonable. On the other end, the PC has shown compassion for the lampas in sparing them. As far as that one lampas was concerned, you weren't a threat, let alone someone who would get in the way of their plans unless it directly impacted you.

Fourth, game tries to make me feel bad for it. Why? It was her personal decision to do so, nobody forced her doing it with a gun at her head.
Is compassion for someone showing you mercy at every turn a foreign concept for you?

Fifth, what was it all for? Just to show up that they not only a "cum-sucking abominations" but they also have feelings? Again, I get it long before this scene.
The point was to establish what the outcome of your kindness or cruelty can result in, but also to put forward just how cruel the end boss actually is. It establishes the stakes for those who oppose her, gives your character motivation to get stronger, and establishes the lengths the end boss will go to in order to dissuade "wrong think" within her ranks. In terms of narrative elements, it's as basic as MGQ was in presenting to you the flip-side of Human/Monster relations when rape wasn't a factor.

Game is just dont work for me.
Yes, art is good....well mediocre, okay.
I mean, if you're jerking it to Shrift...

Yes, story is good...maybe a little bit silly.
Yes, world building is good...again, silly in some concepts but meh, moving on.
Like I said, the story is basically Undertale except with porn. The world-building is fine, nothing to write home about.

Gameplay? "Default" RPGM kind of gameplay, nothing to hype on.
Porn part...makes me laugh several times but overall 'gud enuff'.
But overall it tries to do thing that does not work for me, like
If it doesn't work for you, it doesn't work. I'm not trying to twist your arm. I just think you gave up too easily and expected something that the game never implied.

I already know that. Is there are more than that to it?......No?! In trash bin than.
There is a lot more. It's up to you to make the effort to find out what that is, or not.


Well, no. Undertale was "an ordinal rpg that not so ordinal at all...more on that next". Whole game was builded on it.
Like EXP was was abbreviation for EXecution Points, LOVE for Level Of ViolencE, etc. That why it worked. And yes, undertale is JUST an interesting game, not a masterpiece GOTY 12 out of 10
And what we have in "blue shrift"? Ehhh.....demons are not evil?! First of, its debatable...I mean they all womans, which is...but anyway, is that all?!
Okay, so I'm going to pretend there was something beyond casual sexism for your last sentence, and focus on the fact that Undertale wasn't operating too far outside the normal mechanics of the rpgmaker engine in itself. It simply did what games like Shrift and MGQ:paradox do, which is manipulating certain elements in the engine for a desired mechanic. I'm not a dev myself, but I imagine I could get the same results as Tobey did if I made the investment. The mechanics all apply numerical values to certain behaviours, which involve "if" and "when" triggers.

I can tell you that you're wrong about the nuances of Shrift's demons on the basis that I'm playing it, have passed the section you quit at, and have paid attention to the story. There is a lot more than "demons are evil, except when they're not." I would personally discourage you from making broad statements on a game you know nothing about based off your limited understanding of what some random on the internet says. Obviously, I'm not giving the full details for reasons of not spoiling those who might want to play it for themselves.
 

FaekNaem

New Member
Jan 17, 2020
13
14
After grinding for a bit and finally completing the final floor of the labyrinth I can safely say that Ceris is the best hellhound.
I was about to say. Everyone's been super high on Ushris throughout the thread and Ceris isn't getting nearly enough love. Granted, she is, as Beris puts it, really basic and straightforward but there's definitely room to build on with her. Plus I don't think we have a dommy character in the game that's that loving and encouraging throughout the whole thing. All the hellhounds are great (well, Ushris is bottom tier for me because I don't like that kind of content) but Ceris just hits all the buttons. Definitely hoping to see more content for them.

As for my thoughts on the Labyrinth itself, I don't have much to say that others haven't but I'll word it out in case Thresh is still here looking at feedback. I found it a neat way to change up the gameplay though it does suffer from no real reason to repeat the challenge after you've completed it. The problem elements are the 3rd and especially 4th floor. It's not just the fog of war that makes them irritating but the fact that traps are completely invisible, especially forcing you walk through them as opposed to the other floors where you had the option to try and minimize them.

Iabel's floor gets hit particularly badly since the floor and even traps are all randomized and many traps spawn in ways that you have to trigger twice in order to get keys. It feels more like trial and error as opposed to the others where you can make a plan as you go, even Ushris's floor doesn't have extensive alterations so you can still have a good idea of the layout once the fog of war kicks in.

This is also relevant for reviewing scenes. For the most part it's pretty easy to trigger the traps/fights to rewatch the scenes as you want but Iabel is completely randomized so it's much harder to get to her sex content.

I like the content overall, just has a few hiccups.
 
4.60 star(s) 85 Votes