VN Ren'Py Abandoned My Daughter's Plaything [Ch. 1] [KimmiChan]

4.40 star(s) 8 Votes

Muffeh

Member
Jun 25, 2017
181
346
The fanfic this is clearly using was written and released for free. The game itself has also been released for free. However the games developer is soliciting donations for the game. Making use of someone else's writing to do so. If this game had amazing renders this would be less of an issue. The fact is that the writing is doing most of the heavy lifting.

I am not arguing for the moral high ground here. This site is primarily used to download for free games that are charged for normally.

However 2 wrongs do not make a right. Profiting from someone elses written work, particulary without crediting them at all is shady as hell. If the original author was at least credited somewhere this would be more palatable.
 
Apr 24, 2018
214
576
I like that sneaky nod to F95 near the beginning of the game. Well played lol


Edit: Just finished the game. Holy shit, that was hot as fuck. I've never been so satisfied with just one scene. Your killing me with the cliffhanger, but at least I hav another game on here to look forward too. Great Job. If I was to give any actual critique, I would say the renders may not be the greatest but honestly your writing more than makes up for it. And in the long run I think it's much easier to learn how to make higher quality renders than it is to learn how to write well. Still I wouldn't mind if they stayed the way they are. I'm just hungry for more content. Hopefully gets the recognition it deserves. Either way, if you keep this up, I think your going to have a whole lot of coffee. (y)

Edit #2: It's a shame that all of the writing was taken from another creator without credit. Still a good story but that's not your doing so....I would suggest contacting the person who actually wrote it (DirtyMindedMinx). Maybe you can come to some sort of arrangement. Shit, you may be able to get her to collaborate with you on a new VN. Trust me it feels much better to recive praise for work that you know you actually did. I don't know your motivations for this whole situation but plagiarism is not ok. It's also not worth killing your own reputation for a few bucks.
 
Apr 24, 2018
214
576
The fanfic this is clearly using was written and released for free. The game itself has also been released for free. However the games developer is soliciting donations for the game. Making use of someone else's writing to do so. If this game had amazing renders this would be less of an issue. The fact is that the writing is doing most of the heavy lifting.

I am not arguing for the moral high ground here. This site is primarily used to download for free games that are charged for normally.

However 2 wrongs do not make a right. Profiting from someone elses written work, particulary without crediting them at all is shady as hell. If the original author was at least credited somewhere this would be more palatable.

What Fan-fic? Not that I don't believe you, I just haven't read the it. Plus I may need to amend my review on this game if what you said is correct.
 
Apr 24, 2018
214
576
Check the thread a few pages back. It's laid out there.
Oof. Well that is indeed pretty problematic. How disappointing, especially because after doing some research on the actual writer, (DirtyMindedMinx). She seems like the kind of person who would have been open to some sort of arrangement. Who knows, she might have been down to collaborate on a completely new VN. :(
 

Messalina

New Member
May 8, 2018
12
21
I must say this is maybe the most erotic visual novel about incest I've ever "played". The writing is so damn sexy... Can't wait for Chapter 2!

#Edit: Oh well, I've just read the rest of comments.... Nevermind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: proximus

proximus

Member
Donor
Apr 25, 2017
345
666
My Daughter's Plaything
all episodes to read - here:

My Daughter’s Dildo, Ch. 1 to 8
by DirtyMindedMinx

View attachment 220149
Wow, just wow. Read all 8 chapters in one go. Without question, one of the most erotic media experiences I ever had.
I know that this is a pirate forum, but lots of game developers post their game here in order to gain more patrons (at least first few chapters). I support about half dozen games and was seriously considering adding this one.
Considering that this is pretty much exact story adaptation, author deserves to be mentioned in opening credits at a bare minimum, or even get some cut if game takes off.
 

proximus

Member
Donor
Apr 25, 2017
345
666
Oof. Well that is indeed pretty problematic. How disappointing, especially because after doing some research on the actual writer, (DirtyMindedMinx). She seems like the kind of person who would have been open to some sort of arrangement. Who knows, she might have been down to collaborate on a completely new VN. :(
There are already few "professional" writers collaborating on some games. I am fairly sure that teaming DirtyMindMinx and someone experienced with Ren'Py and DAZ would result in a great game. Maybe some of game devs could reach to her and see if she would be interested. It would probably need to be established dev, as she is an American and most of devs here are first timers from Eastern Europe (absolutely no disrespect intended) to streamline payments.
 

darlic

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2017
1,804
3,031
I came here all happy and ready to praise this game, then I began reading the last pages of comments...

This game is damn good and I really hope for it to continue being developed, but the fact that it is not a 100% original product makes me wonder if this could be wrong on some aspects. So many doubts yet so little answers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ed B

bsjfan69

Member
Oct 4, 2017
343
329
This is really fucking good, even the renders are great. Like many others I'm not sure how to feel about the fact that the story is straight up stolen... but in the end, considering it's better than 99% of the other porn games' stories, I'm gonna say fuck it, more devs should do like this guy did. It's clear that most of them can't come up with decent stories by themselves, so might as well steal someone else's, even if scummy at least the end product will be better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ed B

P1Pi

Newbie
Sep 3, 2016
17
16
My Daughter's Plaything
all episodes to read - here:

My Daughter’s Dildo, Ch. 1 to 8
by DirtyMindedMinx

View attachment 220149
Is this down... anyone has a copy maybe?
 
4.40 star(s) 8 Votes