VN Ren'Py Completed My Sister, My Roommate [v1.69] [Sumodeine]

[Avaron1974]

How is it fucked up?
Nikki was never an option or haven't you been paying attention for the past two years?

Clearly hasn't payed attention.

Obviously the devs fault for them not knowing.

 

[I'm Not Thea Lundgren!]

Clearly hasn't payed attention.

Obviously the devs fault for them not knowing.

Of course, why own up when you can just blame the dev?

 

[The One and Only Bob]

But I gave him $2 one time (trust me, I would never lie in a totally anonymous setting like this)! So he clearly was obligated to re-write the game to be entirely populated by anthropomorphic velociraptors like I told him!

 

[Goblin Baily: DILF]

the "perfect ending" ( I was hoping Nikki would end up with Sarah but it didn't happen but that's not enough reason to act like a brat) fit the tone and themes of the previous updates and everyone got what they deserved. At some point you have to leave neverland and grow. That's what the talk between Tales and Nikki was about. Should we feel bad for Nikki ? Nah, she ended her search for a harbor... From the beginning she wanted a relationship but she was barking at the wrong tree. In the end she got what she wanted.
Tales wanted a normal girlfriend with a sex drive. He got one.
D'brick wanted a phat ass, he got it...
Mrs S also got what she wanted....
Everyone was happy..
And Molly.... she learned what the fuss was about and she was jolly.

 

[pletoxxx]

But I gave him $2 one time (trust me, I would never lie in a totally anonymous setting like this)! So he clearly was obligated to re-write the game to be entirely populated by anthropomorphic velociraptors like I told him!

"i want my spoon or i'll stop eating!"
even my 5 yo daughter knews well enough that kind of pouting wouldnt get her what she wanted.

 

[DA22]

the "perfect ending" ( I was hoping Nikki would end up with Sarah but it didn't happen but that's not enough reason to act like a brat) fit the tone and themes of the previous updates and everyone got what they deserved. At some point you have to leave neverland and grow. That's what the talk between Tales and Nikki was about. Should we feel bad for Nikki ? Nah, she ended her search for a harbor... From the beginning she wanted a relationship but she was barking at the wrong tree. In the end she got what she wanted.
Tales wanted a normal girlfriend with a sex drive. He got one.
D'brick wanted a phat ass, he got it...
Mrs S also got what she wanted....
Everyone was happy..
And Molly.... she learned what the fuss was about and she was jolly.

Actually that marc Nikki ending was the saddest one of all for me. I have seen a marriage like that where they stayed together for 30 years with a deep dividing unhappiness between them, since she cannot really be happy that according to her beliefs the man she loves and has been married to for so long will go to hell even if he is a good man.

Besides Nikki as she is written at best got second best and she will always know that, most likely she will be sleeping again with tales within a year and then also feeling guilty about betraying two people she cares for. If that is happily ever after in your eyes. Well I would not wish it upon my enemies.

Edit: it also felt to me that Nikki really had not learned anything, more like a 30 yo virgin that immediately marries the first woman that let him get in her bed, whether he is suited to her or not. Or like running away again from her real feelings as she had been doing years before by trying to get into relations time and time again to run away from the relation she really wanted. Now if she had truly acknowledged her feelings and need for Tales and then decided to not follow up on them and move away that might have worked for her over time or she would also end up with three cats. Running away to the first offer rarely solves anything though.

 

[Tataty]

Of course, why own up when you can just blame the dev?

I knew we wouldn't get a Nikki ending. He still fcked up the game not making one.
I am not blaming Sumo for writing the story the way he wanted but I'm expressing my opinion.

Let's face it: Most people (Don't comment "But I didn't".) have been playing this game because of the relationship between Tales and Nikki. When you end a story that is based on taboo feelings with "Hey let's not be together because society wouldn't allow it." then OFC people are going to be disappointed.

Nikki was never getting an ending. Dev made that clear from the very start.

Lets blame the dev for you not being able to a search though.

Like I said. I knew it was coming.
Announcing something does not make it good though

It's like your dad saying: "Son, I don't love your mom anymore. I will leave you. Just so you know. Better be prepared..."

 

[Qwerfy]

So, how should it have been done?

Remember, Sumodeine is 1 guy working on his first game.

That doesn't mean criticism can't be levelled towards it. That was my criticism, there's numerous ways it could have been done but generally just more ways to impact the story and its end are popular with players.

I'm not criticising the author, but it's a criticism of the game that will hopefully be helpful for him.

 

[Goblin Baily: DILF]

I knew we wouldn't get a Nikki ending. He still fcked up the game not making one.
I am not blaming Sumo for writing the story the way he wanted but I'm expressing my opinion.

Let's face it: Most people (Don't comment "But I didn't".) have been playing this game because of the relationship between Tales and Nikki. When you end a story that is based on taboo feelings with "Hey let's not be together because society wouldn't allow it." then OFC people are going to be disappointed.



Like I said. I knew it was coming.
Announcing something does not make it good though

It's like your dad saying: "Son, I don't love your mom anymore. I will leave you. Just so you know. Better be prepared..."

If we're going with the dad analogy, the whole situation was more like the dad returning home with the cigs he was buying five years ago and trying to patch things up.

And if I had a cent for every time someone said that Nikki wasn't going to be a LI.... I'd be playing tag with my five trophy wives on my yacht en route to my private archipelago

 

[Qwerfy]

End of the day it's the creator that decide the ending and what is final. Those not agreeing to the end, or like it, find themselves in the same situation as someone who is unhappy with the end of a movie, book, whatever. Sometimes you will never get the "happy ending" you want.

It doesn't need to be happy, and saying people just want a happy ending is a bit insulting. However, it should be satisfying to the reader/viewer/player etc. If people found it lacking than constructive criticism should be given so the author can take it into account in t he future.

 

[DA22]

If we're going with the dad analogy, the whole situation was more like the dad returning home with the cigs he was buying five years ago and trying to patch things up.

And if I had a cent for every time someone said that Nikki wasn't going to be a LI.... I'd be playing tag with my five trophy wives on my yacht en route to my private archipelago

Whether Nikki was a LI or not, those endings provided with her were depressing though if you have to come to care about Nikki. I had hoped Sumo would have found a better way for her or to just leave it hanging in the air.

 

[Qwerfy]

If we're going with the dad analogy, the whole situation was more like the dad returning home with the cigs he was buying five years ago and trying to patch things up.

And if I had a cent for every time someone said that Nikki wasn't going to be a LI.... I'd be playing tag with my five trophy wives on my yacht en route to my private archipelago

I mean come on, they specifically addressed your argument in the comment you replied to. Announcing something doesn't make it better, it just makes it less of a surprise.

 

[Avaron1974]

I mean come on, they specifically addressed your argument in the comment you replied to. Announcing something doesn't make it better, it just makes it less of a surprise.

Thing is, it was announced at the very start and has been made clear ever since so anyone wanting that to happen had plenty of chance to find a game better suited for them.

To get all the way to the end and then complain about the thing that everyone knew wasn't gong to happen not happening .... I mean, sure, it's funny but it's also a bit of a mindfuck that so many people knew what was going to happen yet still find it a surprise that it happend.

It's like they expected Sumo to change his mind despite the fact he hasn't changed his mind in 2 years.

 

[Goblin Baily: DILF]

Thing is, it was announced at the very start and has been made clear ever since so anyone wanting that to happen had plenty of chance to find a game better suited for them.

To get all the way to the end and then complain about the thing that everyone knew wasn't gong to happen not happening .... I mean, sure, it's funny but it's also a bit of a mindfuck that so many people knew what was going to happen yet still find it a surprise that it happend.

It's like they expected Sumo to change his mind despite the fact he hasn't changed his mind in 2 years.

At least Sumo while keeping to the vision left the outcome to the players and their choices, unlike the guy with the burning house.

 

[MOISTNESS]

Great game but MAAAAAN can you tell Sumo was sick of it though... hehe...

He's all


Great job though Sumo...

 

[DA22]

At least Sumo while keeping to the vision left the outcome to the players and their choices, unlike the guy with the burning house.

Did he? There was only a semi happy ending with Molly that was overshadowed by two pretty unhappy endings with Nikki in that same ending and those two unhappy Nikki endings were also in the other option that was a full unhappy ending on all sides, so not many choices ........ I feel more like the same thing was done to me as by the guy with the burning house

Still the game was enjoyable till that end.

 

[Darth Sidious]

That was posted on October 25th 2017.

It's been made clear by the dev for over 2 years now that Nikki was never an option.

As entertaining as it is watching people compleyely miss the point, all this laughter is giving me a stitch and now my side hurts so I thought it would be easier to show that.

Then i'll point out how i've spent months telling people Nikki was never an option.

People argued with me over that, I giggled, lots.

I did find a song I feel fits though....

You must be registered to see the links

I don't understand why you would spend months telling people Nikki was never an option, something is wrong here either many people wanted a Nikki option or you didn't understand what those people wanted exactly. Personally I think it's the latter, because most people can read a few posts back

Here's an entirely on-topic song that fits the slippiness of consensus about the Nikki matter....

You must be registered to see the links

 

[Qwerfy]

Thing is, it was announced at the very start and has been made clear ever since so anyone wanting that to happen had plenty of chance to find a game better suited for them.

To get all the way to the end and then complain about the thing that everyone knew wasn't gong to happen not happening .... I mean, sure, it's funny but it's also a bit of a mindfuck that so many people knew what was going to happen yet still find it a surprise that it happend.

It's like they expected Sumo to change his mind despite the fact he hasn't changed his mind in 2 years.

Again, that doesn't mean people can't have reasonable complaint that she wasn't a love interest. I'd also recommend not naming your porn game after a character that can't be romanced, as others have said.

 

[Goblin Baily: DILF]

Did he? There was only a semi happy ending with Molly that was overshadowed by two pretty unhappy endings with Nikki in that same ending and those two unhappy Nikki endings were also in the other option that was a full unhappy ending on all sides, so not many choices ........

Mike, how is the plant going ? Did you flip the switch ?
The endings are a result of giving characters agency that goes beyond the actions of the MC...
At the risk of repeating myself, it was the happiest outcome that we could get of that situation. And if you feel sorry for Marcc just think about this: everyone in.a relationship has been someone else's second choice.that's just life. And the fact he's a religious maniac implies he knows about Nikki's promiscuity., the same way Tales was known for being a cheater, and yet wants to spend the rest of his life with her.
All those bad endings.... it's because Tales decided that Nikki should be unhappy.

 

[DA22]

Mike, how is the plant going ? Did you flip the switch ?
The endings are a result of giving characters agency that goes beyond the actions of the MC...
At the risk of repeating myself, it was the happiest outcome that we could get of that situation. And if you feel sorry for Marcc just think about this: everyone in.a relationship has been someone else's second choice.that's just life. And the fact he's a religious maniac implies he knows about Nikki's promiscuity., the same way Tales was known for being a cheater, and yet wants to spend the rest of his life with her.
All those bad endings.... it's because Tales decided that Nikki should be unhappy.

No I feel sorry for Nikki and her not growing up, I dont know anything about Marc afterall, and her going for a worst possible relationship that she could. Now if the consequence from you choosing to let her be happy would have been her growing up, acknowledging her feelings and that she had been in love with Tales for years but still deciding she could not live in an incestuous relationship, not throw herself in one that will make her unhappy immediately and move away to see if with distance her feelings for Tales could diminish and then over time possibly find happiness with someone else for herself. I could have lived with an ending like that or her becoming the third part in the relation with Tales and Molly. Nikki marrying Marc though is the most unhappy ending of all to me for many reasons. To me I chose the unhappiness ending for Nikki in my Molly ending, since to me that was the less unhappy ending for Nikki in my book ..... Talking about choices.