Mystwood Manor being a game made by the creator of my favourite game was always something i was looking forward to. Now I could finally experience this game in its full and completed glory. And i have to say, i'm disappointed.
Mystwood Manor is a game with actual gameplay. And that gameplay is pretty good. It's working pretty well and it's somewhat adicting, especially in the first hours of play. We're working as a hotel manager, we're renovating and opening new rooms in our hotel and sending our girly stuff to work and satisfy the guests. This is fine and all. It works pretty well, it's nicely designed and executed. We have different guests, different girls with different skills, we can train those girls and improve their skills, give them different items and cards with different bonuses. If someone is looking for a game with proper gameplay mechanics this is the game for them. What is disappointing in this game it its adult part. It feels completely lackluster and underdeveloped. We have 8 different girls, every one of them have 15-16 events with them. Most of those events are just a waste of time. They're very generic and boring. 75% of them, in every girl case, are only talking with occasional flirting and teasing. That wouldn't be a bad thing if those dialogues were interesting, if those girls we're talking to were interesting, have some depth and we would get to know them better. Unfortunately all those girls are very shallow and have no depth and any character development outside of them getting more and more horny and lawd thanks to that place, that hotel having this effect on people. Yes, this game have some paranormal stuff in it, ghosts, curses and mysterious fog. I really don't like those things in a porn game. It always feels cheap and out of place. Ours relationships with the girls just feels very forced and unnatural. No real connection between MC and them. Their progression system also could be better. Some events are locked behind having some specific room unlocked beforehand or require specific progress level with other girl. You can easily find yourself in a situation where you are not able to progress with one girl for hours because you don't have some room open, thanks to opening other rooms first and not having enough money for next pricey room at the moment. That's just not fun when game doesnt let you do something you want to do. I mentioned earlier that girls have 15-16 events with them. Only last 3 or 4 of them contain sex. That's just not enough, every girl have the same slow progression. For hours you won't see anything sexy. There should be some diversity here, different pacing with different girls. Some events even feel literally the same.
Talking about adult content we have to talk about renders, models and animations. They're just ok. I think in 2022 that's not enough. Many older games have far better animations and more detail models. There is some diversity in girls body types, breasts sizes and looks, so that's a good thing. Sex scenes itselfs are also quite disappointing, they're very short, have only one or two camera angles and one ok-ish animation. Again, many older games have far better, far more hotter sex scenes. They're serviceable i guess, but i expected something better. Nighttime repeatable scenes are also disappointing. Many repeated positions and animations. The one thing i want to mention here is the Gallery feature. It consists some "bonus" renders with girls. This is the thing which just screams UNFINISHED. Some of the girls only have pictures with while they sleep. Like what is this? With so many different rooms, there should be tons of those renders with different girls working in different rooms (like gym, sauna, pool) with their more and more skimpier outfits. Wouldn't that be hot? Wouldn't that be some reward for all your managing? The very recent Halloween update shows this perfectly. Some of the girls didn't even get their Gallery picture with their new Halloween outfit. Just a wasted potential. The last thing i have to mention, it was the same damm thing in previous game by Faerin: no proper harem route. Only this very short bonus, final ending. Why?
Overall Mystwood Manor is a solid game if we're talking about gameplay but severely disappointing in terms of actual porn. It feels like this game was not really created with sex content in mind. Gameplay was the main focus, everything else was just not important. That's why the game end up with generic story, generic girls with little to no personality, slow progression with uninteresting events and finally disappointing sex scenes. This is not a bad game, it has some nice gameplay mechanics but from this developer i was expecting something more, something better. In my opinion, if you're not able do make game with good both gameplay and adult content, you should always prioritize adult content. Porn game with good adult content but with bad gameplay or no gameplay at all still could be good. While porn game with disappointing porn fails as a porn game even with good gameplay.