- Thread starter wynin
- Start date
Pretty sure I've seen a version of this post every six months for the last 4-5 years: "I'm a 1337 hax0r with mad skillz and this whole game could be recreated in a couple of months, no problem. Also, writing is super easy and quick, and definitely not most of the time and effort involved."
Every person that's posted that has either done nothing or started and then dropped it because it turned out to be too much work, so I'm gonna go ahead and call bullshit on "The problem is motivation, game design, persistence, decision anxiety, etc. all psychological factors." Just because you don't have to have mastered everything in Knuth to make the game doesn't mean it's "not too hard and not that much of a time-sink."
Well, I will certainly do nothing, nor was I planning to.
I agree that writing and planning are the major time-sinks here (I even say that the technical aspect is the part that isn't the major time-sink (quoting: "technically, it's not too hard"), in case that was not clear), and I was mostly talking about cloning the game ("very easily replicated"), not developing a new one from scratch. Anything other than that would be misrepresentation of what I said or meant to say.
If you want to claim that technical factors are the actual bottle-neck here, be my guest, I would be glad to discuss the technical aspects of it with you, but it just does not look like it from my point of view.
I'm definitely not suggesting that it's technically difficult to replicate the engine; it's not very complicated at all. But, and maybe this was a comprehension issue on my end, it sounded like you meant that replicating the game just wouldn't be all that time-consuming and that's the idea that I'm pushing back against--it's been expressed here over and over that since it's not "hard" like writing an FPS from scratch, a modern OS kernel, or a fast RDBMS, then it must be both quick and easy to knock out.
I guess it boils down to how much our ideas of time-consuming and easy would differ?
I feel that a few months (maybe 3–6?) of part-time but consistent work on the code base would produce something very closely resembling the original. Certainly not a few weeks' job, but also not a seven years' job, either. The text can be scraped out of the JAR, which cuts down on the main time-sink, and the design is already there, so you wouldn't have to really reinvent the wheel or write a lot of text.
As for the easiness, the game doesn't feel particularly sophisticated code-wise (not that it has to be); it doesn't seem like it would need much more than normal Java constructs (that is, not much beyond OOP, control flow) and a small amount of external libraries (the interface is almost certainly made with Swing, and the game has a YAML parser, and probably a serialiser for saving and restoring state). I feel that the ingenuity of this game is in the design rather than its implementation, and when you're cloning an already existing product, the design is already figured out for you.
Now I understand what you're aiming for: A more-or-less exact clone, as close as identical as possible, that you have the source code to (where the last bit is the entire point). Most of the people that have talked about "cloning" or "replicating" the game really mean some combination of the following:
- Roughly the same game design but implemented on a different platform/engine
- A similar game design but with different content or different/new mechanics
- A more-or-less clean room rewrite of the game from scratch, but change X, Y, or Z features
In general, I can't imagine putting in the time and effort necessary to clone Newlife but not changing significant parts of it to suit my tastes and interests, and frankly I dislike having most of the scenes written in Java instead of something easily editable at runtime, so I'd want to change all that too. So I'm not disagreeing with you on the amount of time and effort it would take to clone Newlife, but I don't think many people would want to perfectly clone Newlife anyway.
Glad that we cleared that up! Yeah, I don't see a point to it other than perhaps enabling the community to contribute to it and develop it rather than depending on one author on updates and being at their mercy if they decide to drop development. Perhaps, when the developer decides he's had enough, he could open-source it and we could bypass the folly of carbon-copying the game. It's all wishful thinking and armchair programming, in any case.
The problem is that the movitation to create your own porn game goes out once you jack off.
- Jan 4, 2019
- 28
- 511
Version 0.8.2
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Feb 23, 2023
- 9,209
- 5,048
Newlife-SPLENDIDOSTRICH-0.8.2b
rpdl torrents are unaffiliated with F95Zone and the game developer.
Please note that we do not provide support for games.
For torrent-related issues use here, or join us on
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Please note that we do not provide support for games.
For torrent-related issues use here, or join us on
You must be registered to see the links
!
You must be registered to see the links
,
You must be registered to see the links
. Downloading issues? Look here.
Last edited:
- Nov 21, 2016
- 128
- 209
how to trigger the scenes with the landlord?
when im short on money it just says "youre late on rent" with no option in the week planner or events before/after the rent
with enough money in the bank the game just tells me that i paid it off
when im short on money it just says "youre late on rent" with no option in the week planner or events before/after the rent
with enough money in the bank the game just tells me that i paid it off
- Dec 6, 2016
- 85
- 72
So, if I always have the money to pay rent, the landlord scenes will never show up?
seems like it
i played some weeks fast forward without doing anything to see if they would trigger but when there is enough money the game just tells me that it has been paid off
then i tried spending all my money the week before and just got the "youre late on rent" message once
If you choose the male start: Like 3 minutes, depending on your reading speed. No time at all if you have the intro skip option checked
I knooooow! That's exactly the point here!If you choose the male start: Like 3 minutes, depending on your reading speed. No time at all if you have the intro skip option checked
The main game-play is all about fem MC. Even if MC was male, SHE will never reflect that.
I do know the wedding has a few lines with the MC thinking about it but otherwise, nothing.