- simple, but still enjoyable gameplay
- avoidable, but not avoidable
- wimp mc, but not wimp mc
- knowing it happens, but being surprised
- self-inserting, but gives perspectives
- a mix of smol and big dicks for mc and opponent
- single villain, but mmf
I don't know man, a lot of these seem doable with a bit of creativity.
Off the top of my head:
1) Simple but enjoyable gameplay has been done in stuff tons of times, though it's probably the hardest to actually pull off.
2) Avoidable but unavoidable sounds basically like what we get in a lot of NTR titles where virtually all the sex happens in the NTR route and the vanilla route is just there.
3) Entirely possible to have a character super confident in their comfort zone, but utterly wimpy outside it. Hell, I know a ton of people IRL who fit the bill.
4) Knowing it happens but still being surprised can also be done by obfuscating the details and just giving hints. Nebel Geisterjaeger, for example, could essentially sneak your love interest off under your nose with just hints that
something happened, and likely would do that if you went in blind without a guide; but you could see pretty much all of it if you invested in the surveillance stuff or know where to look when the action was going on.
5) Interlude format for everyone else, basic character creation for the mc (pick your name and a few backstory details that only really affect 3-4 lines of dialogue in actual gameplay), but it does require a bit of writing skill to make the self-insert part convincing for the players.
6) Make all dudes tentacle monsters.
7) Have one villain as the driving force that uses her up and throws her away once he's bored with her.
I'd play the shit out of that game.
with the recent discussions, i dont think there will ever be an NTR game thats unanimously good for everyone
it's not like we're looking for one, we just need enough to cater to each one of us right?
But yeah, my typical contrarianism aside I do agree with you. A game that fits every taste is impossible, because some people specifically want the absence of things other people want. But what we're all really looking for is a decent volume of games that suit our particular tastes.