What would your perfect heroine corruption be in ntr? I see a lot of criticism about how heroine fell, it being too easy, disliking the way it happened etc.
So rather than saying how its not supposed to be, how do you think would the perfect heroine fall happen? Possibly with an example of a game that accomplishes that.
In general, we have the NTR Type ABC from all the responses. This is a very old classification from vndb
You must be registered to see the links
Type A: consensual
Type B: non-con > consensual
Type C: non-con only
Regardless of whatever flavor, there are core tenets that have to exist in every sort of game.
1. Heroine is beautiful.
Physically, mentally, spiritually, morally: she exudes grace and class that puts her above the rest. JP games love to do the ditsy pretty heroine troupe, but I personally love the "strong female character" that we have here in the West. Think Tracer, Aloy, Tifa Lockhart, Wonderwoman, Spidergirl, etc. She's top of class beauty in what exemplifies of a woman.
As such, Type A would never work for me. The moment a heroine cheats because "the other guy is better", she is no longer chaste (in the sense that she devotes her love to a singular man). She becomes ugly.
2. Game is logical.
I would say 85% of NTR games fail this. Right off the bat, classic "get sexually harassed until she is used to it" doesn't work. The slow "corruption" of first touching her ass, grabbing her tits, then making her handjob, blowjob, etc. No real female character would fall for that shit. I'd like to invite authors to think of their dream girl, their girlfriends, wife, etc. How would you as a bad guy get her to love you? It sure ain't fucking her with your 8 inch cock until she becomes a vegetable. That's not how real life works. I invite men without sexual experience to visit communities of women and learn what women like. My recent favorite is /r/HLWomenOnly, where women with high libido complain about not getting fucked properly. /r/TheGirlSurvivalGuide is another. Tons of women post about sex on there, writing about their first time and their "lost love".
There was one recently about how some feminist girl hate "rough sex" in "porn culture" that "rots men's brains", but she loves it with this one guy because she can really "let loose" and let him take control. They write about how that requires trust and intimacy. You do not see this level of writing in any h-games. Men don't do their basic research and write shit games. I personally love Eva Kisse's girls because some of the depraved shit done to her FMCs are written really well in the S & M space.
---
If a NTR game can fulfill these 2 basic criteria: they're already top 5%. I don't care if their art sucks, if there is no music, if it's a VN, etc. Write a good story, write believable dialog, write good characters.
Aside from that, give me a good NTR game where the heroine is truly forced to do sexual things (with a real reason, not the classic "oh no he has a video of me having sex with my husband") or "he's going to bully my son".
Some scenarios:
1. Bad guy has blackmail material that could land wife's man in jail or executed. Think leaking State Secrets, evidence that the loved one committed some serious crimes (whether it is misunderstanding or not, whatever. Just make the wife believe it).
2. Woman is forced to suck and fuck due to hard times. For example, during war times where there is no food, woman is forced so have sex with the enemy occupiers secretly in order to provide for the family. She feels guility and is used like a cum rag. Give me a cute little Church Girl getting her face fucked by the meaniest baddiest man.
3. Man falls into a coma for 2 years and the woman hooks up with one of his enemy. Woman does not know that they don't get along. Man wakes up, woman feels guility but has feelings for the bad guy. Bad guy torments man at work / school when he is trying to rehab, secretly behind the woman.
4. Bad guy rapes woman after he beats her in a fight. Think the classic Tomboy troupe where the woman is a badass and the man is passive, kind, etc. Has a bunch of videos of her absolutely being humiliatied. Girl is afraid that her man will actually kill himself if he finds out, so they sign a contract to suck and fuck behind his back for a period of time. She never falls for the bad guy, but admits she likes the rough sex. After the contract is over, she doesn't "crave cock" and leaves the husband but the bad guy reveals it and the man kills himself