Different tastes indeed. In my opinion the writing in Princess Evangile was atrocious in almost every regard except some comedy scenes.
So it's kinda "in the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king" type of situation, eh? Damn i almost want to see this trainwreck myself. Almost.
I don't mind some MC's i've seen but there those like the guy in Magical Marriage Lunatics I absolutely can't stand. That do such moronic things and wonder why things go wrong.
The ones in Princess Evangile and Noble Works are okay. Not the greatest but tolerable.
If i'm going to go with male MC's I genuinely enjoyed reading then it would be Yamato from Maji de Watashi ni Koishinasai!
Intelligent, funny, badass when needed and not clueless around women. Give him a pair of tits and i'd be happy with that.