It's not a criticism for you - guys that actually do the work for free. It's directed at the owners. This site may be free to us but it generates income for the shareholders (Possibly a lot.. it's ranked like 3700 in the US for traffic) And I do report threads that are violating the rules. Espeically anything with threats or violence or hate. I just don't hit report everytime someone says something stupid. You moderators don't need that headache.
And even if the shareholders of this site made no money, it's still their responsibility to keep a clean house, so to speak. I'm not talking censorship. And speaking of censorship - this is one of the very few forums I have seen where posts get deleted but not archived in any way that the participants can see, and that have no breadcrumbs left in the thread. The same goes for edits. They do edits here with no comment made in the OP to show that an edit was done. As a forum owner and operator for over 22 years, that really gets my back up. But it's a private forum, so I have to live with it.
I don't want posts to go away (like mine did today after the same group of people reported it again) They should be punted to an off-topic area instead. And the repeat offenders get muzzled if they continue to troll game threads that they target as a group. Tell me I am wrong? There's 4 million fucking members on here and yet I see the same dozen or so, in almost each and every thread that has any chance of a certain tag needing to be applied. They badger and passive-aggressively attack devs and other members alike - anyone who has a different opinion then theirs.
And guess what... I have now had to reply to someone here, which is technically off-topic as well, so I am sure I'll see this post go *poof* soon as well. In any event, i really couldn't care less what these guys think. But I do respect what you uploaders and moderators do. Like I said, I've run several forums and I know it's a lot of work. It wasn't a personal attack.
The site doesn't earn any money, we break even. Any excess money is used for community stuff like the Christmas contests we sometimes host, or the iray server we offer to smaller developers for free.
If we properly monetized the site, forced people to disable adblock (which the vast majority use), used popunders/popups, push ads, auto play ads, uploaded to k2s, like the 100s of other porn sites out there, we could comfortably take a full time wage. However, we believe profiting from piracy is abhorrent.
Nobody takes a wage at any level, be it uploaders, moderators, staff, or admins. We are providing a free service and work on it in our free time, despite being incredibly short staffed as we have no where near enough staff to comfortably support a forum of this size. If things are slow or are not up to your standards then you're more then welcome to request a refund.
Regarding your complaint, if we split off all offtopic discussion from game threads, the general discussion/offtopic section would literally get 100s of new threads per day and it would just be a total mess. Your post will remain up, but if you would like to further this discussion, please take it to the offtopic or general discussion subforums, as game threads are not the correct place for it.