VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Skylaroo]

I'm not sure but there is also the bicurious stat for her if I'm correct, maybe the casual lover path can lead to Mina/Hana/Mc relationship if you're on both paths (I said Hana because she seems to appreciate Mina already but you can replace Hana by any romanceable female). It's also just a guess and I'm not even sure if the dev is for harem/mini-harem

The bi-curious stat definitely means interest in girls. My guess is that it'd determine whether the threesome that she wanted is MMF (with Ian?) or MFF (with Hana or Veronica or Felicia?). I wish there is a polygamy path, but I have no idea how the devs would implement it considering there are quite a lot of possibilities with the girls, so limited threesome/orgy scenes might be the limit. We'll see how it goes.

 

[HSHS1111]

If you take Mina to the gym there's definitively chemistry between her and Veronica. And once Felicia knows she isn't the innocent little girl anymore I doubt she'd have a problem to be with Mina in a threesome. So there's plenty prospects.

 

[UnoriginalUserName]

If you take Mina to the gym there's definitively chemistry between her and Veronica. And once Felicia knows she isn't the innocent little girl anymore I doubt she'd have a problem to be with Mina in a threesome. So there's plenty prospects.

Eh...Felicia might actually not want to do that with her in case it fucked up their friendship, same with Mina as weirdly neither of them seem to have very many "real" friends.

...Or, you know, maybe she'd just dive right in there because : Mina

The bi-curious stat definitely means interest in girls. My guess is that it'd determine whether the threesome that she wanted is MMF (with Ian?)

No. Unless she plans to cuck the absolute shit out of him (as in not even touch him) while she's all over the MC, followed by a real breakup, and dumping him outside naked. Then maybe. But otherwise, no. (can you tell I don't like Ian?)

or MFF (with Hana or Veronica or Felicia?).

Yes please! Especially Hana (FUCKING YES PLEASE!!) and Felicia (assuming they're down with it in their friendship or it moves beyond that).

One of the great things about a game with fantastic writing is if the devs are interested they could create pretty much any path or outcome they choose and we don't really have to worry too much about if it'll make sense.

"And with that the MC walked off into the sunset with his lover, Frank and their 3 year old pet possum." isn't likely to happen for example.
...I'd say my preferred "ending" of "MC-Hana-Mina Happily Ever After" (if there will be such a thing) is pretty obvious.

 

[Heinata]

Great update. Mina/Hana/Felicia foursome when?

Also what is up with Killian hate? The dude has been nothing but good friend for the MC. He helped him with job, helps him with girls and is generally supportive. He doesn't treat his girlfriend right and I can condemn him for that, but to you, the MC, he has done nothing wrong.

 

[Drafox]

As a boobs man I have to say I'm completely satisfied...I'm glad the dev appreciates that part of the body and how much erogenous it can be; it's vastly ignored by most of other writers and artists..What a fucking blast.

Felicia has grown on me quite a lot, if I had to rank girls from most interesting to least important it would go like this:

1/ Mina & Kat
2/ Hana & Felicia
3/ Rose (used to be N1 but I didn't like her developement as a character tbh she switched places with Felicia) & Veronica (lovely body but her personality isn't my cup of tea so far; she may climb the ranks in the future though).
4/ Female Ian..Just joking the secondary characters and all quick fucks are ranked here.

 

[UnoriginalUserName]

Great update. Mina/Hana/Felicia foursome when?

Also what is up with Killian hate? The dude has been nothing but good friend for the MC. He helped him with job, helps him with girls and is generally supportive. He doesn't treat his girlfriend right and I can condemn him for that, but to you, the MC, he has done nothing wrong.

Eh...I have personal issues with cheaters, and I fucking detest his uncaring attitude. The MC in the game might think he's a good friend, but I'd have never associated with him in real life. ...which I guess means if Mina the Unicorn actually exists I wouldn't meet her. Figures.

 

[akselx]

Eh...Felicia might actually not want to do that with her in case it fucked up their friendship, same with Mina as weirdly neither of them seem to have very many "real" friends.

This. At least not without convincing.

No. Unless she plans to cuck the absolute shit out of him (as in not even touch him) while she's all over the MC, followed by a real breakup, and dumping him outside naked. Then maybe. But otherwise, no. (can you tell I don't like Ian?)

Since she doesn't mention sex with women if her bi stat isn't high enough, but still mentions threesome, I think there is a possibility to have a threesome with Ian.

Also what is up with Killian hate?

It was here from the beginning, although seemingly just as much people like him enough. I know I do, guy have major abandonment issues and need a tough love from MC. I can almost picture it: MC beating the shit out of Ian then helping him to get up, tells him to get his shit together, hugs him and then they go together towards sunset.
Not going to happen, through. MC doesn't value their friendship nearly as much as Ian does and also has some serious psychological issues.

 

[Darg]

Since she doesn't mention sex with women if her bi stat isn't high enough, but still mentions threesome, I think there is a possibility to have a threesome with Ian

She exactly mentioned the women there couple times, or you can have different dialogue?

 

[akselx]

She exactly mentioned the women there couple times, or you can have different dialogue?

She skips the line about sex with women if her bi score lower then, I'm guessing, 3 or 4, maybe, and only mentions "threesome" in the same sentence with "dick".

 

[dolfe67]

If Mina has at least 2 bicurious points, she says an additional line.

Spoiler: Code

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[HSHS1111]

This. At least not without convincing.

Yeah, right now to Felcia Mina is way too innocent and inexperienced. But if we show her a picture of her tied up and getting fucked in the ass be Edwin she'll lose that notion fast, I think. Still Veronica would probably the better partner as she is into women in the first place. Hmm, Edwin and Veronica doming Mina together ... so many possibilities with that bucket list of hers.

Since she doesn't mention sex with women if her bi stat isn't high enough, but still mentions threesome, I think there is a possibility to have a threesome with Ian.

I think a threesome with Ian would be more likely if they stayed together. Going by the question game at the party Ian would probably be into it. But after Mina dumping him there would need to be some serious character development for both of them because right now I very much doubt Mina will let Ian get anywhere close.

 

[Famescua]

damn i accidentally compressed this game after qwer alraedy did it. anyways here is my version

Pale Carnations gh3 u3

original size 4.22gb

compressed size 1.43gb

You must be registered to see the links

 

[Daken9]

Felica has fallen from my eyes. Two charecter are trying to survive one for her child and second for her business and there is F which intensely want to ruin everything.

Felica's husband is definition and prime example of simp. I mean his life based on a public, cheap and slutty lie.

I am starting to hate this F character!

I thought it was pretty nice, that her motivation for joining the competition was ultimately pretty stupid and grounded on how/who she is.

I mean, devs could've easily made it something tear-jerky for mere sympathy points, but instead they stuck to the character they made (an intelligent if deeply materialistic hoe who willfully made her bed) and even gave us the option to look down on her for it, as someone like the MC, with all his mommy/money issues, would - and as frankly most of us here also would if she were a real person.

This not to say that i don't see her layers, like how she despises the people she grew up around for settling for mediocrity while she's basically doing the same but with more shiny stuff at her disposal (hence the low self-confidence and not very high opinion of herself, we don't like about others what we don't like about ourselves afterall), but rather that i very appreciate her - and the devs work - for them, even if i don't really 'like' her.

 

[inevitableandinfinity8]

I thought it was pretty nice, that her motivation for joining the competition was ultimately pretty stupid and grounded on how/who she is.

I mean, could've easily made it something tear-jerky for mere sympathy points, but instead they stuck to the character they made (an intelligent if deeply materialistic hoe who willfully made her bed) and even gave us the option to look down on her for it, as someone like the MC, with all his mommy/money issues, would - and as frankly most of us here also would if she were a real person.

This not to say that i don't see her layers, like how she despises the people she grew up around for settling for mediocrity while she's basically doing the same but with more shiny stuff at her disposal (hence the low self-confidence and not very high opinion of herself), but rather that i very appreciate her - and the devs work - for them, even if truthfully i don't completely 'like' her.

Hmm...
What about she doing that just for bit of money , while her husband adore her clearly she want to be a public whore , sorry she already is.

On personal level who would you help : A person whose and her child survive at stack or a rich whore, Which travel in sports car and try to buy mc fuck.

It's not a mommy but more of moral issue.

 

[What'sNew]

Is it possible for MC to have a "perfect" photoshoot to present to Kathleen? In all my playthroughs, she says she wishes Felicia was more flustered. Is this always the outcome?

 

[Daken9]

Hmm...
What about she doing that just for bit of money , while her husband adore her clearly she want to be a public whore , sorry she already is.

On personal level who would you help : A person whose and her child survive at stack or a rich whore, Which travel in sports car and try to buy mc fuck.

It's not a mommy but more of moral issue.

I'd say her husband values her as much she does him, which is to say not very much beyond what they can provide for eachother (a trophy and cash). I'd also say, though, that ultimately the sucker is more of a victim than she is. I mean, he's probably cheating too, and he lowkey fucked her up with all his looking down on her, and Felicia or some other hot woman would have likely been the same to him, but like i said, she willfully made her bed.

And as for the mommy issues bit, i was talking about the MC. Morals might be a part of it for him, but as i read it most of his disdain (in the hate-fuck scenario) came from his understanding that Felicia was doing all this stuff that his mom had been 'forced' to do just for shit and giggles. It was personal to him, and it was quite smart of the devs to write it that way 'cause it makes complete sense.

But anyway, i'm in no way trying to justify her actions. What i'm saying is that i appreciate the complexity of her character, and how it comes at the cost of something more cheaply 'likeable'.

 

[Skylaroo]

No. Unless she plans to cuck the absolute shit out of him (as in not even touch him) while she's all over the MC, followed by a real breakup, and dumping him outside naked. Then maybe. But otherwise, no. (can you tell I don't like Ian?)

I don't like Ian either, but my personal feelings is irrelevant because what matters is Mina as a character. So far, she hasn't shown initiative to break things up with him. If MC chose to be fuck buddies and didn't encourage for her to break up with him, there might be a path where they stayed together with MC being the third wheel in the MMF threesome.

What about she doing that just for bit of money , while her husband adore her clearly she want to be a public whore , sorry she already is.

On personal level who would you help : A person whose and her child survive at stack or a rich whore, Which travel in sports car and try to buy mc fuck.

I think this is a bit too shallow of an interpretation about Felicia as a character. She's a much more complex than that. Even the simple claim of trying to buy MC to fuck is not as it seems on the surface, it's more about her trying to not get feelings involved. Though this next part is just my own interpretation, I believe she did so more for MC's benefit rather than her own. She kept on asking MC's age to emphasize his youth and that he didn't have to be stuck with (or following the footsteps of) a woman who is much older, and that he could do better than that.

 

[Squarblesport]

Just wanted to say- What an amazing update! Can't wait for the next one. Thank you @Mutt&Jeff!!!

 

[inevitableandinfinity8]

I'd say her husband values her as much she does him, which is to say not very much beyond what they can provide for eachother (a trophy and cash). I'd also say, though, that ultimately the sucker is more of a victim than she is. I mean, he's probably cheating too, and he lowkey fucked her up with all his looking down on her, and Felicia or some other hot woman would have likely been the same to him, but like i said, she willfully made her bed.

And as for the mommy issues bit, i was talking about the MC. Morals might be a part of it for him, but as i read it most of his disdain (in the hate-fuck scenario) came from his understanding that Felicia was doing all this stuff that his mom had been 'forced' to do just for shit and giggles. It was personal to him, and it was quite smart of the devs to write it that way 'cause it makes complete sense.

But anyway, i'm in no way trying to justify her actions. What i'm saying is that i appreciate the complexity of her character, and how it comes at the cost of something more cheaply 'likeable'.

Bro you are making a shitty argument :
1.There is no proof her husband is cheating on her while she the one doing that.
2. I was also taking about mc : mc knows the ìmportance of money because what his mother have to done for money so who mc shold help women in real need or a woman which just want be a public whore.

3. If you are interested in character you should go for Khatelee or whatever the fuck her name is.

I don't like Ian either, but my personal feelings is irrelevant because what matters is Mina as a character. So far, she hasn't shown initiative to break things up with him. If MC chose to be fuck buddies and didn't encourage for her to break up with him, there might be a path where they stayed together with MC being the third wheel in the MMF threesome.


I think this is a bit too shallow of an interpretation about Felicia as a character. She's a much more complex than that. Even the simple claim of trying to buy MC to fuck is not as it seems on the surface, it's more about her trying to not get feelings involved. Though this next part is just my own interpretation, I believe she did so more for MC's benefit rather than her own. She kept on asking MC's age to emphasize his youth and that he didn't have to be stuck with (or following the footsteps of) a woman who is much older, and that he could do better than that.

I am just seeing things the way they are !
If you are sure : Here is question : Why she felica fucked mc when they meet first time ?
The fact of the matter is : she is a whore by nature other because of the problem they are in.

 

[Daken9]

Bro you are making a shitty argument :
1.There is no proof her husband is cheating on her while she the one doing that.
2. I was also taking about mc : mc knows the ìmportance of money because what his mother have to done for money so who mc shold help women in real need or a woman which just want be a public whore.

3. If you are interested in character you should go for Khatelee or whatever the fuck her name is.

0. Ain't making no argument.
1. Hence the 'probably'.
2. Yes, that's what i said. But if you really want me to answer that, obviously Rosaline is life.
3. Wut