CREATE YOUR AI CUM SLUT ON CANDY.AI TRY FOR FREE
x

Spamwise

Member
Mar 29, 2020
213
249


My personal favorites in no particular order would be probably Serena, Mercedes, Celine, Madison and Lucy.
Who would you choose if you were a member of the CarnationClub?
Obviously Harper runs away with my top spot, but Yoo-ri would be interesting without the pregnancy thing, just for her larger dimensions.
Dalia's fine-ish, but I'd really like a dark skinned, short haired option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: selberdreher

selberdreher

Member
Dec 29, 2017
448
943
Obviously Harper runs away with my top spot, (...)
This is an interesting and - at least for me - unexpected choice, because i always considered Harper as rather unattractive.
Since thankfully personal tastes and the subjective perception of beauty differ, i dont want of course to disrespect this pick of your favorite House Girl in any way; i was always aware that Harper (surprising to me) has her Fans.
(Also it would be kind of a Dick Move to ask for your favourites just to diss you afterwards for it, doesnt makes sense imo)

It is not always easy to tell what exactly we find attractive about a model, but for me, and in this case, i am able to tell what i personally dislike about her appearance:
  • when i was younger i had quite a thing for tattoos, but i noticed that the older i get, the less i like them. Perhaps the reason is that most tattoos dont age very well, and what may have been good looking on a younger woman often just doesnt work well on a middle-aged or older woman. Putting this rather generic dislike aside, i also think full-body suit tattoos tend to look better on east-asian females. However my biggest critic of Harpers tattoo would be the weird choice of colours. The washed-out green and brown hues used in her tattoo look like she is wearing a lizard skin. I would have gone for a much brighter and more primary colour based palette.
  • if i had to choose between the same woman with either short or long hair, i would nearly always go for the long hair version. The only exception would be a very good looking short hair style, which would compliment her face in an extraordinary way.
  • i have always highlighted Jeff&Mutts exceptional use of facial expressions, and again Harper falls flat on that. She has a rather uninteresting face, without distinctive features and is in my opinion often lacking to show emotions. This could be of course intented by the creators, because they specifically wanted to portray Harper this way, but it doesnt help me to like her more.
So if Harper was an east-asian female with long hair and an expressive body tattoo using more like blue and red instead of green and brown, she would score waaaay higher in my book.

I feel the need to stress again: just because i dont think Harper is attractive, doesnt mean that you should feel or need to feel the same way, on the contrary, any other preference is as good (or bad) as mine. We can only explain why we like or dislike this or that and and both views are justified.

So, tastes are different, and these were just mine, however i am interested in why Harper earns your Top Spot?
Is it because you like short hair styles? Or do you especially fancy big Tattoos? Or are you intrigued by her seemingly emotionless personality? Or because she is a good sport in being a Sub?
Perhaps you or any other of Harpers supporters could guide my eye to unseen or overlooked qualities of her?

Looking forward to your answers, because it is always nice to discuss the cast of PC!
 
  • Hey there
Reactions: Turret

Tumai

Member
Sep 1, 2019
479
1,082
Anybody have an idea of what Felicia's secondary stat "self-confidence" will lead to?

For the other competitors, their secondary stats' seems clear cut, who wouldn't want more horniness, for example. However, as a player who finds no appeal in femdom or being Sugarmoma's toyboy, not sure if I should keep Felicia's stat suppressed or not. (If it'll make her bolder in the competition, lead to break-up with her husband/become a painter outcome etc. then that's a different story.)
 

Soul3r

New Member
Sep 5, 2020
9
25
I've been scouring the threads a few times but I'm still clueless as to what is gonzo points. Anyone can answer me?
 

Spamwise

Member
Mar 29, 2020
213
249
It is not always easy to tell what exactly we find attractive about a model, but for me, and in this case, i am able to tell what i personally dislike about her appearance:
  • when i was younger i had quite a thing for tattoos, but i noticed that the older i get, the less i like them. Perhaps the reason is that most tattoos dont age very well, and what may have been good looking on a younger woman often just doesnt work well on a middle-aged or older woman. Putting this rather generic dislike aside, i also think full-body suit tattoos tend to look better on east-asian females. However my biggest critic of Harpers tattoo would be the weird choice of colours. The washed-out green and brown hues used in her tattoo look like she is wearing a lizard skin. I would have gone for a much brighter and more primary colour based palette.
  • if i had to choose between the same woman with either short or long hair, i would nearly always go for the long hair version. The only exception would be a very good looking short hair style, which would compliment her face in an extraordinary way.
  • i have always highlighted Jeff&Mutts exceptional use of facial expressions, and again Harper falls flat on that. She has a rather uninteresting face, without distinctive features and is in my opinion often lacking to show emotions. This could be of course intented by the creators, because they specifically wanted to portray Harper this way, but it doesnt help me to like her more. So, tastes are different, and these were just mine, however i am interested in why Harper earns your Top Spot?
Is it because you like short hair styles? Or do you especially fancy big Tattoos? Or are you intrigued by her seemingly emotionless personality? Or because she is a good sport in being a Sub?
Perhaps you or any other of Harpers supporters could guide my eye to unseen or overlooked qualities of her?

Looking forward to your answers, because it is always nice to discuss the cast of PC!
No worries about offending me or clouding my viewpoint. I'm pretty strongly devoted to what I like.

1-Tattoos are cool, and someone that distinctly ornamented has probably lived an exciting unconventional life.
2-Short Hair is hot, and I would choose it over long 10 times out of 10. But of course, there's a caveat; hairstyles should reflect the character. Harper's choice of short hair is again indicative of a athletic, wild life. No surprise- she's a contortionist and a gymnast. So her hair is both attractive to me personally, and a good storytelling cue. Double points!
3-Yes, emotionless or deadpan girls are rather attractive to me. It's not the only personality I like, but it's high among them. There's nothing sexy about a woman seeking attention, but take one with a brusque or businesslike exterior, and getting to the emotions inside is like a very thrilling challenge.

I'd have to say overall Harper is so interesting to me because she's such an anomaly. Some of the carnations have no marketable skills besides what they're doing, while she's clearly diversely talented and battling a run of bad luck (or sabotage). That interests me; and her introverted guardedness sells it even more. Let the plebs argue about breast size and hair color- what makes a woman interesting is how much of mystery she is.

Of course, that short hair sure doesn't hurt. :love:
 

GhostMGN

New Member
Oct 10, 2021
2
3
3-Yes, emotionless or deadpan girls are rather attractive to me. It's not the only personality I like, but it's high among them. There's nothing sexy about a woman seeking attention, but take one with a brusque or businesslike exterior, and getting to the emotions inside is like a very thrilling challenge.
Sorry for the machine translation.
I'm a big Harper fan too. But I disagree about her emotionless. If you do not take birthday gift from Kathleen's, then Harper will become much friendlier to the MC and this is where my sympathy for her begins, also i am deeply sympathetic to people who do their job well but do not fawn over the bosses.
As for her appearance, I'm not a big fan of large colored tattoos, but for my taste, some flaws against the backdrop of surrounding magnificence (Nicolette's veins for example) give the characters a special charm.
 
Last edited:

Diagnosed

Newbie
Game Developer
May 12, 2022
31
47
Cool game. Im not a fan of a lot of the scenes but there is something for everyone if you stick around. Felicia might be the hottest honey select 1 model of all time.
 

selberdreher

Member
Dec 29, 2017
448
943
(...)
1-Tattoos are cool, and someone that distinctly ornamented has probably lived an exciting unconventional life.
2-Short Hair is hot, and I would choose it over long 10 times out of 10. But of course, there's a caveat; hairstyles should reflect the character. Harper's choice of short hair is again indicative of a athletic, wild life. No surprise- she's a contortionist and a gymnast. So her hair is both attractive to me personally, and a good storytelling cue. Double points!
3-Yes, emotionless or deadpan girls are rather attractive to me. It's not the only personality I like, but it's high among them. There's nothing sexy about a woman seeking attention, but take one with a brusque or businesslike exterior, and getting to the emotions inside is like a very thrilling challenge.

I'd have to say overall Harper is so interesting to me because she's such an anomaly. Some of the carnations have no marketable skills besides what they're doing, while she's clearly diversely talented and battling a run of bad luck (or sabotage). That interests me; and her introverted guardedness sells it even more. Let the plebs argue about breast size and hair color- what makes a woman interesting is how much of mystery she is.

Of course, that short hair sure doesn't hurt. :love:
(...) If you do not take birthday gift from Kathleen's, then Harper will become much friendlier to the MC and this is where my sympathy for her begins, also i am deeply sympathetic to people who do their job well but do not fawn over the bosses. (...)
Glad i asked and thank you guys for your answers!
You two were able to shine light unto some aspects of Harper which eluded me sofar, because i never followed her path i guess.
(During Hanas concert i had the conversation with August and i took the birthday gift from Kathleen)
I didnt knew about her being a contortionist and gymnast and was also unaware of her problems; although having problems seem to be a common attribute of the HouseGirls, as the CarnationClub thrives on cornered women.

I can relate to pretty much all of the points you mentioned, especially the challenge of melting an icy heart.
I am not particularly attracted to the introvert, "deadpan" Type, but they are indeed often interesting and even fascinating, probably because they are so hard to read and guard their secrets so well.

(Side Note: My Avatar is Mero Furuya from Sankarea. I like her (in a non-sexual way, you pervs! she is fucking twelve!), because she is obviously cool (you know in the "cool" sense, not in the cool sense; ahem, nevermind, it works in german).
Commonly classified as a "Kuudere", a characterization which usually encompasses the traits we associated with Harper.
Yeah, but this went deep into geek territory, sorry for that.)
 
4.90 star(s) 501 Votes