- Mar 31, 2022
- 557
- 3,748
- Thread starter GIL3D
- Start date
-
- Tags
- 3dcg ahegao anal sex animated bdsm big ass big tits bukkake cheating creampie exhibitionism female domination groping group sex handjob humiliation lactation lesbian male domination male protagonist masturbation milf mobile game multiple penetration oral sex prostitution romance sex toys spanking teasing titfuck urination vaginal sex voyeurism
- Jun 15, 2017
- 207
- 646
There is a rather bad glitch in the game, when I load a save from before the second exhibition and receive a text message from Rose the morning of the exhibition it suddenly changes halfway through to a text from Hana and suddenly puts me on the date with Hana before I've done the exhibition. So basically the game doesn’t let you do the exhibition and forces you to do the Hana date and ends the game making you miss the whole exhibition. Anyone else experiencing this?
Thank you for making Veronica Week 2 Competition Max Point now being 5 because that actually would add to better experience for first time players that specifically chose not to perform with Rosie. Since Ian+Rosie defaults at 5.It was considered, largely for the sake of having parity between Hana and Mina's respective scenes, but having Edwin explain the situation with Mina, her bucket list, and the impetus behind it seemed (to me) pretty out of step with the pace and tone of the scene. It's true that the longer Edwin waits to bring it up, the more damning it becomes if he does choose to broach the subject with Hana, but let me assure you it's not something I plan on dragging out for the sake of cheap drama.
(...and let's not forget if you're Felicia's would-be sugar baby, that would be a whole other thing to explain.)
So I settled on having Edwin acknowledge he's at a (fast-approaching) critical juncture, as I believe there's a better time and place for him to bring it up that will more neatly set up and lay out the various outcomes.
--
I support your thought process on not having Edwin tell Hana about the Mina deal on the date night. The game is good because the characters feels like real people. And on that, I think Edwin as a person wouldn't tell Hana at that night anyway. This is a person that keeps her mother's secret his whole life, and player-dependent, suppresses his own depravity.
If Main Character (Edwin) is merely an avatar of "we" the player, then yeah it's disappointing to not be given the chance to be upfront with Hana right then and there because some players would want to do that. Me included actually.
But Edwin as a person probably rationalizes and find justification that not talking about the Mina deal would be "better for Hana" for that night.
- Dec 8, 2017
- 790
- 7,363
Is this the uncompressed, non-modded walkthrough version?
You're the third person to mention this, but I can't replicate it myself and another person also tried and it progressed as normal.
- Apr 30, 2017
- 4,551
- 20,227
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Sep 20, 2018
- 3,420
- 14,167
You're probably right, but then again Victoria and Spider have profiles and all indications are they're off the menu. It's possible Grace may be included purely for her importance to the plot/other characters. Personally I'd say the MC's well established crush on Grace is a better indication that she'll eventually see some action than her profile page.
Excellent analysis. But I have a few points of disagreement.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Eh, my main MC has about as bad a relationship with Kat as it's possible to have and he still had the option to go to Kathleen at the end of Chapter 3. I think you just need the latest versions of Pale Carnations (either the Ch3Up4 public release, or Ch4Up1).
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Last edited:
I seconded that Kathleen take. On my first playthrough playing naturally using MC as an avatar of my personal choice, Kathleen and the MC does not get along. I don't think the dialogue changes that much, the face changes though. There are more frowny faces after the choices.
When I made another playthrough embracing the depravity, it does feel like Kathleen and MC is in a Master and Student budding relationship.
That said, I always went to August when dealing with Rosie's debt, what happened if Good Guy Edwin ask Kathleen to help?
Did she just say no because it's policy?
- Jun 16, 2022
- 395
- 470
I can respect that. Thank you for the clarification.It was considered, largely for the sake of having parity between Hana and Mina's respective scenes, but having Edwin explain the situation with Mina, her bucket list, and the impetus behind it seemed (to me) pretty out of step with the pace and tone of the scene. It's true that the longer Edwin waits to bring it up, the more damning it becomes if he does choose to broach the subject with Hana, but let me assure you it's not something I plan on dragging out for the sake of cheap drama.
(...and let's not forget if you're Felicia's would-be sugar baby, that would be a whole other thing to explain.
So I settled on having Edwin acknowledge he's at a (fast-approaching) critical juncture, as I believe there's a better time and place for him to bring it up that will more neatly set up and lay out the various outcomes.
- Jun 25, 2018
- 481
- 1,742
I hope you meant Jerrica not Spider, out of all female characters that have their own profile only her (and Grace) has no sexual content (there is also Sophia Lundgren but she does have sexual content and will surely interact with Edwin sooner or later, Veronica is off limits but does have sexual content).
Anyway, yeah, I'm aware that profile page isn't much of an indicator but considering we barely interact with her and we can make a deal with her and now Ian might be aware of it (and he knows Edwin had a crush on her, the drinking game confirmed it) I don't see a reason why she would be introduced in such a way in a porn game other than for us to bang her :]. I hate red herrings and so far TD hasn't disappointed, that's why I'm eagerly waiting on Ian collecting debt that Edwin owes him (if he lost the bet about Alice and agreed to do whatever Ian asked him to do).
BTW, when it comes to threesomes not only H-E-M is possible but also F-E-M. After all, just after seeing Ian sex tape she suggested doing her own sex tape but with Felicia and Edwin:
mina "You should see the look on your faces."
mina "I'm... kidding. Just..."
mina "...kidding."
mina "I mean, could you imagine it?"
mina "You? ...me?" "...and Edwin?"
mina "Nope!"
mina "File that alongside the growing list of bad impulses today."
We now know it's on her bucket list.
I think she agrees but there are strings attached (or not if you have social chameleon trait).
Edit:
Just like Grace is aware that Ian is a man-child and a pervert, I'm pretty sure Victoria knows that too. On a side note, I wouldn't be surprised if she was attracted to him hence she's shown herself like this:
She's basically flashing her vagina to her son(s). The interesting thing is that Edwin suspects that Ian is attracted to her too but he can't be sure.
Anyway, I don't think whether she knew Chuck's influence over him (which she might suspect, Ian and her are close after all) or that Ian was working in a sex club would change much. She is aware that their work is somewhat fishy and that it involves Chuck and she's not stupid. Also, seeing her son suddenly getting a huge apartment where there are different hot women around each time she visits suggests that. Maybe she suspects it's a strip-club but I'm pretty sure she's close to the truth.
Last edited:
Hana chapter is good but I love the progress between MC and Veronica's relationship.
I still ship Veronica. Veronica ftw
I still ship Veronica. Veronica ftw
- Jun 22, 2018
- 521
- 775
Nah, it is kind of normal for a mother to wear a towel in front of her son(s) (she kinda is Ian mother since as far as we know she gave him much more affection and love than her) without even thinking about it. Imho Edwin is projecting and thinks that Ian likes Victoria just because he actually had a crush for his mother Grace. One of the main differences between the two is that Edwin perverted nature is twisted and repressed in total contrast to Ian who is immature and straightforward.
Last edited:
Just replayed this from the beginning and I seem to have encountered a bug? When Rosalind is supposed to send her second photo to the MC it transitions to Hana sending one instead and then the game proceeds directly to Hana and MC's date, which cuts out a lot of content. Anyone else have this issue? I am using the walkthrough mod if thats relevant
Edit: Apologies I saw a few others have had similar issues. I'm also using the uncompressed version so I assume it's an issue with the walkthrough mod
Edit: Apologies I saw a few others have had similar issues. I'm also using the uncompressed version so I assume it's an issue with the walkthrough mod
Last edited:
I don't know if my eyes are playing tricks on me but I just noticed that you can see faint outlines of veins on Hana's boobs. If true then that's nice attention detail.
- Aug 25, 2021
- 30
- 248
Excellent sex scene with Hana. I speculate that Cynthia will end up being Hana's first recruit to Pale Carnations. I would like to see the MC get involved in recruitment too: the place must always be in need of fresh meat, and it seems like it would be a logical progression for him to be thrust into that role.
- Aug 1, 2019
- 31
- 73
Wowowowow
It isn't every day that erotica gets me interested in the plot, much less thinking abstract.
This one is my favorite for sure.
Most porn games go with the, "this is your one dimensional fuck toy, go nuts" approach but this one had me actually feeling the characters' struggles and going to mental war with myself on whether or not they should actually be here.
It isn't every day that erotica gets me interested in the plot, much less thinking abstract.
This one is my favorite for sure.
Most porn games go with the, "this is your one dimensional fuck toy, go nuts" approach but this one had me actually feeling the characters' struggles and going to mental war with myself on whether or not they should actually be here.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Last edited:
10/10 update. can't wait for that hana-mina threeway
- Oct 16, 2019
- 669
- 1,877
I don't buy it. I think it's familiarity meant to simply illustrate how long they've all known each other.
In fact, I bet if there was one women Ian wouldn't touch sexually with a ten foot pole, it's her. He views her as his mother figure more than his own mother. He doesn't want sex from her, he wants affection, love, and affirmation. He wants her to be proud of him regardless of his choices; Likely a reflection on what he wants from his actual mother (though we don't really know quite enough about that dynamic yet to say anything definitively, I think)
- Mar 31, 2022
- 557
- 3,748
Walkthrough Update
I've updated my walkthrough on my post
Or here is a direct link: PaleCarnations-Ch4Up1_walkthrough-rev-1.1.1.pdf
If you want to support my work, you can:
Visit my thread to post suggestions for my next work.
Walkthrough is also available here:
Cheers,
Mr Bubu
I've updated my walkthrough on my post
Or here is a direct link: PaleCarnations-Ch4Up1_walkthrough-rev-1.1.1.pdf
If you want to support my work, you can:
You must be registered to see the links
Visit my thread to post suggestions for my next work.
Walkthrough is also available here:
You must be registered to see the links
Cheers,
Mr Bubu