Antera

Active Member
Nov 19, 2017
801
1,296
So I am replaying game (been more then year since I last played).. And have question about Rose and Ian

Did he actually banged her, before MC meeting her?
 

TD1900

#701
Game Developer
Dec 8, 2017
791
7,440
So I am replaying game (been more then year since I last played).. And have question about Rose and Ian

Did he actually banged her, before MC meeting her?
That is what is implied by Rosalind at the start of the game. I can't remember if Ian ever explicitly confirms it, I wrote that shit awhile ago. :KEK:
 

Alphaeboy

Active Member
Jul 22, 2019
630
977
Question will be okay to do Feliecia's path while being Mina's? Will there be a threesome if it's possible?
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,420
14,169
dude tastes are subjective and all but that just looks like a standard set of anime knockers which are far from perfect. The proportions are all wrong and there's nothing really beautifully shaped about them other than they're just BIG.


I bring this up because in a game full of really good dialogue, storytelling, pacing, interior design art, set art, character face art and emotions, the boobs look the most cheaply done and unispired. Basically every character has a set of DDs bolted on, rinse and repeat.

(fully aware of how unpopular this take will be :ROFLMAO:, but right is right)

I agree the textures are good, just the overall shape needs work and variety. Also can I start a petition for the de-ratchetification of the girls nails?
Eh, TD and GIL like big breasts, so they gave the Pale Carnations universe a somewhat larger average cup size than our own. The rest of the game is more than good enough to cut them some slack for not appreciating the perfect bust size. :p


Honestly that was one if not the only really stern look she ever gave the MC, so in my opinion that worked very well. Then again, "my MC" is still trying to do what he can, to help the women as much as he can.

Overall that call was one of my favorite scenes of the whole update and I found it an exemplary way of "show don't tell" and showing Rosa's motivation that way via her relationship with a character the player can't even see isn't easy.
It's not a bad look by any means, I just thought it wasn't quite right. Rosalind should project a little more menace because this is one of the few times where she really might rip the MC a new one if he tries anything that her daughter could hear. IMHO, obviously.


You're not the only one, a few people have mentioned having issues. If you have any quick/auto saves, I'd try those.
Come to think of it, I did have an error on the last save for my main run; fortunately I'm something of a save-rat so I just loaded the previous one and carried on. I think the problem had to do with saving during the reworked scene with Abel rather than at Victoria's later one because I didn't have a problem on any of my other save paths.


Question will be okay to do Feliecia's path while being Mina's? Will there be a threesome if it's possible?
I'd say your odds are very good. Neither girl is interested in a formal commitment at this time. Mina is specifically interested in experimenting with the MC and Felicia, and Felicia is generally down for kinky things and seems to like Mina.

I don't think it would work long term, but a one-time threesome doesn't seem like much of a stretch before the end of the game.


As close to Pale Carnations as possible, with a good story and also plenty of choice. I also like the corruption part, if you like it too.
Pale Carnations is in a league of its own; close is going to be a very relative term.

Still, if you like choice and corruption, you might want to try Friends in Need. The writing is very good, the characters are very well presented, and the difference between being a nice guy and a monster is pronounced. The downside is that the game is more lopsided in favor of corruption content, and the story, while good, is a lot more slice of life than unfolding plot. Plus the dev has a hard time saying no to the girls he creates, so there are (IMHO) too many girls to split time between. It's still worth playing, though.
 
Jun 25, 2021
126
634
I always looked at the ridiculously high rating of the game and wanted to play it, but was put off by the style. I dislike the look the asian style character rendering program (IDK what the software is called), because the characters tend to look like plastic without any detail and the lighting looks bland and bad. The dev has managed to overcome these issues - the lighting looks good and the backgrounds are wonderfully lush and detailed.

After so much time, I finally decided to give it a shot. It took some time to get going and for me to get hooked, but after that, I could not stop. It ate my whole weekend. There is so much content and all of it is very engaging.

It also has one of my favorite characters now - Veronica. A bisexual muscular woman whose muscles are an integral part of a great story feels like it was tailor made for my interests.
 
Last edited:

Alphaeboy

Active Member
Jul 22, 2019
630
977
Eh, TD and GIL like big breasts, so they gave the Pale Carnations universe a somewhat larger average cup size than our own. The rest of the game is more than good enough to cut them some slack for not appreciating the perfect bust size. :p



It's not a bad look by any means, I just thought it wasn't quite right. Rosalind should project a little more menace because this is one of the few times where she really might rip the MC a new one if he tries anything that her daughter could hear. IMHO, obviously.



Come to think of it, I did have an error on the last save for my main run; fortunately I'm something of a save-rat so I just loaded the previous one and carried on. I think the problem had to do with saving during the reworked scene with Abel rather than at Victoria's later one because I didn't have a problem on any of my other save paths.



I'd say your odds are very good. Neither girl is interested in a formal commitment at this time. Mina is specifically interested in experimenting with the MC and Felicia, and Felicia is generally down for kinky things and seems to like Mina.

I don't think it would work long term, but a one-time threesome doesn't seem like much of a stretch before the end of the game.



Pale Carnations is in a league of its own; close is going to be a very relative term.

Still, if you like choice and corruption, you might want to try Friends in Need. The writing is very good, the characters are very well presented, and the difference between being a nice guy and a monster is pronounced. The downside is that the game is more lopsided in favor of corruption content, and the story, while good, is a lot more slice of life than unfolding plot. Plus the dev has a hard time saying no to the girls he creates, so there are (IMHO) too many girls to split time between. It's still worth playing, though.
Yeah playing as Dark MC freaks me out, and I felt bad for playing as him that way.
 

Pr0GamerJohnny

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 7, 2022
6,776
10,145
Eh, TD and GIL like big breasts, so they gave the Pale Carnations universe a somewhat larger average cup size than our own. The rest of the game is more than good enough to cut them some slack for not appreciating the perfect bust size. :p
Absolutely, which is why I prefaced it with a heaping of praise for other elements. Everything else is great.

Just don't tell me that an Escalade is a Maserati. :LOL:

This

Will never be this
wt.jpg
 

Takkatakka

Engaged Member
Nov 11, 2022
3,063
9,879
It's not a bad look by any means, I just thought it wasn't quite right. Rosalind should project a little more menace because this is one of the few times where she really might rip the MC a new one if he tries anything that her daughter could hear. IMHO, obviously.
I got that. What I meant is, that while her look might not be that menacing coming from someone like Warren, who looks like that all the time, coming from her, from someone who is always very submissive and tries to smile most things away, it actually looks menacing. Coming from her, this is a very "THIS is serious!" look, so for me it worked.

It's a bit of a relative thing.
 

dolfe67

Forum Fanatic
Apr 25, 2020
5,082
14,100
I got that. What I meant is, that while her look might not be that menacing coming from someone like Warren, who looks like that all the time, coming from her, from someone who is always very submissive and tries to smile most things away, it actually looks menacing. Coming from her, this is a very "THIS is serious!" look, so for me it worked.

It's a bit of a relative thing.
Yeah, first time was with the "deal" event. It was a nice character twist/reveal
 

zszszszs32

Newbie
Jul 14, 2017
23
10
TD1900 You have real talent as a writer. Way beyond anything necessary for porn. If you have aspirations in other genres you should give it a shot. My one criticism is that the heart to hearts or discussions of values come too often and too easily. It's unnatural, though being subject to what is basically torture makes it more believable for the carnations. It works best when revealed through actions or the discussion of other subjects like the scene where Veronica describes throwing.
 

TD1900

#701
Game Developer
Dec 8, 2017
791
7,440
TD1900 You have real talent as a writer. Way beyond anything necessary for porn. If you have aspirations in other genres you should give it a shot. My one criticism is that the heart to hearts or discussions of values come too often and too easily. It's unnatural, though being subject to what is basically torture makes it more believable for the carnations. It works best when revealed through actions or the discussion of other subjects like the scene where Veronica describes throwing.
I do jokingly think of Pale Carnations as Spill Your Guts: The Porn Game. No, you see, Pale Carnations is actually set in a universe where the average cup size is DD, everyone went to therapy, and are so painfully aware they're in a movie that they ham it up. :Kappa:

Jokes aside, fair criticism, thank you. For me though, porn is what I care about and aspire to create.
 
4.90 star(s) 502 Votes