VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

I'll be honest, after watching both scenes it wasnt even close to a hard choice. The solo scene is just so much better I'm kind of amazed its not just part of her base story and people can actually miss it by choosing the 3some path. The solo is such an intimate moment and such a point of development for her character.

It was good except for the conclusion personally. A choice between anal or [non-penetrative view] vag sex felt kinda lackluster given all the buildup.

Kissing was nice though.

 

[micojive]

It was good except for the conclusion personally. A choice between anal or [non-penetrative view] vag sex felt kinda lackluster given all the buildup.

Kissing was nice though.

Eh the non view was fine imo. The dev hasnt shy'd away from showing everything so its not like they use it to just mask being shitty at showing sex scenes like some other devs do. Having the entire scene just be spooning and kissing without the need to spread the girl wide, or make overtly obscene moves just added to the intimacy imo. Not every sex scene in the game needs to be a fluid flying pound fest, and the choice here felt right with how the rest of the date had gone up to that point.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

Eh the non view was fine imo. The dev hasnt shy'd away from showing everything so its not like they use it to just mask being shitty at showing sex scenes. Having the entire scene just be spooning and kissing without the need to spread the girl wide, or make overtly obscene moves just added to the intimacy imo. Not every sex scene in the game needs to be a fluid flying pound fest, and the choice here felt right with how the rest of the date had gone up to that point.

shrug, to each their own, I'd rather have both, a scene with passionate kissing alongside explicit sex; for me the latter isn't incongruent with the former. Granted, having 'spread the girl wide' like some piledriver woulda felt out of place The earlier Felicia photoshoot home visit office sex scene IMO was a perfect example of combining intimacy with intensity (missionary on desk)

 

[Jacowboy]

I'll be honest, after watching both scenes it wasnt even close to a hard choice. The solo scene is just so much better I'm kind of amazed its not just part of her base story and people can actually miss it by choosing the 3some path. The solo is such an intimate moment and such a point of development for her character.

Oh no, I agree completely... but it kinda sucks since I was looking forward to the blondie sandwich, I wish we could have both, but it is what it is... the solo scene complements the story MUCH better without a doubt.

 

[Meabe37]

It was good except for the conclusion personally. A choice between anal or [non-penetrative view] vag sex felt kinda lackluster given all the buildup.

Kissing was nice though.

I disagree with lackluster but i would say that it felt a bit short (the sex part not the date). It didn't need a super big scene (like others before) but just a little bit more would have been perfect.

That being said no 3some on Fel path felt a bit punishing for those you really like her since she is in it... it should have been stack against another girl path instead in my opinion.

 

[Randomguy3478]

Man, I'm really disappointed.

- MCs orgasm with Hana is ruined just for a joke

- then he eats his own cum by making out with her directly after cumming in her mouth

- the threesome with rose is again only about impressing and pleasuring her; she should pay them 5000$ not the other way round

- getting blueballed in the lucy scene; finally it seems like we can make use of one of the prostitutes in A GAME PLAYING IN A BROTHEL only for the MC to... finger her to climax - the end


wtf is this?

honestly this seems more and more like a fetish about impressing women

I mean, holy lord, can the MC for once just enjoy having sex without trying to cure his lack of self esteem?


I cannot understand you guys' taste.

The writing and especially GIL's visuals are of course stellar again.

Thanks nonetheless for the effort

 

[CalicoBROOJ]

It was good except for the conclusion personally. A choice between anal or [non-penetrative view] vag sex felt kinda lackluster given all the buildup.

Kissing was nice though.

Is the anal penetration not shown again? I think the first anal scene (Felicia in her husbands office I think) you couldn't see the penetration.

 

[Jacowboy]

Man, I'm really disappointed.

- then he eats his own cum by making out with her directly after cumming in her mouth

- the threesome with rose is again only about impressing and pleasuring her; she should pay them 5000$ not the other way round

On the first point I quoted, you shouldn't be surprised... it's not the first time, hell, not even the second time it can happen...

And on the second point, that's not really the point of the scene AT ALL... it's all got to do with their bromance, the rest is really secondary.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

On the first point I quoted, you shouldn't be surprised... it's not the first time, hell, not even the second time it can happen...

And on the second point, that's not really the point of the scene AT ALL... it's all got to do with their bromance, the rest is really secondary.

Yeah that's how I saw it, it's not like a literal "we're paying you 5 grand to perform sexual services", but more like "we can do you a solid and help you out here, if you're willing to have some fun with us".

 

[Jacowboy]

Yeah that's how I saw it, it's not like a literal "we're paying you 5 grand to perform sexual services", but more like "we can do you a solid and help you out here, if you're willing to have some fun with us".

Not even, the way I see it is that Ian is kind of an asshole, but he's not a bad guy, I really think he agreed to help Rosie (specially since the MC cares about it) 'cause he's a chill guy, but he also saw an opportunity to do something he's wanted to do with his bro for a while, as a bonding experience between them... and that's really what's going on in that scene, it's not about who is being pleasured or not, for Ian it's totally about bonding with his bro and making up for lost time.

 

[Orangeyouglad]

Man, I'm really disappointed.


- then he eats his own cum by making out with her directly after cumming in her mouth

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[TD1900]

Not even, the way I see it is that Ian is kind of an asshole, but he's not a bad guy, I really think he agreed to help Rosie (specially since the MC cares about it) 'cause he's a chill guy, but he also saw an opportunity to do something he's wanted to do with his bro for a while, as a bonding experience between them... and that's really what's going on in that scene, it's not about who is being pleasured or not, for Ian it's totally about bonding with his bro and making up for lost time.

That sounds almost as gay as eating pussy, dude.

 

[Jacowboy]

That sounds almost as gay as eating pussy, dude.

Pshh... I'm so straight I'd be a lesbian if I was a woman...

 

[name]

i'm a few versions behind, if i download just the latest update will that break anything? or do i have to download the whole game

Pshh... I'm so straight I'd be a lesbian if I was a woman...

didn't know Drake posted here

 

[HUNUTAN]

I can assure you that was GIL at his most interested, and that the cause of your disappointment rests somewhere else other than a lack of enthusiasm on his part. I'm actually stumped on how you'd call any of that "very little expression", other than perhaps you want ahegaos and eyes rolling back into heads or maybe more climatic close ups? In which case, you can blame my direction for not calling for those in the script.

Anyway, probably an isolated case, so don't be too worried?

Yes, I meant the first option with ahegao and rolling of the eyes. The close-ups of one part of the body are not very pleasant to look at and the overall view is much better given the limited scenes, so it's ok.
You may be right, I started to panic too early. It’s just that the developers of such games have recently begun to frustrate players more often than to please them with their attitude towards their own games. Therefore, you begin to look at such changes with caution.

 

[GIL3D]

By the way, why do so few animated scenes have slightly varying points of view? Like, when it goes to a sort of pov, why does it keep static instead of the viewpoint swinging up and down, if you know what I mean. Always wondered that.

It bothers me when the camera moves too much. As a viewer. I know a lot of other artists like to move it around but I will only ever add anything other than a mild sway on TD's request.

 

[shazba jnr]

Love this game... but the sexual onomatopoeia...



Sounds like he's fucking a broken R2D2...

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

 

[Lust0ne]

just started playing and after seeing MC mom feel a missed opportunity. She is hot older woman in need of loving . Great game so far

 

[msleomac]

Walkthrough Update


Hey everyone, here's my walkthrough for this great game. I hope you find it useful to navigate the game and get all the hidden gems.


If you want to support my work, you can:

You must be registered to see the links

Visit my thread to post suggestions for my next work.

Walkthrough is also available here:

You must be registered to see the links

Spoiler: Changelog

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Cheers,
Mr Bubu

just heads up. new game ver out

 

[msleomac]

Well yes, I did it again.

While waiting for the incoming update I wrote another game mini-guide.

After my Pale Carnations story timeline scene-by-scene, here you have my

Pale Carnations not-so-side characters: a guide to house girls and patrons. What we know about them till now.

Heavy spoilers, of course. So don't read it unless you completed your gameplay!

----------

guide has been updated!

just heads up. new game ver out