VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

4.90 star(s) 471 Votes
Discussion Reviews (471)
Skeltom

Skeltom

Engaged Member
Oct 9, 2017
2,329
2,763
Ottoeight said:
Having the same discussion about the very same pointless subject over and over and over and over and over is really tiring, and it happens in every fucking damn game thread.

- you have a very well written overview

- you have very explanatory preview pictures

- THERE IS NO NTR TAG

Still, they ask.
Click to expand...
Fair, but it's pointless to you, not them. Not saying it wouldn't do them some good to actually read the OP but the best you can do is take it up with them or ignore them and go about your day. The forum members don't have a hive mind. There will always be people asking questions like that. And people like you asking why.
 
T

tak51

Newbie
Dec 17, 2017
46
19
how to get Mina&Felicia scene in last update? I tried going back to not go with felicia at the art exposition and still get close to Mina but I still don't get the scene.
What's the requirement for this scene? Do I have to go back farther to be Mina boyfriend?
 
Skeltom

Skeltom

Engaged Member
Oct 9, 2017
2,329
2,763
tak51 said:
how to get Mina&Felicia scene in last update? I tried going back to not go with felicia at the art exposition and still get close to Mina but I still don't get the scene.
What's the requirement for this scene? Do I have to go back farther to be Mina boyfriend?
Click to expand...
You need to be on both of their paths and say "The more the merrier" after the art show.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ename144
Skeltom

Skeltom

Engaged Member
Oct 9, 2017
2,329
2,763
dolfe67 said:
And have 4 points in Mina's bicurious stat I think
Click to expand...
Ah yep, 3 points actually >=3. Not hard to get at all so I guess I just missed it. But I guess you have to tell her to break it off with Ian as well to get the Mina wants to watch.

Edit: Never mind I'm pretty sure the break off is if you stop your deal.
 
Last edited:
T

Turret

Engaged Member
Jun 23, 2017
3,740
6,447
ename144 said:
I don't know that we should put *too* much stock in anything Abel says. His description of August is certainly plausible, but he doesn't provide any hard evidence for his speculation and Abel's motives are highly suspect.

That said, it's obvious pissing off August would be a bad idea, the question is what that would take. At the moment, his overriding priority seems to be bonding with Hana. He evidently thinks having the MC around the Club helps Hana feel comfortable. She likes the MC (the exact amount depending on our choices) and clearly feels better having him around - both as someone her age, and as a fellow newcomer trying to find their role in the place.

I suspect August is willing to tolerate a fair amount of disrespect as long as the MC continues to serve the main goal. If the MC should stop making Hana comfortable, that's when we'll need to walk a lot more carefully. And if the MC manages to piss Hana off enough to be a net discomfort to her, that's when things could quite literally end in blood.

All the more reason not to cheat on her. :whistle:
Click to expand...
Hi!
While it is correct that Abel and Sophia have their own (currently mostly) unknown reasons for coming to our MC and even giving him Sophia´s telefone number as an "emergency call option", their description of the PC club bosses cannot be far from the truth for several reasons.

1) Lying to the MC would be counterproductive in the long run. Lies can be found out and Abel and Sophia want Edwin´s trust if they have the goal of recruiting him for their side. So their description of August, Kat and Chuck has to be mostly true.
2) While I play a nice Edwin in my 3 canon playthroughs, I also try to keep some modicum of good relations with my bosses. And because of Hana, I certainly did try to win brownie points with August in special. If you do that, you´ll learn quite a bit about August which underlines the description by Abel and Sophia for the most part.
August himself tells us that he wasn´t and isn´t a good person. It becomes obvious that as he ages, August has become more self-reflective and recognizes how little good he did so far in his life. Unlike Kat or Chuck it seems August came to the conclusion to start some kind of balancing the scales. At least when it comes to his daughter.
3) If you choose to go to August with Rosi´s loan shark problem, he is really happy when "Oliver" does not react like Edwin and Ian hope. It becomes clear during your conversation that Oliver now either gets an offer he cannot refuse at best, but from the phrasing it is more likely he gets a gift of e.g. concrete shoes.
4) Depending on how you play, August can really like you and even tells you that he is ok with your and Hana´s relationship. There are certain situations this also becomes clear by his reactions. As long as you and Hana are happy and your presence helps Hana with easing into the Club and reconnect with August, there will be no problem at all. On the other hand, I doubt we will like what can happen if August came to the conclusion, we make Hana sad and disturb him and Hana reconcil.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DirtyMario and fred9320
Ungawa

Ungawa

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2017
1,513
3,222
So an update on where I am in PC...

Got most of the unlock until Veronica's update. Played once with Hana while cheating, I'm going a FWB route because man, the situations just keep piling up. Hana's night of wild abandon still best sex in game and Mina's cute hotel scene is still great. Gotta see how Veronica's is before I comment.

I do find myself taking similar routes and not diverting TOO much when I can. As stated before, I LIKE the scenes with the LIs and going to August or Chuck just seems pointless. Still do it just to see the scene and take notes (look, the granite note pad is TOUGH), but overall, but familiarity with what's there before seems the most plausible for my version of Edwin so far.

I probably won't make it before the Felicia update drops, but I'm going to try. ;_;
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarkLords00, Mythrs, TD1900 and 1 other person
Shawnchapp

Shawnchapp

Well-Known Member
Modder
Feb 13, 2018
1,926
5,064
tak51 said:
how to get Mina&Felicia scene in last update? I tried going back to not go with felicia at the art exposition and still get close to Mina but I still don't get the scene.
What's the requirement for this scene? Do I have to go back farther to be Mina boyfriend?
Click to expand...
need to be on both their paths and have her cheat on ian with you, and also have a bi score 3 or above.
 
DegenPink

DegenPink

Newbie
Sep 14, 2021
21
11
After re-extracting hard worked. I had the other mods from here in there as well, and hadn't removed soft, so there was a conflict.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fred9320
Phase_01

Phase_01

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2021
1,173
1,896
Tyson Mikel said:
Is this game NTR type? I saw multiple penetration tag.

Dude can you please tell me is this game NTR?
Click to expand...
This game is not vanilla, neither is it NTR (it can be considered Netori, which is NOT ntr, since the MC is not the one being cucked)

The game has what I would call 2 real Love Interests, that don't have ntr
There are also 3 other main girls, but they are not love interests per se, they are essentially prostitutes that are competing in a brothel for money.
The brothel is the main part of the story, so if you are not comfortable with that kind of story, then this game ain't for you.

There are also flashback scenes of the MC's mother who did porn in order to make money to raise him, but I do not think she will get any sex scenes in present time, so no "ntr" there either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grufix, Mythrs, TD1900 and 1 other person
T

Tyson Mikel

Member
Sep 16, 2023
114
229
Phase_01 said:
This game is not vanilla, neither is it NTR (it can be considered Netori, which is NOT ntr, since the MC is not the one being cucked)

The game has what I would call 2 real Love Interests, that don't have ntr
There are also 3 other main girls, but they are not love interests per se, they are essentially prostitutes that are competing in a brothel for money.
The brothel is the main part of the story, so if you are not comfortable with that kind of story, then this game ain't for you.

There are also flashback scenes of the MC's mother who did porn in order to make money to raise him, but I do not think she will get any sex scenes in present time, so no "ntr" there either.
Click to expand...
Thanks that's all I have to know, and I'm fine with that I have play worst, so it's doesn't bother me much, one more question how is MC personality? I hope not like "I see hole I will goal".
 
Phase_01

Phase_01

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2021
1,173
1,896
Tyson Mikel said:
Thanks that's all I have to know, and I'm fine with that I have play worst, so it's doesn't bother me much, one more question how is MC personality? I hope not like "I see hole I will goal".
Click to expand...
His personality changes based on the options you choose and the path you choose to take
But for the most part he's a very quiet, calculative character, and can sometimes bring out a sense of sadism depending on the scene.
The game takes an almost philosophical approach to the narrative and for the MC's internal monologue, its not like your usual "porn" game that's just see girl and fuck (though the beginning of the game does give the option for a quick sex scene when meeting up with MC's best friend and 2 girls)
 
  • Like
Reactions: LeoYoung, Mythrs, TD1900 and 4 others
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.90 star(s) 471 Votes