VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[ffive]

MC isn't gonna fuck his mom, the devs made that clear

Also given how ridiculously toxic Killian's mom is I fear Edwin's dick might decay and fall off the moment it gets anywhere near her

Ehh, if it didn't shrivel and fall off after getting into Kat, it should be fine. It's clearly a legendary class artifact.

 

[sunaboz]

BTW, Elias' kids go to St. Ives so things might get really awkward during parent-teacher meetings especially if Lucy would be a homeroom teacher of one of them. I'm guessing she would prefer Felicia than Elias to attend it (or maybe not, maybe she would like to have sex with him at school after her coming out as a nympho).

Then again the school might be big enough that he might not know who she is yet (he met her after all with senator Shelby and hasn't commented it at all so either TD forgot that part or he assumed that Elias doesn't know/doesn't care).

 

[dolfe67]

Yeah, that's what i meant. For Mina hangout to become available Edwin has to spend time with her and show that he "gets her" by doing the PDA she's hinting at. And not be another girl's boyfriend, obv.

For those who, like myself, didn't know what PDA means, it means Public Display of Affection (when MC kiss Mina in the audience during the concert)

BTW, Elias' kids go to St. Ives so things might get really awkward during parent-teacher meetings especially if Lucy would be a homeroom teacher of one of them. I'm guessing she would prefer Felicia than Elias to attend it (or maybe not, maybe she would like to have sex with him at school after her coming out as a nympho).

Then again the school might be big enough that he might not know who she is yet (he met her after all with senator Shelby and hasn't commented it at all so either TD forgot that part or he assumed that Elias doesn't know/doesn't care).

Do you think he attends parent-teacher meetings himself and not just send the mother alone?

 

[sunaboz]

Do you think he attends parent-teacher meetings himself and not just send the mother alone?

Their mother is dead and Felicia is just a step-mother. He probably does attend it from time to time, although who knows, we don't have enough data.

 

[dolfe67]

Their mother is dead and Felicia is just a step-mother. He probably does attend it from time to time, although who knows, we don't have enough data.

Not the mother then but the nanny or something. I doubt he's the one going, I believe more that Felicia would go.

 

[Leinad_Sevla]

There's a Mina scene, after Edwin has breakfast with the mom, you can go to Mina or Hana or in my case neither

I remember now, that´s what happened. After Sophia´s visit, I could choose Hana if I was on her GF path or Mina, but those options were greyed out for me, so I had to go to the club directly.

So many people expect to get Mina scene and are absolutely convinced there just wasn't one, when they didn't have the basic courtesy not to treat her like some second-string afterthought, smh.

That is absolutely the developers fault. They put Mina and Hana in front of us and expect us to choose? In what world?

Because he didn't look at the game gallery

 

[Hiarus]

That is absolutely the developers fault. They put Mina and Hana in front of us and expect us to choose? In what world?

We're getting a option for a poly relationship with both of them, trust

 

[hitman2511]

We're getting a option for a poly relationship with both of them, trust

 

[jasonhxzy]

I lost my save file and replaying. Does the latest update have scenes with the mc mother? I loved the flashbacks last update of her

 

[Halsy]

I wish there were more Mina scenes
She brings light to this very dark game

 

[dolfe67]

I wish there were more Mina scenes
She brings light to this very dark game

Me too
I want to turn off her light

 

[Discrepancy]

I lost my save file and replaying. Does the latest update have scenes with the mc mother? I loved the flashbacks last update of her

Yes, it's actually the first scene of the update, the continuation of the mom tape.

 

[Halsy]

Me too
I want to turn off her light

You monster

 

[claimant32]

So as some of you know MrBubu has had to slow down on making WTs and close his patreon which is a shame because his were the best in the game. Now I am no MrBubu but I did create a flowchart style WT for the latest update if any of you are searching for ways to unlock various scenes or implications of different choices. As noted this was just for fun so if you don't like it then don't use it. But I hope at least a few people find it useful! (Someone pointed out a few typos, updated)

 

[ename144]

If he didn't spend time with Mina last update I don't see why he would deserve a Mina scene in this one .

To be fair, Mina's scene in this update requires not just spending time with Mina, but spending it in vary specific way. I'm still not sure I like the jealousy flag being necessary; I get the idea, but it feels like there should be some alternatives or at least some slightly more robust feedback for those not peeking behind the scenes.

We're getting a option for a poly relationship with both of them, trust

Something can potentially happen, that seems clear, but I'm not sure it will be a lasting setup. We'll see how things develop.

Now that you mention it, though, this makes me think. I'm working on a new save path that focuses on dating Mina after initially turning her down, and I've been trying to figure out what will happen with Ian in this setup. But speaking of poly relationships, I wonder if there's a possibility of setting up a throuple with Mina and Ian if we jump through the right hoops. Sure, it feels like a stretch, but then again it would tie in with the Marlow story. And those Mina/Killian Romance points have to do something eventually, right?

It would probably be the least popular ending by a country mile, but it would definitely be funny!

 

[Hiarus]

Now that you mention it, though, this makes me think. I'm working on a new save path that focuses on dating Mina after initially turning her down, and I've been trying to figure out what will happen with Ian in this setup.

All my saves to date have been focused on Mina instead of Hana because I'm one of those people that always dates the same LI in every replay, so I can't point out the differences between routes buuuut tbh, I think Mina and Killian breaking up fits a introspective Killian perfectly, 'cause it's like a catalyst to get him to want to change his behavior

'course, you can still get that if you decide you don't wanna bone her but still make it a point to break them up

Also we haven't had the pay off of Ian finding out we are dating his ex yet, but I am also genuinely curious what's gonna happen, because a party boy Killian seems far more likely to just brush it off compared to a introspective one, even though you are generally a better friend to the introspective one, there's some interesting drama here.

Lastly, leaving Killian aside and going on my own little schizo rant...giving this is your first time going that route; you'll find that Mina & Edwin are more similar than it seems, both are so invested in a act that it has become their personality, to a point where they are disassociating from everything going on

 

[Ottoeight]

All my saves to date have been focused on Mina instead of Hana because I'm one of those people that always dates the same LI in every replay, so I can't point out the differences between routes buuuut tbh, I think Mina and Killian breaking up fits a introspective Killian perfectly, 'cause it's like a catalyst to get him to want to change his behavior

'course, you can still get that if you decide you don't wanna bone her but still make it a point to break them up

Also we haven't had the pay off of Ian finding out we are dating his ex yet, but I am also genuinely curious what's gonna happen, because a party boy Killian seems far more likely to just brush it off compared to a introspective one, even though you are generally a better friend to the introspective one, there's some interesting drama here.

Lastly, leaving Killian aside and going on my own little schizo rant...giving this is your first time going that route; you'll find that Mina & Edwin are more similar than it seems, both are so invested in a act that it has become their personality, to a point where they are disassociating from everything going on

Nope. Not in least.

They always break up. Killian becomes "introspective Ian" ONLY IF AND WHEN you raise his bro points AND trigger a single key choice. Only IF you as Edwin decide it.

How Edwin interacts with the LIs has zero effect towards Ian.

And let me tell you that if you play a single route only, you will never be able to enjoy and, mostly, understand the story and its characters.

 

[Hiarus]

And let me tell you that if you play a single route only, you will never be able to enjoy and, mostly, understand the story and its characters.

Not necessarily, a lot of the choices in this game aren't really locked behind who you're romantically interested in, at least when it comes to Mina, I know Hana route keeps track of cheating

I still did all the available content for the carnations for example, rewinding saves if need be, only thing I'm really missing on is the exclusive Hana GF content

Edit: also I should make clear that I don't consider any of the carnations as love interests the same Mina and Hana are

 

[Ottoeight]

Not necessarily, a lot of the choices in this game aren't really locked behind who you're romantically interested in

I still did all the available content for the carnations for example, rewinding saves if need be, only thing I'm really missing on is the exclusive Hana GF content

You misinterpreted me.

In my opinion, going down Kath's sadistic rabbit hole IS a route per se, even though she is NOT a LI.

Raising/not raising bro Ian's bro points are 2 different routes.

Deciding which Carnation Edwin wants to win the exhbition are different routes.

There are tons of routes.

 

[Hiarus]

You misinterpreted me.

In my opinion, going down Kath's sadistic rabbit hole IS a route per se, even though she is NOT a LI.

Raising/not raising bro Ian's bro points are 2 different routes.

Deciding which Carnation Edwin wants to win the exhbition are different routes.

There are tons of routes.

Ah I see, then we are talking about completely different things

When I say route, I am exclusively talking about who Edwin is in a more formal relationship with, just that

I assure you I still did a lot of the content outside that, and if I missed any it was either a byproduct of me getting the result I wanted or simply not getting around to it (like keeping Ian on the playboy route)