VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Discrepancy]

idk if it's the lastest update cause i download the Android section and i played up to Vicky about to tell Edwin about her past and it end the game after Hana tell Mina she's Edwin GF...that's why im asking if it's possible to be in relationship with both cause it feels bad to see Mina got sad like that

There's one more update, maybe not for android yet?
So you're on Hana GF path and still fooled around with Mina after that? I thought that wasn't possible

 

[Rem is the best]

There's one more update, maybe not for android yet?
So you're on Hana GF path and still fooled around with Mina after that? I thought that wasn't possible

yeah cause i see Mina had Bi point so i thought if her Bi point is high enough she will accept to be in a poly relationship (as GF not FB) with Hana and somehow Hana will accept that since she seem to like Mina alot

 

[Discrepancy]

yeah cause i see Mina had Bi point so i thought if her Bi point is high enough she will accept to be in a poly relationship (as GF not FB) with Hana and somehow Hana will accept that since she seem to like Mina alot

If you cheated on Hana I doubt your Edwin will have a relationship with her in the future and even less with both
With all this said I tried Hana GF on my first playthrough, but then Mina rejected me when I met her next time, don't really remember the details was a long time ago, I just went back on a save file and chose Hana fuck buddy, and once again I really think it's the right choice if you want to be with both.

 

[Rem is the best]

If you cheated on Hana I doubt your Edwin will have a relationship with her in the future and even less with both
With all this said I tried Hana GF on my first playthrough, but then Mina rejected me when I met her next time, don't really remember the details was a long time ago, I just went back on a save file and chose Hana fuck buddy, and once again I really think it's the right choice if you want to be with both.

could be the devs changed it? cause after i chose Hana GF and meet Mina at the coffe shop later...you can choose to tell her about new relationship with Hana or hide it...if you hide it you both will go to a hotel and have some fun time there

but yeah unfortunate it's a choice matter game where your action had consequence so ig we can't be with both as BF GF...unless the Dev decide to let us swing that way in the future
i literally skip all the other girl excepted Mina cause i have hope they will let us be in relationship with both H/M

 

[Discrepancy]

could be the devs changed it? cause after i chose Hana GF and meet Mina at the coffe shop later...you can choose to tell her about new relationship with Hana or hide it...if you hide it you both will go to a hotel and have some fun time there

but yeah unfortunate it's a choice matter game where your action had consequence so ig we can't be with both as BF GF...unless the Dev decide to let us swing that way in the future
i literally skip all the other girl excepted Mina cause i have hope they will let us be in relationship with both H/M

Ah, I probably told her. But yeah when I chose the GF option for Hana at the time in my mind was always to be truthful to Mina, so if that choice came I told her and she rejected me, I don't remember that step but it was probably it.
So yeah choices will have consequences, and remember Hana's dad is a Gangster, cheating on her is probably not wise

 

[Rem is the best]

Ah, I probably told her. But yeah when I chose the GF option for Hana at the time in my mind was always to be truthful to Mina, so if that choice came I told her and she rejected me, I don't remember that step but it was probably it.
So yeah choices will have consequences, and remember Hana's dad is a Gangster, cheating on her is probably not wise

Man they really got me with the picture H/M hugging each other in the intro....i thought i can get both as GF

 

[hitman2511]

Man they really got me with the picture H/M hugging each other in the intro....i thought i can get both as GF

Don't give your hopes up nobody knows for sure. All we know is that they want to talk about this throuple thing in the coming days.

 

[Rem is the best]

Don't give your hopes up nobody knows for sure. All we know is that they want to talk about this throuple thing in the coming days.

i really hope they will let us get both honestly.... having a Goth GF is nice but it feels bad to cheated on her or have to broke the cutie heart (i limited myself as much as i can by doing it with just Mina and no other girl cause i just want those two)

does anyone know how far are we from ending? cause i saw this game a long time ago but see it didn't have much chapter yet so i wait then just completely forgot about it until now

 

[hitman2511]

i really hope they will let us get both honestly.... having a Goth GF is nice but it feels bad to cheated on her or have to broke the cutie heart (i limited myself as much as i can by doing it with just Mina and no other girl cause i just want those two)

does anyone know how far are we from ending? cause i saw this game a long time ago but see it didn't have much chapter yet so i wait then just completely forgot about it until now

One ingame week is left.

 

[Rem is the best]

One ingame week is left.

oh cool...yeah im just trying to find those post about H/M relationship atm

 

[Rem is the best]

But yeah i really REALLY hope they will let us have a poly with both H/M

I got my hope up after i see the scene with Felicia and Mina (i do know the different between Felicia and Hana since Mina been knowing Felicia for a longgg time) but i think Mina will be fine with Hana as well if she know her well enough

 

[soemantri9]

holee 13gb....compressed pls

 

[torresm]

holee 13gb....compressed pls

Try searching the thread, it's been posted already.

 

[helo138]

One ingame week is left.

1 ingame week ~ 5 real life years

 

[Turret]

Damn Sophia and her drugs. Damn the evil side chick.

You will see one day that Sophia gives the world a new energy drink and Super-Viagra. And she is simply pragmatic when she gives the club her "fun stuff", it furthers her plans for the club and ingratiates. As Sophia correctly observed, the VIP club members would be decadent and behaving like animals with and without her inventions. So you gain at least additional testing info by supplying them the Viagra plus.

You really like to antagonize Turret don't you?

He tries, but he doesn´t succeed. He is so over the top with his hate for Sophia that I can´t take it seriously. Still so, I will enjoy the Sophia arc as it unfolds, knowing it is driving Darreau nuts that she is one of the most important characters in the game now.
As I mentioned many times before, there should be an ending with those two nerdy eccentrics together and a little Sophia/Edwin running around them. I hope such an ending will come.

 

[Rem is the best]

Mina showing sign of jealousy is balanced by the kiss scene. She literally admits that she doesn't know if she was more jealous of Edwin or Hana. Wouldn't be the best way to resolve said jealousy to date both of them at the same time ?


On the contrary I think the very existence of a previous instance means that there is a chance of getting a throuple in the end. For my arguments about that, refer to my previous message. A previously failed attempt set a precedent, and pave the way to a second attempt, but with different circumstances and characters to prevent the failure this time.


Refer to my answer above. I still don't understand why a throuple ending would be a bad one. You seem to think that the concept of a throuple means being a jerk or completely corrupted, which I don't understand. Again, the possibility of a Mina/Hana/Edwin throuple would most likely depends on variables and choices with Mina and Hana. I don't see why it should be a bad ending.

As for jealousy, it could be part of the process. There is jealousy now, but Mina offered a solution to this jealousy. If the three of them are together, then there's no reason to be jealous anymore as long as they all learn to share their time equally. Also there's a great way for it to last: by ending the game. We're probably not gonna follow up for decades after the story. Just give the players a throuple ending, and then the end. Let the player choose if it lasts or not, who cares, the game will be over anyway. I'll make it last a century, don't worry about that.


Hana didn't want to fuck Edwin at the beginning of the game either. Characters evolve, relationships evolve. Hana might accept an "exclusive" throuple, where she doesn't want Mina and Edwin fucking other people. It is consistant with all the characters. Mina is attracted to both, Hana is attracted to both, Edwin is attracted to both. They all like each other (given the right choices of course), so why not long-term stuff ? Because you guys decided a throuple can't ever work for some reason ? Well, I think it's possible, and even likely.

And I will die on that hill, damn it.

We will die on this hill together

 

[Discrepancy]

We will die on this hill together

Don't want to reignite the throuple discussion, but if a throuple will happen in the future/end, I doubt the path for it to happen is being Hana boyfriend and cheating on her with Mina, the path would be fuck buddies with both and then the offical throuple will happen (whatever that even means).

 

[UmbralKnight]

Who's talking about incest? They're mimicking a casting where they'll play the role of the sleazy porn producer trying to bait the soon to be porn actresses (the carnations). Who of the trio plays the nervous newbie the best before they all point their gaped assholes into the camera in the end wins a point. Or something like that. At least that's what I would have done with the scene. Or something like that.

ok but
what did she mean by "Let them believe they're going to have a real audition. They should have realized by now how much our games can creep into their lives"

this is week three of the carnation games so both the girls and the patrons are already fully committed to the act
so what exactly is this new "real audition" for ?
they're all already part of the games and how does this audition tie into their lives ?

the incest thing is just entirely speculative
since we already know that there is going to be no actual content with Victoria and the MC
this is just a unique scenario where all those people who were desperately asking for some Victoria content with the MC can finally get it
and since it's all part of kathleens LARP
It doesn't break any rules (atleast in theory)

The mom role play is already in the game so if patreon wants to drop the ban hammer they already have the excuse even if its flimsy.

well technically in that RP scene with rose

the visuals might show MC and Rose "doing" the act while engaging in some word RP and name calling it's still just MC and Rose doing it and everyone is VERY aware of the LARPy nature of it
It was almost like watching a play

but what i suggested is very VISUALLY different
something we have already had a glimpse once
when rose comes to the MCs appartment to convince him to help her
if they both have sex MC suddenly gets flashes of Victoria having sex during a prono for a few moments in his mind while they're doing it and it even almost stops him from having sex with rose for a while

so if kathleen recreates one of Vicky's old pornos with MC and Rose
it's only going to trigger all those repressed memories even further
and if Kathleen drugs the MC or maybe dresses up rose to look "visually" look like victoria
it would all still be an elaborate make believe LARP

so in this scenario even if MC has "sex" with this lookalike victoria and the entire scene was visually shown them doing it

it shouldn't in theory break any rules since
it's just a "fake" victoria (rose) having sex with the MC
and that's why I said it would be like that scene from tropic thunder
"a dude playing a dude who is another dude"

so even though it's not technically "incest"
this should satisfy all those people who desperately keep asking for scenes with Victoria and MC

plus it could be a good learning moment for the MC to show
the fact that Kathleen loves to mess around the personal past lives of not only the carnations but him too

One ingame week is left.

it's kind of weird that so much has happened yet in the Ingame universe it's not even a month yet since MC joined the club and he is still a pre med who still hasn't even completed his exams yet
epilogue time skip must be crazy trying to compress years worth of content flash forwarded and condensed into a few frames and slides

 

[Rem is the best]

Don't want to reignite the throuple discussion, but if a throuple will happen in the future/end, I doubt the path for it to happen is being Hana boyfriend and cheating on her with Mina, the path would be fuck buddies with both and then the offical throuple will happen (whatever that even means).

After i readed the discussion i think its pointless to argue so imma just say
I had my own opinion and You had your own opinion and i respected it
Just wait to see how the story goes

 

[slightchance]

what did she mean by "Let them believe they're going to have a real audition. They should have realized by now how much our games can creep into their lives"

When I see a preview I put my own spin on it. For fun. That's all there is to it. What ends up in the game is usually more tame, especially since the previews don't show any plot twists. Victoria's audition tape doesn't come up here. I've put it in there for cheap laughs.